AITAH for hooking up with the guy my ex accused me of flirting with months after we broke up?
I (21F) was 19 when I dated my ex (23M), who I’ll call K. For context about K … The relationship started out great, but over time he became increasingly insecure and controlling. If I spent too much time at the gym, he would call and ask who I was with. If I told him I was alone, he would say I was invalidating his feelings. He would also get upset if I went out without him or wore something he considered too revealing.
The other people in this story are K’s best friend, R, and R’s best friend, P.
One summer, the four of us went on a river float together. P was visiting from Florida. If you’ve never been on a river float, it’s basically several hours of floating down a river, eating sandwiches, drinking, and hanging out. At one point, P offered the group a joint. K declined because he was interviewing for a fire station job, but I joined in. Since P and I were sharing the joint, our floats stayed next to each other, and we ended up talking for a long time. We discovered we had a lot of shared interests, including antiques, rocks, oddities, bones, and music.
Afterward, we all went to K’s parents’ house for R’s 21st birthday. We all got a little tipsy, and once again P and I ended up talking for most of the evening.
When everyone left, K immediately accused me of flirting with P all day. I was genuinely shocked because I didn’t feel that way at all. I was in love with K at the time and honestly thought I had just enjoyed talking to someone who shared my interests. It turned into an argument because I felt the accusation was completely unfounded.
A few months later, K and I broke up for reasons unrelated to P. After the breakup, I spent a lot of time reflecting on the relationship and became pretty angry about some of the things I had put up with.
Around that time, P and I started talking occasionally just to catch up. There had never been any romantic feelings between us while I was dating K and frankly none after.. I never pursued him in that way.
At one point, I jokingly said I should come visit Florida because I wanted to travel more, and P actually agreed. A few weeks later, I flew down and spent a week exploring Florida with him.
During that trip, we did end up hooking up.
We also went out to dinner and spent a lot of time together, but neither of us was looking for a relationship.
While I was there, I posted a picture of P and me working out together on Instagram. I knew there was a good chance K would see it, and if I’m being honest, part of the reason I posted it was because I was still angry about the relationship and wanted him to see that I was doing fine without him. Before posting it, I asked P if he cared what K thought, and he said he didn’t.
Nobody ever confronted me about the post, and neither R nor P seemed bothered by any of it. However, I recently found out that K no longer allows P at his house. This is significant because R and P are now roommates, which means K’s issue with P has apparently continued long after my relationship with K ended.
AITAH?