You Can Like Hardcore and Still Miss the Entire Point
I genuinely think a lot of people in modern hardcore have completely lost touch with where this music and scene came from.
Hardcore did not emerge from conservative ideology. It didn’t come from nationalism, authoritarianism, blind patriotism, billionaire worship, or “law and order” politics. Hardcore came directly out of punk and punk, historically, has always been rooted in anti-authoritarianism, anti-fascism, anti-racism, skepticism of capitalism, and resistance against systems of power that crush marginalized people.
That doesn’t mean every punk or hardcore kid throughout history has personally lived up to those ideals. Obviously there have always been people more interested in aggression, image, or scene politics than the actual message. But the actual ideological roots of the culture are not hard to trace.
Bands were writing songs about police brutality, war, Reagan-era conservatism, racism, greed, consumerism, homophobia, and fascist violence decades ago. DIY culture itself was built as a rejection of corporate control and mainstream power structures. The scene was supposed to challenge authority — not worship it.
So yeah, it’s genuinely bizarre watching people try to force pro-Trump, right-wing authoritarian politics into hardcore while acting like everyone else is “making it political.” The culture was already political. It always has been.
And before somebody jumps in with “so you can’t be conservative and like hardcore?” Obviously nobody can stop you from listening to the music. But if your worldview revolves around hierarchy, nationalism, hostility toward minorities, worship of wealth and power, or defending authoritarian politicians, then you are fundamentally at odds with the core values that shaped punk and hardcore culture in the first place.
Also, rejecting fascist ideology is not the same thing as being intolerant. The whole “you’re no better than Nazis if you hate Nazis” argument completely ignores the fact that fascism itself is built around domination, exclusion, and stripping rights from other people. Refusing to tolerate that is not hypocrisy.
Hardcore was never supposed to be safe, comfortable, or politically neutral. It was supposed to confront oppressive bullshit directly.