I Know I am Gonna Get Hate for This, But I'll Say it Anyway...
With all the girls we have had in this manga till date, I was always able to find some redeeming quality in them (in terms of the entertainment they provide in the series) despite how disliked they were initially, including Chiyo and Suu. A large part of it is that Nakamura managed to make every girlfriend interesting with something unique no other girls at the time had which made them their own unique characters, like Chiyo's young but responsible and Suu's autistic number girl gimmick. Unfortunately, for the first time I don't feel the same way with the newest girlfriend Fushida Rana.
My main complaint is that her entire personality feels a mix and mash of all the tropes we already have with the previous girlfriends and somehow it feels that she is worse than the other girlfriends at these already existing tropes. These comparisons make me ponder why do we even have her when there are already girlfriends who embody her tropes better than she does. Let me give examples to illustrate my point -
- Middle School Class Prez - Chiyo does it better committing more to being prim and proper and her 'rrgh' expression
- Competitive Rivalry and Sore Loser Attitude - Saki does it better with her girlfailure character as she cries and loses constantly to her junior Matsuri
- Busty Middle Schooler - Nemu is a busty middle schooler in her own right with added cute points and Meme is even bustier than Rana with her added vanishing gimmick when she is embarrassed
- Insecure and Shy about Her Body - Again, I believe Meme does it better
The only kind of unique things she has are her kinda sad backstory of being harrassed for her well-developed body and her calling out and being flustered about 'vulgar' things but honestly, these are not very interesting tropes in themselves comparing with what other girls can offer in the series and on top of it, her character design is not even that special. Hope Nakamura proves me wrong by adding some interesting facets to her character just like he did with Meme's erotic fantasies and Uto getting flustered and also adds a lot of interesting interactions with other girls to flesh out her character better as it is too early to judge. But for now, I can't help but feel that Nakamura kinda dropped the ball for this girlfriend by recycling the tropes we already have in previous girlfriends making her feel less special as compared to other girlfriends who are much more unique.