u/smoshmademedoit

Hi! So, for context, my gf and I both love Smosh, she's more of a fan of the older stuff but I like the new stuff a bit more. We just watched the new video with Amanda, Chanse, Angela and Olivia playing mermaids and we loved it, but I was distracted by Olivia's participation. I felt like if she's not going in the water and playing with them, why did production choose to have her there? At some points, it just kinda felt like she was the mercuck which isn't bad but it felt kinda awkward.

I read on some YT comments that maybe she can't swim but if that's true, why not get another one of the cast members that can swim to be in the video? Kinda seems like a missed opportunity to amp up the content in the video. Any insight? I'm just a curious gal.

EDIT: to the mod/s that deleted comments that were just showing a difference of opinion, yet left rude comments asking me why my post matters: you're whats wrong with Reddit. Sharing opinions respectfully, regardless of whatever it is, is what Reddit is about. For a sub that claims to be a "free space", this is disappointing and just condones silencing people with different but valid opinions. Not all comedians are everyone's cup of tea, and not every Smosh fan likes every cast member. Grow up.