u/TurkeyLeg68

What if in an alternate timeline, instead of a platformer/fighting game, Super Smash Brothers was instead a traditional fighting game, focusing on it's playable fighters and archetypes?

RULES
- Can only include characters that existed up until 1998 (1997 for New IPs)
- No Third Party Characters (For now...)
- Try to be unique, and not produce the same roster as canon
- If you want to include a specific character, also comment what their archetype would be between Average, Tank/Grappler, Zoner, Rushdown, Trapper or Special.
- If a tie happens between 2 or more characters, I'll spin a wheel to decide who wins.

So, what are you waiting for? The comment with the most upvotes will have their character be the first in the clash. Have fun everyone!

List of Fighters
01 - Mario
02 - Link
03 - Donkey Kong

What if in an alternate timeline, instead of a platformer/fighting game, Super Smash Brothers was instead a traditional fighting game, focusing on it's playable fighters and archetypes?

RULES
- Can only include characters that existed up until 1998 (1997 for New IPs)
- No Third Party Characters (For now...)
- Try to be unique, and not produce the same roster as canon
- If you want to include a specific character, also comment what their archetype would be between Average, Tank/Grappler, Zoner, Rushdown, Trapper or Special.
- If a tie happens between 2 or more characters, I'll spin a wheel to decide who wins.

So, what are you waiting for? The comment with the most upvotes will have their character be the first in the clash. Have fun everyone!

List of Fighters
01 - Mario
02 - Link

What if in an alternate timeline, instead of a platformer/fighting game, Super Smash Brothers was instead a traditional fighting game, focusing on it's playable fighters and archetypes?

RULES
- Can only include characters that existed up until 1998 (1997 for New IPs)
- No Third Party Characters (For now...)
- Try to be unique, and not produce the same roster as canon
- If you want to include a specific character, also comment what their archetype would be between Average, Tank/Grappler, Zoner, Rushdown, Trapper or Special.

So, what are you waiting for? The comment with the most upvotes will have their character be the first in the clash. Have fun everyone!

List of Fighters
01 - Mario

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi
09: Kururin
10: Bowser
11: Villager
12: Luigi
13: Princess Zelda
14: Princess Peach
15: Isaac
16: Wario
17: Marth
18: Captain Falcon
19: Metang
20: Sami
21: Meta Knight
22: Ganondorf
23: Ness
24: Hector
25: Mr. Game & Watch

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi
09: Kururin
10: Bowser
11: Villager
12: Luigi
13: Princess Zelda
14: Princess Peach
15: Isaac
16: Wario
17: Marth
18: Captain Falcon
19: Metang

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi
09: Kururin
10: Bowser
11: Villager
12: Luigi
13: Princess Zelda
14: Princess Peach
15: Isaac

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi
09: Kururin
10: Bowser
11: Villager
12: Luigi
13: Princess Zelda

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi
09: Kururin
10: Bowser
11: Villager
12: Luigi

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi
09: Kururin

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran
06: Pikachu
07: Fox McCloud
08: Yoshi

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong
04: Kirby
05: Samus Aran

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link
03: Donkey Kong

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

List of Playable Fighters
01: Mario
02: Link

Many Smash fans have went on an endless debate on what the roster of a DS entry to the Super Smash Bros. series could've looked like, so now, I've decided to ask YOU, the users, what the roster would look like, if the DS had a Super Smash Brothers entry. But before we start, there are some rules...

RULES
1 - This game releases on June 25th, 2006. You can only use characters who existed up until 2004.
2 - You can still request third party characters, but given that this was before Brawl released, I'd limit the amount of third parties to just 2.
3 - Characters like Pokémon Trainer, Olimar, or any other character that needs a lot of coding in, will not count, as the DS would've been pushed to it's limitations with the 30 character roster.
4 - If a tie happens, I'll make a wheel randomizer for the 2+ characters, and whichever character is landed on, will be added.
5 - Try to be as realistic as you can be.

Anyways, whichever comment has the most upvotes will have their character be one of thirty playable fighters within the Clash.

And with that, this series has came to an end (At least, If I don't remember this once Smash 6 rolls around, or if It never happens)

Thank you all so much are sticking around on this goofy little series I've made, and thank you all that made suggestions.

We've come a long way...

Anyways, see you next time!

RULES
- Must've made their debut before January 28th, 2020
- Have Fun!

Base Game Newcomers
Inkling
Alucard
King K. Rool
Tails
Decidueye
Bayonetta

Fighters Pass 1
Joker
Travis Touchdown
Toxtricity
Chun-Li
???
???

Fighter Pass 2
???
???
???
???
???
???

So, go ahead and comment any character you desire. The comment with the most upvotes will have their character join the Ultimate Battle.

8 Slots Remaining!

RULES
- Must've made their debut before December 7th, 2018
- Have Fun!

Base Game Newcomers
???
???
???
???
???
???

Fighters Pass 1
???
???
???
???
???
???

Fighter Pass 2
???
???
???
???
???
???

So, go ahead and comment any character you desire. The comment with the most upvotes will have their character join the Ultimate Battle.

RULES (Read before commenting)
- Character must've debut before February 3rd, 2016
- Be realistic, and try to not make this a near one-by-one identical selection
- Have fun

Cuts from Melee to Brawl (Two more can be brought back through DLC)
Raichu
Glass Joe
Black Shadow
Heracross (Playable)
Leif

Cuts from Brawl to Smash 4 (One can be brought back through DLC)
Mudkip
Grovyle
Birdo
Lucas
Snake
Ayumi Tachinaba

List of Newcomers for Smash 4
Villager
Dillon
Bandana Waddle Dee
Lucina
Shulk
Mega Man
Haxorus
Pac-Man
Palutena
Ridley
Rosalina
Ashley
Duck Hunt Duo
Isaac
Mii's (Brawler/Swordfighter/Gunner)
Ryu (DLC)
Terra (DLC)

Comment anyone you desire that fits under the criteria rules. The comment with the most upvotes will have their character be part of this alternate smash.

RULES (Read before commenting)
- Character must've debut before February 3rd, 2016
- Be realistic, and try to not make this a near one-by-one identical selection
- Have fun

Cuts from Melee to Brawl (Two can be brought back through DLC)
Raichu
Glass Joe
Black Shadow
Heracross (Playable)
Leif

Cuts from Brawl to Smash 4 (One can be brought back through DLC)
Mudkip
Grovyle
Birdo
Lucas
Snake
Ayumi Tachinaba

List of Newcomers for Smash 4
Villager
Dillon
Bandana Waddle Dee
Lucina
Shulk
Mega Man
Haxorus
Pac-Man
Palutena
Ridley
Rosalina
Ashley
Duck Hunt Duo
Isaac
Mii's (Brawler/Swordfighter/Gunner)

Comment anyone you desire that fits under the criteria rules. The comment with the most upvotes will have their character be part of this alternate smash.

RULES (Read before commenting)
- Character must've debut before September 13th, 2014
- Must include exactly 2 New Third Party characters
- Be realistic, and try to not make this a near one-by-one identical selection
- Have fun

Cuts from Melee to Brawl
Raichu
Glass Joe
Black Shadow
Heracross (Playable)
Leif

Cuts from Brawl to Smash 4
Mudkip
Grovyle
Birdo
Lucas
Snake
Ayumi Tachinaba

List of Newcomers for Smash 4
Villager
Dillon
Bandana Waddle Dee
Lucina
Shulk
Mega Man
Haxorus
Pac-Man
Palutena
Ridley
Rosalina
Ashley
Duck Hunt Duo
Isaac

Comment anyone you desire that fits under the criteria rules. The comment with the most upvotes will have their character be part of this alternate smash.