
Recommendations for a good BIFL backpack for a university student
Hey all! I made a post similar to this in r/backpacks to no avail. I'm currently looking for a good (but not terribly expensive) backpack for University/College. I've done my research, and by research I mean looking up 'Backpack name + reddit' and going on r/BuyItForLife and typing the word backpack. I only have two sets of criteria I want my ideal backpack to have outside of the cost.
I currently own a TNF Jester (for roughly 8 months) and my experience with it has been surprisingly subpar. The backpack is effectively always bent, which means my notebooks are bent as well, and it has resulted in two notebooks breaking.
I'm mainly looking for a backpack that has good water resistance, as it rains a lot where I live, even during summer time. I also want it to have a 17 inch laptop sleeve for convenience. The standard from what I see is 15 inches but I have a quite thick laptop (studying CS), and my TNF Jester's 15 inch sleeve doesn't do anything.
I've done a bit of research and have come across three backpacks I'm looking at purchasing, though I'd appreciate any recommendations or words of advice against or towards one of my three possible picks. I'm looking to spend AT MOST $150 USD.
I found the Carhartt 35L Triple-Compartment Backpack at $130 USD and it meets both of my ideal choices! It has a 17-inch sleeve for my laptop and seems to have water resistance. I did read a reddit post from someone who got a 28L backpack from them and had a less than stellar time with it, stating that much of the price came from the brand and not the materials.
The SwissGear 1900 Backpack at $99 USD and meets one of the two criteria. It has the 17-inch sleeve but no water resistance, with reviews pointing out how light rain quickly results with the internals of the backpack getting wet, which is NOT what I'm looking for.
Lastly I found the Patagonia Refugio Daypack 26L/30L at $135 USD and meets one of the two criteria. It doesn't have the 17-inch sleeve but DOES have water resistance. Not much else to say here other than I like the colorways.
I've checked Osprey but they seem like the same price as Patagonia (if not more expensive) and meeting the same criteria as the Refugio. Tom Binh does have some backpacks with 16-inch sleeves but the price is far too high for me. I'm also interested in an Aer backpack but reviews either alternate between saying its great or claiming the opposite, and again, the prices are a bit too high for me.
If anyone has any suggestions or comments regarding these I highly appreciate them :)