r/smoking

I got a chicken throne and need recommendations
▲ 14 r/smoking+1 crossposts

I got a chicken throne and need recommendations

Friends, pitmasters, and students… I managed to pick up a traeger chicken throne for free today. Well it just so happens last night at my local grocery store they had 2 Amish country birds on sale. I feel the signs pointed at me to try it on this throne. I have never done this style before. For the most part I’m a red meat smoker. For Christmas I did a spatchcock turkey and it turned out 8.9/10 in my opinion. I’m thinking beer in the throne but I’m needing help of temperature, time, and recommended seasonings. Typically I’m a meat church guy but I’m open to any recommendations. Tips and tricks are welcome and I’ll be sure to post the results. Thank you everyone!

u/Excelerator2562 — 7 hours ago
▲ 53 r/smoking

Smoked my first brisket. I'm afraid there's no hope for me.....

Because I'm trying to lose weight and this turned out amazing!
The details:
12lb Prime brisket trimmed and seasoned with kosher salt and pepper with a sprinkling of Lowry's on top. After trim and smoke weighed in at 6lbs (I used the meat trimmings for smash burgers that were also pretty awesome.)
Smoked in a Weber Searwood Pellet grill with cookin' pellets 100% hickory pellets.
Also added a few hickory wood chunks during the first four hours of the smoke to add another layer of smoke.
Started 8pm smoked at 180 for first four hours and then kicked it up to 250. Wrapped at 6 hours into the cook in butcher paper and used some of the rendered tallow in the wrap.
Pulled at 13 hours internal temp ranging from 203 to 199 and then stashed in a temp offset oven at 150. Until dinner at 6pm.
Easily the top item I've ever smoked. Smoke flavor on point, in fact better than any bbq joint that I can remember, tender and juicy. I'll definitely be coming back after my wallet recovers.

u/livinonnosleep — 7 hours ago

Help

Recently I received a prime rib roast since word got out that I have a smoker. I am very novice at this whole thing and would appreciate shared experience.

Cheers.

reddit.com
u/lvsprl — 8 hours ago
▲ 35 r/smoking

Scored this big guy last night

picked up this used XL BGE for $500. Couldn't be happier and I think the only people who understand how excited I am are you guys. This little guy and a cheap offset smoker has been holding it down for some time now but this big guy will take over for the most part. looking forward to smoking some beef ribs this weekend.

u/No_Debt5142 — 9 hours ago
▲ 7 r/smoking+4 crossposts

Black Olive Grill upgrade

I’m in the middle of an upgrade to my Black Olive. Bought a Pit Boss controller replacement. I’m hoping someone can tell me a few things. Apologies for the questions, I can’t seem to find the answers myself. Can anyone definitely tell me what each wire does? The unit has a fan, auger and ignition, just not sure what is what? Can the ignition be replaced easily? Controller came with a new one if it’s compatible. The temperature/RTD probe I’m just going to have it sitting in the back of the seal as the two halves close. New to all of this (charcoal) so thanks for the help. Right now the controller starts and then throws a ERR error. White, Black, Orange, Red, and Green wires. Green was grounded to the controller when I removed the old one.

u/kevham78 — 6 hours ago

Brisket fat cap up or down

I've been smoking (attempting) Brisket for the past 5 or so years now, didn't quite get the hang of it till last year, now it's a crowd pleaser. Fat cap up, aerodynamic trim, 12-16 hrs depending on the brisket, Montreal steak seasoning. Since I discovered the hot/warm hold, it's become a no brainer and consistently good.

However, in my pursuit of continual improvement, I like to learn how other people do it. I've recently learned that some pros smoke it fat cap down. The theory is, the rendered fat doesn't technically render directly into the meat, and smoking fat cap down protects the meat from the heat source more.

What's everybody's thought on this? I'd be worried the seasoning on the fat cap facing down would drip off with the fat. Also, the thought that the fat doesn't render directly into the meat made me consider stabbing through the fat cap into the meat with a meat tenderizer a bunch of times, hoping the fat would render into the meat through the larger pores created by the meat tenderizer.

Edit: thank you everyone for your responses! I did forget to mention I'm using a Lone Star Grillz 40" pellet smoker with a water tray (4 beers and 4 cups of pickle juice or apple cider vinegar). The heat source is far right of the smoker, similar to an offset but still in the smoke chamber. Meat placed mid section of grate. Now, I have not done a full 3D temp study of the chamber, just along the grate, so I'm not sure if I get more heat wrapping around the meat, or radiating from the diffuser. I guess I'll have to try it fat side down just to see what it does. My current setup does not dry the meat out at all, and I'm now the brisket house among my group of friends. I'm just always looking to get better. Also, I don't wrap my brisket. That may or may not play into these responses, but it might be worth noting.

reddit.com
u/Agreeable_Result9212 — 10 hours ago

Can I brine whole chickens before marinating them for smoking?

I heard that brining whole chickens gives the best juiciness for smoking, I only got 20 hours from now before I start the fire. Can I wet brine them now for a couple hours then marinate them overnight? They’re small whole chickens, around 1.4lbs each. Or are there better ways to ensure they stay tender?

Edit: making Peruvian style chicken, so no, I’m not down to change the recipe lol. Because marinade is already set and I’ve been craving trying this recipe being smoked for a long time.

reddit.com
u/ElevatedDyer — 9 hours ago

PSA: Brisket on sale!

If there's a Publix where you live, check your weekly flyer. Where I live, Publix is selling choice brisket for $5.99/lbs. I haven't seen it that low in a loooong time.

reddit.com
u/The-Tradition — 7 hours ago
▲ 5 r/smoking+1 crossposts

New Smoker Help

I’m looking to replace my electric Masterbuilt 30”. The MB has trouble keeping temperature and often the gauge is incorrect. I also don’t love the vertical design and having to put chips in every 45 minutes to an hour.

I’m considering a wood pellet grill as I’ve been smoking for a couple of years and feel ready to move on to something else.

What are thoughts on the Weber Searwood XL 600 for an entry level into a pellet grill? It seems to get high ratings and not going to completely break the bank. But if I’m already willing to spend $1200, are there other better options? Id love some feedback here! Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Still-Ad-2732 — 7 hours ago
▲ 4 r/smoking+1 crossposts

Smoking hog casing

Whats the trick to getting the hog casing, or the collagen ones for that matter, nice and "snappy"?

I usually never smoke them cause they come out chewy and rubbery

reddit.com
u/Low-Entrepreneur941 — 9 hours ago
▲ 110 r/smoking

Introducing: The Meat Curtains 5000... still working on the name

I'm smoking my second batch of beef jerky. My old way was to skewer the meat and thread it through the grates (see last picture). I'm fortunate to have a job that has access to multiple laser CNCs. After bribing some engineers with future delicious jerky, they drafted up my post-it note sketch. I am now able to load up the racks in the kitchen and conveniently hang the whole thing in my upright pellet smoker. And now I can load up 5 racks at a time! It's a game changer for my jerky making. Let me know your thoughts for improvement! Will post updates once it's done.

u/brainstew9886 — 22 hours ago
▲ 157 r/smoking

Smoked bulgogi tri tip

Smoked on my LSG 24x40 at 265 for ~2 hours over oak, seared off, then simmered in a store bought bulgogi sauce with some added onion and garlic.

Honestly insane. Highly recommend for something different!

u/deeeebait — 20 hours ago
▲ 70 r/smoking

First brisket. Much better than expected for a first time

16lbs untrimmed weight prime brisket from Costco. Trimmed and coated with salt and pepper. Smoked in Weber kettle at 250 for 7 hours before foil boat around 165. Continued in oven at 265 for another 5 hours as it had started to rain. Probe tender at 200-201. Finished in cooler wrapped in towels for 4 hours.

Had the boys over as it was too much meat for my household, did some burnt ends as well- was very well received overall. Worth it but takes up a whole day, not sure when I’ll repeat

u/mikael50 — 19 hours ago
▲ 381 r/smoking

2 Night Dry-Brined Prime Tomahawk, Smoked Then Cast Iron Seared

Picked up a couple of 2” thick Prime Tomahawk Steaks from Costco and wanted to keep the cook simple so the amazing beef could do its thing.

I dry-brined them for 2 nights with Kendu Spice Co. Moon Rock seasoning with a little extra Kosher salt, then smoked them at 225°F until they reached an internal temperature of 110°F. I used the Chef's Temp remote probe, which helped a lot. After that, I finished it with a hard reverse sear in a cast-iron to build the crust and render the fat.

The flavors, color, and bark/crust were insane.

Basic process:

  • Dry rub brine 2 nights with Moon Rock and a little extra Kosher salt
  • Smoked at 225°F
  • Pulled at 110°F internal
  • Cast iron sear to finish
  • Rested before slicing

The flavors and crust on this thing were unreal. Definitely one of the better Tomahawks I’ve cooked, and highly recommend it.

Thoughts:

  • I’d pull closer to 115°F next time
  • I’d give less to the cat (but he is so cute)
  • I’d get more than 2 Tomahawks
  • I’d invite everyone from Reddit to enjoy a slice

Once again, the boy, daughter, wife, cat, and I smashed them. No leftovers!

u/boathouse_floats — 1 day ago
▲ 77 r/smoking+2 crossposts

Well hot damn!

Picked up 1 of these a few months ago at Costco. $2.99/lb and Kicking myself for not buying 10 more…hatch green chili rubbed pork shoulder butt. Smoked 6 hours on pellet grill. Nice kick and excellent on tacos with some cabbage and grilled corn and stuffed poppers! This was 7.5lb, and very fork tender! Was a crowd pleaser for sure, got both kiddos to eat it too! Even my 5 year old who lives off chicken nuggets!

Sorry for the picture quality and presentation haha this was my 3rd time smoking a big piece of meat.

u/Dontwearshoesindoors — 19 hours ago
▲ 205 r/smoking

Let’s talk about wood

So I’ve been smoking for a few years and I own a tree company, I basically have access to unlimited wood for smoking. I have hickory, red and white oak, apple, black walnut and more I can’t think of, are there any other good woods to cook with? No post oak in my state.

u/CRaCkTh3Sky3 — 1 day ago
▲ 128 r/smoking

Found this Bradley sitting at the back of the thrift store today...$30

Only thing missing is the feeder tube. Never been fired up

“Pork Belly Burnt Ends - The ORIGINAL Recipe!” by How To BBQ Right

Today I completed the pork belly burnt ends by How to BBQ Right.   It was a moderate success. Still delicious, but I would cut down on some of the cook time that he suggested.

The different phases you see here are the initial cubing, then after the initial smoke, then phase 2 where you put them in a closed pan with butter and brown sugar and honey, and then finally with his recommended glaze combination of barbecue sauce, apple juice, apple jelly (which as you will see in the pictures I didn’t want to do just apple jelly, so I turned apple jelly into apple jalapeño jelly,) and Frank’s Red Hot.

Modifications to the recipe, I would do the initial smoke of the pork belly a little over two hours as I did, but I should not have put them into the closed pan with the butter and brown sugar and honey for an hour and a half. If anything about 45 minutes. And then at the very end I did them open pan with just the glaze on them for a few minutes. But live and learn. Still very very good. Just not as falling apart as I like.  I did a little sampling after phase one of the initial smoking and they were absolutely perfect at that point.

Live and learn. Just wanted to share my experience. I will absolutely use this recipe again, but I took some good notes in Evernote to remind me how to change it next time.

If you haven’t seen the video of this recipe, you can find it here. https://youtu.be/nL82hlORY-k

u/Fabulous_Log844 — 20 hours ago