

Is "saving" Melina with the Frenzied Flame cure actually worse than letting her burn?
Setting up my main save and thinking about the Forge of the Giants from a lore standpoint.
A lot of players take the Frenzied Flame, burn the Erdtree themselves to spare Melina, and then cleanse it with Miquella’s Needle to do Age of Stars or Perfect Order. On paper, it feels like the big galaxy-brain move where nobody dies.
But lore-wise, isn't "saving" her actually a way worse fate?
1.She’s already burned and bodiless: She doesn't have a mortal body to return to. Keeping her alive just leaves her as a wandering spirit with no physical life.
2.It robs her of her agency: At the Mountaintops, she explicitly tells you this sacrifice has become her chosen will, not just her mother's orders ("My heart is set. Do not worry about me."). Stealing the flame completely overrules the one choice she actually makes for herself.
3.She's left in limbo: She leaves you in hatred, believing you doomed the world, and even if you cure the flame, she never finds out. She’s just left alone with no purpose and no rest.
Is letting her kindle the flame the only real closure she gets, or is there an actual lore argument for sparing her? Curious how you guys view