r/StarCityTV

Star City is a great show, however...

The real history of the cosmonaut program, star city, GRU, KGB, and the Soviet Union are absolutely fascinating.

Obviously, it's quite bleak as well.

The story of Oleg Penkovsky, a GRU Colonel that sold secrets to the CIA and was caught is fascinating.

There really are so many real life stories that are incredible.

Has anyone researched this time period of the CCCP? (Soyuz Sovetskikh Sotsialisticheskikh Respublik)

reddit.com
u/Illustrious_Bag_7323 — 2 days ago

Narrative logic problems

OK... I watched up to season 3 of For all mankind and gave up for several reasons.

  1. The ludicrous forbidden love plot... What is this doing in a show about alternate reality NASA ( I mean the later one, not the main one, that's fine and actually realistic, even with modern day politics)
  2. Each head of astronauts has absolute power, even to bring back an old buddy who they KNOW has gone crazy in space. They can then call in their own daughter to become an astronaut, no selection process, just how would you like to join me on a trip to Mars.
  3. Nuclear propulsion up to orbit???? that is completely sci-Fi unless you want to poison the whole earth.

Most of the rest was quite realistic I thought.. which is why those stood out.

So I had heard that Star City was better.. So I was looking forward to it.

Again most of the technical stuff looked real. 1st couple of episodes were good, not afraid to kill off apparently major characters very brutally.

Then it too started to go sideways. The Secret mission >!to Venus In Soviet Russia? How would you hide such a thing? Also why send people to Venus? They can't land. They could have sent the probe alone, it's nonsense!<. If it's renewed for another season I'll have to decide carefully if I'll watch it. I am invested in some of the characters which is the only reason I'm considering it.

reddit.com
u/lwSeagull — 4 days ago

Soviet Space Dominance

Watching Star City got me interested in the Soviet perspective of the Space Race. I watched these movies, and decided to make a poster series to bring these hidden gems to life as a series. I included the year they take place so watch them in order if you can.

Taming of the Fire (1972)
Filmed during the cold war as a propaganda film, recounts the life of Sergi Korolev from college through the first satellite and first human in space. They definitely had some real launch site access when filming this, pretty amazing shots. But kinda slow, I could probably have cut 40 minutes and not missed anything. Interesting nonetheless.

Gagarin: First in Space (2013)
Biography of Yuri Gagarin. I really wanted to like this film. It's fine, but, its really slow and even boring in some places. It actually reminded me of First Man (2018) which was also a slow biopic.

The Spacewalker (2017)
This movie is about the first human spacewalk, and is really great. They overcame a lot of challenges and they all play out on film. Major Apollo 13 vibes throughout. The movie has a compressed timeline compared to how long some things really took, but really enjoyable.

Salyut-7 (2017)
The Soviets lose contact with their space station, and send cosmonauts to investigate. Also based on a true story, but this one is highly sensationalized. Interesting and fun, but a bit over the top.

PS Taming of the Fire is available on YouTube at 720HD. Enjoy.

u/bcirce — 5 days ago

For anyone who’s also seen The Terror…

Which notably features Adam Nagaitis! The scene with Valya on Venus reminded me so much of >!Blanky finding the Northwest Passage, knowing he’s going to die but having that euphoric moment of victory/having completed the mission/getting to see something really unusual.!<

reddit.com
u/thequickpurplefox — 11 days ago

Why Venus and not Mars?

Why launch a mission to Venus when other missions—unmanned ones—had already failed, and when Venus offers nothing of interest or viability to humanity? Mars is a far better and safer option for everyone—especially for Soviet propaganda, given the goal of being the first to actually travel to and return alive from a planet that is at least somewhat hospitable to life.

reddit.com
u/p3t3rp4rkEr — 13 days ago

Rewatching Berlin Station where Rhys is one of main protagonist and there is scene where he is sitting in apartment and looking in a distance at pic on a wall which happens to be an Soviet astronaut. Amazing foreshadowing! Berlin Station was filmed during 2016-2019

Amazing foreshadowing by Mr. Chief Designer.

It was S1 EP2 of Berlin Station. Btw, if someone didn't watch this show, check it out. It is really good show and Ryhs is killing in it.

u/Boring_Aioli7916 — 13 days ago

A question about the audio recordings. Has it been discussed HOW each apartment’s recordings are collected? Like, does some security apparatchik collect them daily from a locked cellar closet in each building?

reddit.com
u/CanadianJediCouncil — 13 days ago

Why does Rhys Ifans sound like Peter Capaldi

Random post I know but started watching the series right now and Rhys is a fantastic actor but he sounds the spit of Peter Capaldi like if i close my eyes it sounds like doctor who is speaking to russian cosmonauts.

reddit.com
u/daveroo — 13 days ago