Looking for honest feedback: what's good, what sucks, and what should I add? As a student myself I built a free speech coach for students that gives feedback on speeches and presentations and also has a bunch of other confidence/debate/public speaking features
Thanks Heaps!
I'm Jerry, founder of Monni.
I'm giving 20 people a free 1-year membership in exchange for blunt feedback on the first week.
Monni is an iOS money brief for people who want a lighter weekly check-in instead of a full budgeting system.
Best fit:
App Store: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/monni-ai-money-tracker/id6778174904
Website: https://monni.io
DM me if you want one. I'll reply asking for the email to grant access to, then manually add the free year.
Please don't post your email publicly, and don't send balances, screenshots, account numbers, addresses, passwords, or private financial details. High-level workflow feedback is enough.
I may be biased because I'm the founder of Monni.io.
I could use some fresh eyes from people who have probably looked at way more app icons than I have.
I’m building Jogventure, a beginner-friendly walking/running app that turns your progress into more of a lighthearted adventure, levels, milestones, challenges, a journey map, etc. The little blue guy in both icons is the app’s mascot, Joggle.
I originally made Option 1 a while back. It’s more detailed and tries pretty hard to communicate the whole “running + adventure/journey” idea directly in the icon.
More recently I made Option 2, which strips a lot of that away and puts more emphasis on the mascot itself.
I keep seeing the same advice with iOS icons: less is more, especially once the thing gets shrunk down to actual Home Screen size. That’s what made me start questioning whether the first icon is trying to do too much.
But I’ve been staring at this app for so long that I don’t trust my own judgment anymore.
If you saw these two next to each other in the App Store, which one?
Would you choose 1 or 2?
And more importantly, why? Does one feel more polished, recognizable, or like something you’d actually tap?
Feel free to be picky. Color, composition, mascot size, background, readability, whatever jumps out at you. I’m specifically looking for the kind of feedback I probably wouldn’t notice myself.
I’d rather hear that one of them sucks now than figure it out after launch 😅
