What’s the current consensus on Suikoden Remakes?
Selected flair doesn’t mean discussion has to revolved exclusively around S1.
I’ll say, I’m no authority on this series. I played S2 back in the early 2000s. Rented it multiple times from a Blockbuster shelf, and loved everything about it. Didn’t even realize the game has a save transfer gimmick from its first game until several years later and that gave me the S1 experience, which had a cool story, and gave some much needed story context about the reoccurring characters and wider world, but I enjoyed my time with less. Never played any of the other games in the series though.
S2 is in my JRPG Holy Trinity. I bought the remaster, loved it. I backed Eiyuden Chronicle, and while objectively I think that game was probably a 7, I’d give it at 8 all things considered, and absolutely loved the idea that it existed via crowdfunding. What I am currently, impatiently waiting for now is a Global Star Leap release. All those familiar characters, with these new flashy animations and attacks, battles with modernized gimmicks and system, but still feeling very Suikoden. Between Star Leap and Eiyuden, it really has me looking to the first game, wondering “what could be” if say, they chose to do Remakes of 1&2 that, keep the style and story of the original games, but really ramp up animations and effects of certain rune magic and attacks to feel be even more detailed and intricate.
Where are you guys at on this? Are the remasters enough? Would you prefer 3-5 get some love? Do you just want 6 at this point? Idk if I’m in the minority or not but I really do appreciate the sprite-style of the first two games. I remember seeing the change in design for S3 and just not…gravitating to it the same way. The fact that Eiyuden opted to be created in that style is a huge part of why I donated. There’s just something that feels so unique to Suikoden about that style, but it might just be my personal experience.