Miata RF vs Shelby GT350 - Which delivers the better raw driving experience?
I'm moving back to the Dallas/Las Colinas area this July after spending the past two years working abroad, and I'm finally in a position to buy a weekend/fun car. I've narrowed it down to two cars that couldn't be more different: a brand new Mazda Miata RF and a low-mileage Shelby GT350.
On paper this seems like a ridiculous comparison, but what matters most to me is the quality of the driving experience rather than outright performance.
A little about me:
- Early 40s
- Have owned sports cars before
- I enjoy driving for the sake of driving, not drag racing or chasing lap times
- I prefer manual transmissions and cars that feel mechanical and engaging
- I plan to explore the Texas Hill Country on weekends and maybe do the occasional track day, but 95% of the driving will be on public roads
The Miata RF appeals to me because:
- Lightweight and incredibly communicative
- Seems like a car you can enjoy at sane speeds
- Lower ownership costs
- Brand new with a warranty
- Around $43k
The GT350 appeals to me because:
- That incredible Voodoo flat-plane crank V8
- One of the best sounding modern performance cars ever made
- Tremec manual
- More practical for road trips
- It just feels like a special occasion every time you start it
My concerns:
- The Miata's lack of storage space and lower power. Am I going to wish it had another 150 hp after the honeymoon period?
- The GT350's purchase price ($60-70k+), higher maintenance costs, and buying a used high-performance car that may have seen track use.
For those who have owned or driven both, which one left the bigger impression after the novelty wore off?
If you could only own one for the next 5-10 years, would you rather have the pure, lightweight precision of the Miata or the drama and soundtrack of the GT350?
I'd especially appreciate opinions from people who've spent significant time with both cars rather than just test driving them.