Need some honest advice. Should I accept the friendship and move on, or keep hoping?
​
I met a girl on Reddit a while ago. She had recently gone through a breakup, and we started talking. At first, I wasn't expecting anything—I was just being there for her. But somewhere along the way, I started developing feelings.
For some context, I was in a relationship years ago, and after that ended I stayed single for almost 3 years. During that time I've talked to hundreds of people online, but I never felt a connection like I did with her. She just felt... different.
Eventually, I told her how I felt. She rejected me, mainly because she's older than me and doesn't see me that way. She said she'd like to stay best friends.
The problem is that it's really hard for me to see her as "just a friend" because my feelings are genuine. What made me fall for her wasn't just her personality—it was how loyal she was. Seeing how committed she was in her previous relationship made me admire her even more. It made me feel that if she ever chose me, she'd be just as loyal, and honestly I wanted to treat her with all the love, respect, care, and consistency she deserves.
I know she doesn't owe me a relationship, and I completely respect her decision. I'm not trying to change her mind or convince her to choose me. I just can't switch my feelings off overnight.
I also don't want to lose her completely. If staying friends is the only place she sees for me in her life, I'm willing to try because she genuinely means a lot to me. If we ever have misunderstandings, I'd rather apologize and work things out than lose the connection completely. At the same time, I know a friendship should be healthy for both people, and I don't want to ignore my own feelings either.
Lately, though, I've noticed she's not talking to me the way she used to. Maybe she's creating some distance, or maybe I'm just overthinking it. Either way, I can feel myself slowly trying to let go of my feelings because I know I can't force someone to love me.
Deep down, I think I already know the answer: accept the friendship if I genuinely can, without expecting her feelings to change. If I can't do that, then maybe I need to step back and move on.
So I wanted to ask people who have been through something similar:
Should I accept the friendship and move on, or should I keep hoping that maybe one day things change? Have any of you ever stayed friends with someone you loved, and did it actually work out?