Okay. You guys were right. The strawberry milkshake poptarts FROZEN are something else. It really brings out the flavor and makes it taste like a milkshake. I loved it! Makes me wonder what other poptarts are good frozen...
They discontinued confetti cupcake poptarts 😭
BUUUT at target you can get these. They are literally the same, I added a picture to prove it
I’ve got a box of both strawberry and molten lava cake. Have you all been eating them straight out of the packaging? Or putting them in the toaster or freezer?
The rare pop-tarts box I was supposed to receive was returned twice, and now I need to pay $20 for it. I probably won't be able to get it but I will try my best to find a proper address and get it. If I don't receive it they will throw the box away. If I'm not able to get it someone else has to preserve this piece of pop-tarts history.
To me my favorite type of poptart was the Brown cinnamon, But my least favorite or the worst to me was the cookies and cream, Because they don’t rlly taste like Oreos or what I thought they’d taste like
Husband's poptart is on left, mine on the right. Tbh my sprinkles all fell off in the pouch lol hevwas jealous of my icing
Probably the first time having Pop-Tarts since I was 15 lol...feels wrong not buying frosted cherry or wild berry. Hopefully they're better than the regular chocolate, which I remember I never loved.
They also had a $1.00 coupon on the box.
Seen and purchased at Target in Fayetteville AR. I've not tasted these yet. I'm optimistic!
I don't know why people say it's too much filling or too sweet. It honestly tastes amazing to my mom and I.
First time trying it since yesterday and I am hooked!
As a strawberry milk lover, I LOVED these poptarts. The center is not a jam but like a strawberry cream. It really tastes like a strawberry milk/milkshake. This has made it's way up to top 5 forsure. I couldn't get enough of the filling and frosting combo, it worked together so well. I toasted it so the filling was warm, gooey, and oozing. Sooo good.
My mom bought me a box of the new Strawberry Cheesecake Pop Tarts to try. Who knew she had her finger on the pulse like that?!
I toasted some today and they were actually pretty good. They smell exactly like strawberry NutriGrain bars to me and kind of taste like them too. Luckily, I like strawberry NutriGrain bars, so I’m okay with that!
There was a decent amount of filling, though not a ton of cream cheese flavor. The strawberry definitely dominates. The most interesting part was the crust. It had a really convincing graham cracker flavor that I wasn’t expecting at all and seemed drier and crunchier than usual.
My three year old tried them too and immediately asked for a second bite, so I guess that means they passed the toddler test.
I’d give them a 6.5/10, with buttered blueberry still holding strong as my 10/10 gold standard.
Idk how it's my first time trying these but wow, you guys were right. These are sooo good. It's a pretty thick layer of cinnamon filling that gets warm and gooey after toasting them. The top is a simple vanilla like icing that goes perfect with the cinnamon flavor. Dip it in some milk and it's perfection. It almost tastes like a very slight apple cinnamon taste to me. Not in a bad way. Great poptart! Will definitely be keeping these in the rotation.
I haven't eaten a Pop-Tart in many many many years. I remember when I was a kid I used to like the cherry and the wild berry ones but like I said I haven't had them in many years. The stuffed chocolate molten lava cake look pretty intriguing though.
Cherry is my favorite of the bunch, but molten lava cake super stuffed is also thicc and delish. Kids specifically requested the strawberry milkshake and thin mints
This SUPERSTUFFED flavor, chocolate molten lava cake is MMMMM. These pix can't capture it.I had half heated up with butter, and the other half straight outta the box. Both were better than i even expected! 😋 ... I'm off to hunt them down again...