r/AmyLynnBradley

Today while reading more about this case. Btw I knew about Amy much before the Netflix Documentary. Somehow felt something looking at her picture. As if she wants justice or something or like she calls you and gives you that feeling that she is indeed alive. After all this years. It could be her spirit alone. But this case will be solved and she will be found alive or it will known to all what really happened. Anyways, two points I felt very very strong about.

1. Her father. He knows something or did something or has an idea about something or intuitively knows something but it isn’t sharing anything at all. Especially for his wife. Like he is guilty of something and is protecting his wife’s peace by not telling her anything at all or keeping something important away to have Eva to be in a hopeful state.

2. This Scientology shit is beyond just Amy speaking to two their officers. This organisation is accused of trafficking (labour more than sexual) so there is a fair chance that those officers and this angle should be investigated more and more than Yellow guy. Not that I am leaving him or the cruise director or cruise staff as not guilty. But Scientology did something somewhere.

I feel like all the puzzle pecies are right in front of us. We have so much evidence, and with the new leads the private detective found, we are closer and closer. Its just making the timeline make sense, she didnt fall overboard, we was taken.

Obviously just about everyone on the internet invokes this maxim incorrectly. And many goofs even treat it as an axiom (without even understanding it).

But as it relates to the case, is the TRUE usage of Occam's Razor to conclude Amy fell off the balcony or got trafficked?

From another thread where goofs were hallucinating she fell was "occam's razor" that didn't require assumptions -

My response -

You would have to assume all the sightings of fully awake people on the ship AFTER she would have fallen are all wrong/not reliable (INCLUDING PEOPLE WHO SPECIFICALLY KNEW HER), while ASSUMING the sighting of "legs" by her half/full asleep father is infallible and gospel.

You would have to assume all the search teams are incompetent and cannot find someone falling overboard in a narrow channel (has that EVER happened before)?

You would have to assume it's all "coincidental" that all these sightings of her or her lookalike JUST SO HAPPEN to include THE SAME HANDLERS in the different countries in different years, one of which has been arrested for prostitution rings and you would also have to assume it's all "coincidental" that Jas photos showed up on the website owned by a guy who employed the handler previously arrested for prostitution rings who himself had been arrested for prostitution rings in the Caribbean.