u/slavatejasu

Question for Jews of a theistic perspective: why isn't Olam Ha-Ba addressed in the Torah or the early Tanakh, especially when death is frequently described as anything but Olam Ha-Ba?

Now, I know that Daniel and Nehemiah frequently discuss both the resurrection and the world to come, but, stemming from an earlier perspective in the Tanakh, there isn't any mention of it essentially whatsoever. The answers I've been able to glean from the tzadikim and various scholars and such seems to be kind of lost: the Torah was revealed in stages so it didn't mention it, the Torah focuses on life so it didn't mention it, the Torah doesn't want to tempt performing the mitzvot with reward in the afterlife because that cheapens the worship of HaShem.

That's all very well and good, but in the Kohelet, in Samuel, in the Torah, you see mention of death. Death is almost singularly described as Sheol, as a place where the voice of HaShem doesn't penetrate, where there are no words of worship to the Lord, where all is gray and black. Either it's a physical place with a spiritual state of existence that's so divorced from consciousness that it might as well be the death of annihilation of consciousness as understood by most atheists, or it is that annihilation exactly. David's and Solomon's laments don't seem to call for hope, and the only calls for salvation from Sheol or praises for salvation from Sheol seem to be calls to save them from death, or praises for having saved them from death, not calls or praises from having saved them from Sheol as the place where every soul ends its journey to by deliverance to another post-mortem existence that is, in fact, an existence of any conscionable and definable sort.

Now, okay, I'm aware that Judaism has a litany of views on the afterlife, most of which inevitably boil down to "this world is more important than the next, and we ought to live a good life for the sake of a good life, whatever comes next is for God to know." I've certainly heard this especially from the reform and conservative sides of things. But I think it's fair to say that especially up until the modern era beginning in the 18th to 19th centuries, and even fairly into now, the normative orthodox view of the afterlife is resurrection as described by the later prophets of messianic proclivities, and as Olam Ha Ba, a place of conscious physical or spiritual existence that's very much an antithesis to the Sheol lemented for in the Kohelet.

I also know that the Mishnah and Talmud mention the Olam Ha Ba with more relative frequency and more relative affirmation than the written Torah does. And yet, I'm still left wondering: why doesn't the early Tanakh speak to Olam Ha Ba when it seems to specifically speak to the state of the body and soul after death as a defined concept which seems to be Sheol, and with no resolution or notable salvation in any form of what we know now as Olam Ha Ba?

I'd be very interested in answers from theistic and more orthodox Jews, and am fairly interested in theistic and non orthodox answers as well. It's a free world so I can't stop anyone being like haha bcs reLIEgion is dUMB and fAKE so I mean comment it if you want but you're annoying if you do. Would appreciate any attempts to tackle the question using extant traditions, source materials, and scholarly musings!

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 5 days ago

So, what are the options for dental?

My mom is on Medicare for several years. She has a severely abcessed and crumbling tooth that needs to be extracted. I know about dental schools and low cost clinics but they charge a couple hundred in my area and my mom is SOL on money and so am I. Any dental plan probably won't kick in for 30-90 days and would deny her for a preexisting condition. What do y'all do if y'all are in this situation?

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 5 days ago

Any recommendations on a mic for recording outdoors?

I'm trying to record a few songs near the ocean for a short concept album with folk songs about the ocean. I'm planning to do a few solo vocals, a few with a guitar and vocals, a few with me and two or three homies doing vocals and maybe a guitar and a melodica played on the lap and some light percussion (small hand drum). I'm also pretty broke so my budget for an appopriate mic is $100 or less, including if I need extra mics for the instruments or other vocalists, and probably but I think not exclusively including the windscreen. I'd love to use a sm57 but it's way too expensive.

Any suggestions on anything more budget friendly? I don't need it to sound clean record quality, I just need it/them to pick everything up. On hand, I have an old Chinese Neewer USB podcast mic I used to use when I was a journalist. I also have some audio editing skills from my journo days, so I could potentially put that to use to bring down jarring loud sounds? Anything that could help me pair that with anything else to get the instruments and vocals would be killer. Doubly so anything that could help me get a vintage sound a la A.L. Lloyd or Alan Lomax without dropping 500 bucks on a vintage RCA Ribbon mic. Would really appreciate the help in making me make some music!!

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 10 days ago

Anyone ever deal with leakage into the front footwell of a 1st Gen (2008)?

I was detailing my mom's car and I pulled up the carpet to find the insulation completely soaked and the footwell with standing water in it. It's been a few days since it rained so I can't find a clear watermark path as to where it's leaking from. Passenger side was far worse than the driver side but driver side was also somewhat damp. Where could I start checking?

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 12 days ago

Are there any good anthologies of Old English music? I'm in particular trying to dig up either a poem or a song about the seas or the shore, fishing, sailing, etc.

I am also very open to songs about meadows or forests. I'm trying to record some and would love any resources if there are any even!!

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 16 days ago

I created a Google Doc to be shared with two other people. I created the link with "Anyone has access" status set to commenter and copied it. I closed the share box and immediately an anonymous viewer shows up before I even shared the link. I reloaded about 15 seconds later, that anonymous user disappeared 5 seconds after the reload and another showed up for about 3-5 minutes.

I do not have any Google Drive pages open in any other tabs, or any other devices, including a quadruple check on my phone. I had not shared the link with anyone who could have opened it by this point. I did not accidentally share the document with anyone else, I'm the only one listed under shared users.

Is this just a weird caching issue causing Docs to think that my current and/or previous session in the same tab was another user? Or should I be concerned?

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 19 days ago
▲ 2 r/Conroe

Hello! I'm trying to carve a staff for my best friend's wedding gift. Any chance anyone has a non rotted branch in their yard that might fit this criteria, or knows where I can look around for one? Don't care much about what type of wood. Ideally need it to be 5 or more feet long. Really appreciate any help or advice!

reddit.com
u/slavatejasu — 22 days ago