
Powerlifting home gym: talk me out of bumpers?
Setting up a basement gym. Goal is squat, bench, deadlift, RDLs. Limited to no olympic lifting, so nothing is coming down from overhead worst case is a deadlift set down or a rack-miss into safeties.
My instinct was bumpers, and I've narrowed to Weight It Out's Thumper (polyurethane, 1.3" on the 45s, $259/pair) or Fringe Sport savage rubber. But the more I read, the more it seems like a powerlifting-only setup wants calibrated steel or thin cast iron instead thinner, cheaper, more accurate. Weight It Out sells those too and they're less money than their bumpers.
So:
- For pure powerlifting, is there any real case for bumpers over iron?
- Basement, so noise and floor matter. Does a platform plus horse stall mat make iron a non-issue, or is that wishful thinking?
- If bumpers, does the Thumper's thinness actually pay off, or is it a spec-sheet win?
- Anyone gone iron in a basement and regretted it? Or gone bumpers and wished they'd saved the money?
Currently repping in the mid-200s and climbing, so sleeve space matters to me over time. 83" ceiling if relevant.