2014 Lexus GS 350 F Sport RWD vs. 2017 Honda Accord Touring v6
TL;DR - Help me decide: 2014 Lexus GS 350 F Sport RWD vs. 2017 Accord Touring V6 - coming from a 2010 Accord V6
Hi all,
I'm currently looking for a new car and have mostly narrowed it down to two options:
- 2014 Lexus GS 350 F Sport RWD
- 2017 Honda Accord Touring V6
I'd also consider a 2014-ish Lexus IS 350 F Sport RWD, which honestly might be closer to what I actually want, but they're harder to find and the extra space in the GS is appealing.
I've found that the 2014 Lexus GS 350 F Sport RWD and 2017 Honda Accord Touring V6 are currently selling for around the same prices at the ~100k-mile mark, which is where I'm targeting the mileage for my next "new used" car.
For context, I currently own a 2010 Honda Accord EX-L V6 and have put 100k+ miles on it. I've really enjoyed it for what it is: a reliable, reasonably quick, comfortable, and extremely practical sedan. However, more recently I've found myself wanting something a bit more engaging and fun to drive.
That's part of why I'm considering the Lexus this time around. I know the GS 350 isn't a sports car, but from the research I've done so far, it sounds like the RWD F Sport should provide a more engaging driving experience than another Accord while still being a comfortable and practical sedan.
The 2017 Accord Touring V6 is a little more complicated for me. Given my history with my current Accord, it's obviously something I'd already be pretty familiar with. But at the same time, I wonder if I'd essentially be spending a substantial amount of money to upgrade into a newer and nicer version of the same car I already have. If that's the case, part of me feels like I'd be better off just keeping my 2010 for a while longer and waiting for a better deal somewhere down the road.
I also really enjoy taking long road trips, so that's an important consideration for me. I know the GS will cost more to fuel, both because of its worse gas mileage and because it requires premium. That's something I've considered, but I'm potentially willing to accept the additional cost if the car itself is worth it.
One major negative I've noticed with the 2014 GS, and I believe the IS as well, is the infotainment mouse/controller. I used it during a test drive and found it absolutely terrible to use. I'm not sure that's enough of a reason to rule out the GS entirely, but it's definitely a significant negative for me.
The particular GS I'm looking at also has the Mark Levinson sound system, which is a big plus.
I'm not necessarily looking to be convinced that one is objectively "the right car." I'm more interested in hearing from people familiar with these cars about the actual tradeoffs between them.
In particular:
- How different is the GS 350 F Sport to drive compared with a V6 Accord?
- Is the GS actually meaningfully more engaging, or is it primarily a luxury sedan with some sporty characteristics?
- How much am I giving up in reliability and maintenance costs by going from Honda to a 10+ year old Lexus?
- Does the 2017 Accord Touring V6 feel substantially different from the 8th-gen V6 Accord, or does it mostly feel like a newer and nicer version of the same car?
- How do the two compare for long road trips, particularly in terms of comfort and highway driving?
- For someone who likes the practicality of an Accord but wants something more fun to drive, which direction makes more sense?
- For those who have lived with the Lexus infotainment controller, is it something you eventually get used to, or does it remain annoying?
I'd especially love to hear from anyone who has owned or driven both the V6 Accords and the GS/IS 350.