u/chaneldebt

I enjoy it for the fan service by bringing back many of our favorite characters, but that is it.

Rewatching S1-7 and I was hooked every season. Maybe I'm bias because AHS is one of my favorite series, but they were all 10/10!

Some better than others, but none were bad.

Season 8 is where the ball drops. Michael is so stupid at times it hurts.

The two lab geeks talking through Robot Mead to convince him of the nuclear idea???

He initially wasn't thinking that big. he was a teenage killer with no purpose behind it

Half of his decisions were influenced by terrible parental figures, rich idiots, warlocks, and a lot of delusional satanists.

—————————————-
Then, in the end, everything is retcon meaning the whole season is basically a dream.

Everything in Murder House episode never happens so Moira and Harmon family are still suffering.

Voodoo Queen is still stuck in Hell.

Queenie never goes to Hotel Cortez so how does that affect the plot in Season 5 since her blood revitalizes Romona who was nearly dead?

No Myrtle or Madison. Misty's return at the end was silly, even though she is one of my favorites.

I still enjoy the season, but it’s also like … that’s it???

Even Ben saying “he impregnated my wife” like no, he raped her. Why is nobody calling it what it was?

That was not the house influence. He did that to help Mrs. Montgomery and he was a mass murderer as a human!

It's such a cop out!

He offered the cop a million dollars to work for him which is equivalent to about 12 million today so is he suppose to be from an ultra rich family??? I knew they had money, but now I’m thinking they were extremely wealthy.

Twisty the Clown probably thought this family is more f’d up than I am when the mom asked him to meet Dandy grown self 😂😂😂

The fact that he didn’t kill them on sight really spoke volumes

Why did I completely forget about Cordelia's husband being some cheating bastard serial killer. I’m only Episode 4 when he kills the girl in the hotel … but damn I forgot all about this plot (can’t wait to watch the backstory)

I was actually rooting for their marriage and figuring out their fertility issues. AHS really outdoes itself with the plot twists

Rewatching in my 20's is so much better considering I originally watch this show when I was 12 LOL

Season 1 was always one of my favorites, but Season 2 might've topped it.

I can't wait to start Coven since I don't remember much except it being iconic.

Soon as I finish Murder House, I always want to skip to Coven, but I promise myself I would rewatch in order this time.

The psychologist being the serial killer always shocks me everytime. I never remember this plot and it is such a good twist!

I’m trying to rank all the seasons before Season 13 release, but 1 and 2 are neck and neck.

I just rewatched and binged Season 1 in a day. One question that's really bothering me… Vivien stopped Ben from committing suicide because she wants him to raise the baby.

So why didn't she intervene when Hayden came to kill him? Where was she?

She was watching him like a hawk previously so it made no sense.

So glad I started my rewatch from Season 1. This will always be one of my favorite seasons.

Is Larry alive? I’m only on Episode 3 where he kills Hayden. I don’t know if they give his backstory again in another episode.

I find it hard to believe he was “released” from prison, if he was ever in prison at all.

Also, if Rubberman is Tate. Does he just kill every new residence?? How is he able to do so much as a ghost?! The rest of the ghost just get therapy sessions and do nothing… so far

I hope they give an explanation for him attacking the gay couple.

(and yes, I’ve seen this season 3+ times, I just always forget certain details so spoilers are fine)

Please share your thoughts.

• Q's death was devastating. He was my favorite addition to the cast.

• Brooke's attack was heartbreaking. Those scenes with her bruised were hard to watch.

• Jamie and Dan's bond was so sweet. “you’re my bestfriend.”

• NATHAN MADE THE NBA I ACTUALLY CRIED AT THIS SCENE I WAS SO GEEKED

• Peyton's wedding dress was gorgeous.

• I love Brooke and Peyton's friendship again. Their scene before Peyton's wedding was so beautiful.

• Dan is very entertaining to watch. It is hard to hate him.

• Sam grew on me. Her and Victoria's bond made sense. I wish she chose Brooke over her birth mom.

• I was rooting for Mouth and Millie before the Owen thing. They bore me now.

• Brooke's character development is so well-written. She will always be my favorite character.

• 50/50 about Julian.

• “Sawyer” as a name for Peyton's baby annoys me. Anna Elizabeth is better.

• Victoria becoming a better mom to Brooke. Their last conversation made me so emotional.

• Hopefully, S 7-9 doesn't ruin anything. Season 6 ends perfectly to the point I could happily stop watching here.

I'm just starting on Episode 3 and the vibe of this season is so much darker than the predecessors.

Brooke's beating and robbery was so heartbreaking. Watching her cope without her friends after is hard to watch.

Dan being hit by the car, then crazy Nanny Carrie is back??? I thought her arc was finished. I guess you can say it's his karma. However, that hit was brutal… plus all the kidnapping and torture.

Now Q 💔💔❤️ he was my FAVORITE new cast member. I'm so sad. Knowing Jamie was making him a cape the same night I could cry

I'm assuming it gets worse?

I hope their friendship stays strong until the end of the series. I just love every scene of them together.

Maybe because they were married in real life, but their on-screen chemistry remains unmatched to me.

I will always wish they were endgame. He's just so much more lively around her. His eyes light up in every scene

also He supports her 100% in everything she does. No matter how crazy it may seem.

I know Peyton and Lucas are fated to be together, but it does get toxic at times. also I haven't seen them bring out eachother's “fun” side (it’s always so serious or broody) maybe my opinion will change …

I’m on S 5 Ep 9 (library ep) I've never been a huge Peyton fan, but seeing her full mean girl side come out with Lindsay is insane!

Her comebacks at times are hilarious, but mostly mean.

Lindsay is actually really likable too. So it sucks

But at the same time, it’s validating (in why she was never my favorite). She kissed Lucas behind Brooke back twice! If they weren't bestfriends, she probably would've went after him sooner.

Then, did the same to Lindsay. and repeatedly keeps reminding her that she doesn't like her or throwing insults.

Telling her about the ring and proposal from 2 years ago though was cruel imo. Yes. lucas is in the wrong, but embarrassing her like that in front of all the girls…

and she just kept going! Dropped a bomb and then kept taunting her, even about her dead dad! It was hard to watch.

I love this episode because we finally got a backstory on how they got to be where they are. Victoria being Brooke's mom was a total shock to me!

Anyways, I’m very proud of Brooke for walking away. Me personally though, I would've folded …

Their chemistry is just so buzzy! As friends or anything else …

So far I’m liking Season 4, I’m just waiting for the inevitable shoe to drop (lindsay seems too good to be true)

I know it’s the early 2000's so a high career in fashion was very possible. Also, Brooke is very determined and came from money. So, I don't doubt it, but do they offer a realistic explanation to how this happened?

I'm only 30 minutes in to Season 5, but everyone else's jobs seem realistic. Hayley, a teacher. Peyton, an assistant to a music executive. Lucas, a struggling writer and coach for basketball. Idk why Skills isn't in the NBA. Also surprised that Mouth is unemployed. Waiting to see what happen to Nathan💔, but so far, that all makes sense.

Brooke, however, I'm shocked by the trajectory of a career. Did she skip college?

Edit: The fuck ass bobs everyone has, including Nathan, is killing me.

Why didn't Nathan explain in his speech that he was under duress??? He didn't mention how winning the championship resulted in his pregnant wife getting hit by a car!

I’m so annoyed by this storyline. His speech was very heartfelt, but if he explained the situation, wouldn’t they have forgiven him?!

Or would it have made it worse?

Mouth is one of my favorite characters. I think he's actually really cute, especially after seeing the episode of him and Nathan dancing at the club.

He's always been outgoing, funny, and likable. I've been a fan since he taught the cheerleaders a new routine. I don't know if this is an unpopular opinion, but Mouth wasn't a typical “geek”. His bestfriends are literally a jock and a cheerleader.

I'm on Season 4 Episode 13 where everyone is paired up to learn more about eachother…