
(Spoilers Extended) An Obscure ASOIAF YouTuber I Am A Fan Of Thought Of The Soiled Knight Chapter In A Way I Never Thought Of Before
Background
What would you say is objectively the worse chapter of the series? Not counting early chapters where GRRM's Garden was just starting to grow, many would say THE SOILED KNIGHT. Why? for a couple reasons:
- It's mostly relies on Arianne's sexiness to keep you entertained, a clear example of the male gaze in motion.
- Much of the set up occurs near the end and could easily be removed in favor of THE QUEENMAKER near the end.
- It doesn't really advance the plot forward other than explaining the seduction of Arys Oakheart and why Arianne hates her father.
- Aerys Oakheart isn't that interesting and dies immediately after. Hell, Quentyn's chapters have more of a point.
Other than it being written and read with one hand for author and fan alike, it's seemingly superflous.
Or is it?
MykeTheCreator is a YouTuber who is the definition of a hidden gem. Despite his long hiatuses, his content is my favorite among the ASOIAFTuber community. I enjoy how he pays close attention to GRRM's work, the dark and sinister atmosphere of his theories combined with analysis of the themes and symbolism of the books and their historical influences.
He released a video today that made me rethink the purpose of THE SOILED KNIGHT by highlighting power dynamics in feudal society, the connections between Arianne and Criston Cole, a critique and analysis of the Dornish plotline in A FEAST FOR CROWS and how it connects to the upcoming 2nd Dance of the Dragons.
I am not going to spoil it, but I am always willing to give talented creators a shout out so I reccomend you check him out down below.