r/DIYRetirement

Social Security delaying difference is small why isn’t this discussed more?

I used the the open source social security calculator to see what was the best option for my wife and I to take our social security. We are 66 and 65 respectively. It came back with me waiting until 70 and my wife taking it now! I then entered my own calculation, which it allows you to do for comparison. I said we would both take it at our FRA. I was surprised that the present value difference was only 3.1% and $28k over our entire lifetimes. I then started to look at the yearly cash flows and because you get so much front loaded at our FRAs the difference to age 84 is only $13k.

Does anyone ever look at just having the cash flow upfront on an annual basis rather than just maximizing the entire amount. Especially for those who have a robust plan that are not relying on SS to fund their later years?

reddit.com
u/pbfin1937 — 7 days ago
▲ 3 r/DIYRetirement+1 crossposts

Target Date Fund vs ETF

I’ve been investing in 401Ks for almost 20 years (had a lot of jobs but always rollover) and just realized you can invest in ETFs instead of just a target date fund based on when you want to retire. Thinking of moving my money into some market tracking funds with better returns and a bit more risk since no cash or bonds.

Any opinions on picking your own 401K investments?

reddit.com
u/Apprehensive_Gap_966 — 7 days ago

27 yo hoping to retire by 40

Hi everyone,

I recently organized my accounts and took a close look at my current asset allocation, and I’d love to get some perspective from this community as I plan for FIRE.

Here is a quick overview of my financial situation:

- Annual Income: $160k–$200k W2 (varies depending on bonus) + ~$55k rental income
- Real Estate: 2 rental properties (Total portfolio value ~$650k)
- Remaining Mortgage: ~$130k
- Fixed Overhead (Property Taxes, Insurance, HOA): ~$20k/year
- Monthly Savings: ~$5,000–$6,000/month (after all taxes and living expenses)

Currently, I’m saving a solid amount each month, but I feel a bit unsure about how to best direct my future stock investments and overall investment strategy to reach early retirement efficiently.

I know there's no single "right" answer, but I would really appreciate any insights, feedback, or advice on how you would structure things moving forward.

Thanks in advance!

u/MinuteNeighborhood92 — 8 days ago
▲ 2 r/DIYRetirement+1 crossposts

looking for advice : 401K @ 59 yrs old

My company is starting a 401K plan, and I'm 59 years old. I get the whole "no tax up front, taxed when you withdraw" concept but here's the question - do I max out and ride it for 6-8 years or do I just pay my insanely high income tax like I've been doing for years? (no dependas/no debt/no real deductions to speak of)

I can do trad 401k or Roth, or both. Employer will match some, but not all I put in.

I really have no idea about these things, so I'm hoping you money enthusiasts and smarter than me types can help a brotha out :)

reddit.com
u/Vic_Interceptor — 7 days ago

What's the most annoying part of using retirement planners?

For me it is a combination of data entry and learning an unfamiliar UI. I don't like hunting for the spot where something is configured.

reddit.com
u/ItIsALLInTheNumbers — 7 days ago
▲ 3 r/DIYRetirement+1 crossposts

Failed to terminate Solo 401k after becoming a full time employee

I'm not sure where to post this question and am hopeful someone here has some advice. I set up an individual 401k in 2009, and had self-employment income until 2011. I started a FT job in 2010, and subsequently asked an advisor about rolling it over. I was informed that you can't terminate a plan that is in your name (business name was my name) as how do you prove separation from business? Turns out this was bad advice. I haven't had self-employment income since then, but kept the 401k with the intent that I would go back to having self-employment income upon retiring from employment (which was in a different career). I did keep my CPA license active. From what I have been able to determine when researching online, this could have worked to establish continuity of business IF I filed a Schedule C at least once every three years - even if it had zeros on it; however, I didn't do that. I just hit the threshold to file Form 5500-EZ in 2024, but missed the due date in 2025 so filed under the IRS Penalty Relief Program. I recently decided to roll this over to an IRA as I became disabled and it is very unlikely I will ever be able to work again, and discovered that I should have terminated the plan much sooner (or filed the "zero" Schedule C), or there could be penalties.

TLDR: inaccurately kept a solo 401k with no contributions for 15 years (no SE income and no Schedule C filed, though I kept my business license active).

Questions: What are the potential penalties? And is there any way to get ahead of this by "fessing up" to the IRS? I'm considering attaching a statement to my 2026 “final” 5500-EZ admitting the oversight and saying that I did maintain my business license.

Is anyone aware of a situation where the IRS did access penalties for something like this?

Is there a different subreddit that would be more applicable to my situation?

Thanks in advance for any wisdom you can share!

reddit.com
u/NinaStev — 7 days ago
▲ 5 r/DIYRetirement+1 crossposts

Help me understand an Annuity rider called Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit (GMWB)

I put $10,000 into an Individual Retirement Annuity (IRA) about 8 years ago and I'm now past the surrender penalty period. When I signed up I added a rider called Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit (GMWB). The description of the rider says: Income Pay 7% for 10 years with automatic reset option.

The statement inception summary I got recently says:

Premium: $10,000

Premium Bonus: $500

Rider Cost: $1,460

Interest & Index Credits: $1,700

Surrender Value: $10,740

Death Benefit Amount: $10,740

Accumulation Value: $10,740

Below that it lists the details for the GMWB rider:

GMWB Value: $20,650

Income Payment Percentage: 4.75%

Annual Lifetime Payment Amount: $980

Can someone explain what all of this actually means? When I signed up I think I understood it as the rider giving me a guaranteed 7% income every year for 10 years, but that clearly isn't what's happening.

I read through how GMWB riders work here https://www.annuity.org/annuities/riders/gmwb/ but I’m not sure I understood how it all applies to my situation. If I decided to pull all my money out right now, would I be able to withdraw $10,740 or $20,650?

u/truecakesnake — 13 days ago