THE ULTIMATE NANCY DREW GAMES TIER RANKINGS: FINAL RESULTS!

THE ULTIMATE NANCY DREW GAMES TIER RANKINGS: FINAL RESULTS!

Sike! We aren't done yet, y'all!

Yes, Clue Crew: S round voting will be commencing soon!

But first, let's get the results for Mystery of the Seven Keys out of the way. Voting for this game had one of the lowest turnouts ever, which is no surprise at all. Out of 186 votes...

A - 1 vote

B - 12 votes

C - 31 votes

D - 48 votes

F - 94 votes *WINNER*

Now, onto business.

Quite a few of you voiced your opinions in the earlier rounds that S tier ranking should have been an option! And those who spoke up are totally right! After voting for Secrets Can Kill ended, I considered starting over entirely to include an S tier, but then I thought, instead of starting over, why not do things a bit differently and wait until voting for ALL the games are complete before we open up voting to decide which games deserve to be bumped up to S tier the most?

For S tier ranking, I want you guys to consider not necessarily which games YOU think are THE best, but also consider what games you think best embody the concept of the S tier? Think of everything about the games as a package deal:

  • Subjective opinions aside, which games do you immediately think of when you think of Nancy Drew?
  • Which games feel most put together and fully realized, with a well rounded mystery that's best complemented by its' atmosphere?
  • What games feature the strongest roster of characters that feel like actual people, with depth and complexity to them?
  • Also consider the puzzles: which games have the most enjoyable puzzles? Or even the perfect number of puzzles with the perfect ratio of easy to hard difficulty, or even how organic they feel to the world of that particular Nancy Drew game?

Since I started this with the fandom at large in mind, I want your opinion on how voting for S tier should and will happen. Do we....

  • Vote only on A games, or open up to B games as well?
  • Vote for a Top 3 or a Top 5?

My initial thinking was that S tier voting would only be open to A games, as they are the most beloved and there's plenty to chose from, but I also thought that we could also open up voting to B games, too. More games than I expected were voted into B tier, and there's a couple in that tier that I personally believe deserve to be considered for S tier (Fox and Geese be damned).

What are we thinking, Clue Crew? Give me your thoughts and when enough people sound off, S round voting will officially commence!

Round 1 - Secrets Can Kill

Round 2 - Stay Tuned For Danger

Round 3 - Message in a Haunted Mansion

Round 4 - Treasure in the Royal Tower

Round 5 - The Final Scene

Round 6 - Secret of the Scarlet Hand

Round 7 - Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake

Round 8 - The Haunted Carousel

Round 9 - Danger on Deception Island

Round 10 - The Secret of Shadow Ranch

Round 11 - The Curse of Blackmoor Manor

Round 12 - The Secret of the Old Clock

Round 13 - Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon

Round 14 - Danger By Design

Round 15 - The Creature of Kapu Cave

Round 16 - The White Wolf of Icicle Creek

Round 17 - Legend of the Crystal Skull

Round 18 - The Phantom of Venice

Round 19 - The Haunting of Castle Malloy

Round 20 - Ransom of the Seven Ships

Round 21 - Warnings at Waverly Academy

Round 22 - Trail of the Twister

Round 23 - Shadow at the Waters Edge

Round 24 - The Captive Curse

Round 25 - Alibi in Ashes

Round 26 - Tomb of the Lost Queen

Round 27 - The Deadly Device

Round 28 - The Ghost of Thornton Hall

Round 29 - The Silent Spy

Round 30 - The Shattered Medallion

Round 31 - Labyrinth of Lies

Round 32 - Sea of Darkness

Round 33 - Midnight in Salem

Round 34 - Mystery of the Seven Keys

u/southernfirefly13 — 10 days ago

Round 27 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: The Deadly Device!

Hey Clue Crew,

Holy SmokeS, last round brought us incredibly cloSe to a tie, the cloSeSt we’ve ever been, actually! 293 voteS were caSt for Tomb of the Lost Queen, and ranking haS been determined.

A - 21 voteS
B - 64 voteS
C - 92 voteS
D - 97 voteS *WINNER*
F - 19 voteS

Those passionate about the games Egyptian setting fought hard to rank it C, but the people have spoken and the D’s have it!

The Deadly Device is next! 8 more roundS to MyStery of the Seven KeyS!

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 30 days ago

Today felt like the perfect day to make some gumbo!

I fully admit I’m not the greatest cook, but gumbo is genuinely one of my favorite things to cook so I’m always looking to perfect it!

How does it look, guys?

u/southernfirefly13 — 1 month ago

Round 24 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: The Captive Curse!

Hey Clue Crew!

Here we are! Round 24! A games are on a roll! I know I’ve been late, but I’ve still been having a lot of fun hosting this!  It’s been great fun to see just how beloved the games are, and a few of the rankings have even surprised me! 

A - 215 votes *WINNER*
B - 106 votes
C - 21 votes
D - 11 votes
F - 2 votes

Shadow at the Waters Edge is an A game! A games are dominating! These games are beloved, but there’s a couple that for sure surprised me.

Let’s see how beloved The Captive Curse is. Voting starts now!

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 1 month ago

Can we launch a fan campaign to make sure Carrie Coon gets nominated for Best Actress?

Are fan campaigns a thing?

Carrie Coon is a phenomenal actress. Gone Girl, The Leftovers, The Gilded Age, The White Lotus. She COMMITS, and she’s one of the working actresses that you hear her name and you can’t help but be excited to see her work (or maybe I’m biased because she’s one of my favorite actresses).

She’s been getting rave reviews for The Liberation and is entering the discussion for a Best Actress nomination. I feel like she would deserve the nomination more.

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 1 month ago

Pennington County employees that were told to stay home at the start of the cyberattack (7/5) are being told we'll either lose pay or earned vacation time.

My department was specifically told not to come in that first day. Almost a month later, we were told to use either sick pay or vacation time in order to get paid, which we did. I used sick pay. Two months later they're now telling us we have to give up a days pay or vacation time.

Can they actually do this? This fucking infuriates me.

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 1 month ago

Round 21 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: Trail of the Twister!

Hey Clue Crew!

We had a record breaking number of votes come in for Warnings at Waverly Academy!  414 votes were cast to determine the winning vote! 

A - 242 votes *WINNER*
B - 103 votes
C - 54 votes
D - 13 votes
F - 2 votes

A!!!! Never again will I doubt the popularity of this game. It’s clearly beloved, and it deserves the love, too! 

How loved will Trail of the Twister be? Let’s start voting, guys! 

EDIT: I made a typo in the post title. It’s round 22. TBH I don’t feel like reposting this so it’ll stay and next round will show the proper round, 23.

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

The updates rankings will be posted after work!

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 1 month ago

Round 21 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: Warnings at Waverly Academy!

Hey Clue Crew!

Wow. I think we all saw this coming, but seeing it actually happen makes it feel more surprising than it is. But the people have spoken on their choice for Ransom of the Seven Ships! 355 to be exact! 

A - 10 votes
B - 21 votes
C - 64 votes
D - 120 votes
F - 140 votes *WINNER*

F! 

Our next game is guaranteed to do far better. So without further ado, let’s get to voting on Warnings at Waverly Academy! The rankings, as usual….

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 19 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: The Haunting of Castle Malloy

Hey Clue Crew!

Wow, The Phantom of Venice was much closer to having a tie than Legend of the Crystal Skull did.

A - 91 votes
B - 93 votes *WINNER*
C - 68 votes
D - 23 votes
F - 5 votes

This had a much lower turn out than previous rounds, at 280 votes, but the winner was clear - B!

Moving onto The Haunting of Castle Malloy! What will the voting trends be moving forward, now that voting is moving along now?

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

RIP DOLLY PARTON

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 18 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew games tier rankings! Vote now: The Phantom of Venice!

Hey Clue Crew!

Wow, this came pretty close to being a tie, but nope…

A - 147 votes *WINNER*
B - 126 votes
C - 50 votes
D - 23 votes
F - 2 votes

The A’s have it!

The Phantom of Venice is up for voting now! Will it steal another spot among the other A games, or will it fall short? As always…

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 17 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: Legend of the Crystal Skull!

Hey Clue Crew!

2 days, 3 hours, and 330 votes later, we have a verdict on White Wolf of Icicle Creek!

A - 84 votes
B - 115 votes *WINNER*
C - 94 votes
D - 31 votes
F - 6 votes

B wins! Legend of the Crystal Skull is a popular game. Will it rank B, or will the A’s have it? We’ll find out in two days! Voting starts now!

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 16 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: The White Wolf of Icicle Creek!

Hey Clue Crew!

Voting for The Creature of Kapu Cave ended an hour ago, and out of 324 votes…

A - 11 votes
B - 49 votes
C - 99 votes
D - 132 votes *WINNER*
F - 33 votes

Our second ever D game! Will The White Wolf of Icicle Creek follow, or will it fare higher? We’ll find out in two days! Voting starts now!

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

I’ll post the updated tier rankings after work!

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 15 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: The Creature of Kapu Cave!

Hey Clue Crew!

We are nearly to the halfway point of these rankings! Voting for Danger by Design ended, and out of 301 votes…

A - 49 votes
B - 102 votes
C - 118 votes *WINNER*
D - 26 votes
F - 6 votes

Our third ever C game!

Round 15 voting starts now! How will The Creature of Kapu Cave stack up!? Voting starts now, and as always, the rankings are as follows:

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

Fight the power!

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 14 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote now: Danger by Design!

Hey guys!

This is coming way later than I planned. I meant to post this on my lunch break earlier but got distracted. But now that I’m out of my online class, here we go!

Round 14!

378 votes were put in for Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon, and the decision by a landslide is…

A - 281 votes
B - 63 votes
C - 28 votes
D - 6 votes
F - 0 votes

…A GAME!!!!

Which means that voting for Danger By Design starts now!

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

A hill I will die one: Jaclyn, Kate, and Laurie's friendship is one of the best relationships Mike White has written for the series, and they didn't deserve the hate they got.

I love everything about this scene. I love it, so. so. so much. Laurie's monologue especially. Her beautiful and brilliant monologue.

Potential hot take. I feel that Laurie, Kate, and Jaclyn were judged more harshly than they should have been. When the season was airing, the comments were all about how fake the women were and how terrible friends they were to each other. The three women have a complex and resilient friendship that goes back to back to their high school days. That's at least 25 years of solid history, and that's a rarity. Even most marriages don't last that long. Relationships are fickle, and we got to see this point of their lives play out after being apart for so long, shocked and surprised at how different they've become and letting it manifest a worser version of themselves to put on display, and yet by the end, their love and bond are both apparent.

Jaclyn's line "Most people judge me for my superficial defects. You guys judge me for my profound defects," spoke volumes about how she really feels about Kate and Laurie. Their fights were insignificant to her.

Kate compares her friendship with Jaclyn and Laurie to a garden that blooms after a long period of watering and nurturing the soil of it. Again, she said it: their friendship is her garden, and the girls themselves and all the significant achievements in life are the flowers. Their time apart still allows them to grow together.

Laurie and her brilliant and beautiful monologue, in comparison, speaks about how sad she's felt because her mistakes felt transparent after being with them for the week. She wasn't talking about the fact that she knew the other two were gossiping about her, but because they've both achieved a place where they're happy and content with how their lives turned out, while her own is on extremely shaky ground. Her "belief systems" (love, work, motherhood) fell apart, but Kate and Jaclyn are her true constants in life.

You would swear they hate each other, but look at how they speak at the end of their trip and the season. Their friendship survived well into adulthood because they accept that they're growing into different people constantly and they're allowing themselves to grow together, all their fights and squabbles be damned!

Very rarely does a scene or a monologue sticks with me, but Laurie's monologue in particular resonates. I know it hasn't even been a year and a half since the finale, but just being a year older than I was when the finale aired (32 > 33), her words feel more truthful now. You do have to justify your life choices and stuff, but it's exhausting having to do. If religion gives you meaning, great. If love gives your life meaning, great. If it doesn't, that's okay. She's right that time does, and it's great to be happy to be at the table. In turn, it makes me think of my own friendship with my best friend of 8 years and all the good and bad and ugly we've been through and now we're states a part, we're growing as people and it's letting our friendship grow.

Mike White is one of my all time favorite writers. He has a real knack for writing realistic and complex relationships. Makes me real excited to see what season 4 delivers.

youtube.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 13 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew games tier rankings! Vote now: Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon!

Hey clue crew!

Polls for Round 12 closed a few hours ago! Out of 355 votes…

A - 79 votes
B - 126 votes *WINNER*
C - 109 votes
D - 35 votes
F - 6 votes

It’s been a few rounds since we had one, but Secret of the Old Clock was voted into B!!

Truth be told, I honestly thought there was a chance that C would overtake B. B is well deserved, though.

But now, we move onto Last Train to Blue Moon Canyon! Voting starts now! As always, the rankings are as follows:

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems.
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

Hasta la Pasta!

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Round 12 of the Ultimate Nancy Drew Games tier rankings! Vote Now: Secret of the Old Clock!

Hey clue crew!

I’m so late on posting this, and I even forgot to post the updated tier ranking last round. School kept me insanely busy this past week (midterms). But we’re past all that, so here we are with round 12!

332 votes were cast for The Curse of Blackmoor Manor and out of those votes…

A - 214 votes *WINNER*
B - 75 votes
C - 22 votes
D - 13 votes
F - 8 votes

Another A game!

Let’s see if Secret of the Old Clock will be able to secure an A ranking! Voting begins now, and as always, the rankings are as follows:

A - The fan favorites. The cream of the crop.
B - Good enough to be held in high regards.
C - Underrated gems
D - A bit mid, will usually only play once or twice a year.
F - Unfinished. Unplayable. One of the worst.

Until next time, make sure you pick those vegetables.

View Poll

reddit.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago

Private pools, celeb-spotting and intimidating luxury: Secrets of a ‘White Lotus’ resort

Nothing new learned, except they’re also filming something in Monaco. Still a neat write up about the new season.

cnn.com
u/southernfirefly13 — 2 months ago