I scaled my Shopify store from $10k to $61,782/month with a simple strategy.
▲ 206 r/shopify_growth+1 crossposts

I scaled my Shopify store from $10k to $61,782/month with a simple strategy.

P.S I have added a TL;DR at the bottom

I keep seeing people ask variations of the same question in different threads:

 how do you actually scale a Shopify store past the point where more ad spend stops helping. I usually give a short answer. This time I am giving the real one.

For context: my traffic was already decent. Ads were running, conversion rate was okay, but my average order value was pretty low, and it felt like I was leaving money on the table. Last month, our store dashboard hit $52,341 in total sales from 842 orders, with our conversion rate sitting at 2.9%. At first I thought I needed a better product, new creatives, or an increased ad spend. But the real issue was not traffic. It was what happened after people landed on the site.

This month, after fixing our backend leaks, our store dashboard hit exactly $61,782 in total sales from 956 orders. More importantly, our conversion rate stabilized at a very healthy 3.1%. I didn't get here by finding some secret viral trend or doubling my ad budget.

If you are selling physical products, start with Google Shopping Ads. Why? Because Shopping Ads show your product, price, and store rating to people who are already searching with buying intent. They do not need education. They do not need storytelling. They just need to see:

  • the product
  • the price
  • the store
  • and click

Shopping Ads is the cleanest and most direct way to convert traffic when intent is high. Search ➔ see ➔ buy.

If I had started with this instead of testing 20 random creative angles early on, I would have saved a lot of money and time. But here is what most store owners learn later: Traffic is not the problem. Your System is. Once traffic starts coming in, most people bleed money because they rely only on ads and ignore systems. That is like pouring water into a bucket with holes.

Here is the truth almost no beginner wants to hear: Ads bring visitors. Systems turn a profit.

  1. ) Why customer feedback beat every creative test I ran: I realized I was testing creatives blindly and wasted money without understanding what customers actually hesitated about. So I started collecting customer feedback before and after purchase to understand:
  • what made them click
  • what almost stopped them
  • what built trust

That alone improved my ads more than random creative testing.

  1. ) The split-testing mistake that was quietly breaking my mobile site: Another thing that quietly made a huge difference was proper split testing. Small changes like:
  • product page layout
  • review positioning
  • delivery messaging

ended up increasing revenue far more than I expected. But a word of warning: I used to use heavy testing scripts that spiked my bounce rate, caused page flicker, and broke my mobile page for half my visitors. I replaced them with Insighter purely because someone in a thread mentioned it did not have the script weight problem. My mobile load times recovered, the flicker disappeared, and I finally had AB test data I could actually trust to remove friction.

  1. ) The packaging trick that makes your brand feel premium for way less: To create a branded experience for your audience, don't buy products in bulk, buy packaging in bulk instead. It is a much cheaper way to make your brand feel premium and consistent.

  2. ) One font swap and my store suddenly looked expensive: If your website looks cluttered and unprofessional, change your font to Futura to make your website feel more premium and branded. It is very similar to the font used by Louis Vuitton. If your theme doesn't support it, use Afacad, which has a very similar look.

  3. ) The pricing trick that quietly pulls in more Shopping clicks: If you are doing Google Shopping ads, one way to increase clicks is by offering variants and pricing one of the less desirable variants cheaper than the others.

  4. ) How delivery delays turned into repeat customers instead of refund requests: Keep healthy margins and offer partial refunds for delays. It helps solve delivery issues and can turn frustrated customers into customers with a memorable experience.

  5. ) The simple fix that stopped my checkout from leaking easy sales every single day: Guessing how to recover lost sales leaves money on the table. I started using a smart AI tool that reviews the store 24/7 and flags the exact things costing me sales, like a missing upsell widget, so I just review and approve the fix instead of digging for it myself. Celirox does this well for us, link is below. Running these recommendations through it got me:

  • an 18% conversion boost
  • a 22% increase in average order value
  • a 26% jump in repeat purchases
  1. ) The retention move that let me spend more on ads and still stay profitable: Acquisition gets all the attention, but retention is where the actual margin compounds. I stopped treating the purchase as the end of the funnel. We ended up using GetJacked to run the actual points, referral, and VIP tier mechanics instead of building it ourselves, it just handles the plumbing and stays out of the way. Launching a straightforward loyalty and referral program naturally increased the lifetime value of every customer, meaning I could afford to spend more to acquire them in the first place.

  2. ) The $150.8k email flow I set up once: In the last 12 months, email alone generated $150.8k out of $554.6k in revenue. Not by doing anything fancy. Just by automating what already works like:

  • abandoned cart flows
  • welcome discounts
  • review request emails
  • product recommendations
  • happy customer proof
  • back in stock notifications

Simple. Predictable. Compounding.

I used to run my stores with multiple apps. One for flows, one for popups so I can collect their emails, one for reviews so I can collect reviews, one for wishlist and to send back in stock emails. Tabs everywhere. Different apps to write different emails. Branding never looked consistent. Frustration nonstop. Not to mention that monthly subscriptions for each app added up. So I built EmailWish because I just wanted one tool that did all this cleanly. No tech headaches. No connect this to that nonsense. Not even emails to write.

Simple systems scale. Noise wastes months.

Tl:Dr: Don't want to do anything yourself ?No worries !!! Just read below.
👉 Want to squeeze every penny out of your store ?
Use Celirox to automatically optimize your store.. 
👉Want to a/b test to find out what converts and what doesn’t ?
Use Insighter to run a/b tests to see what works  
👉Want the exact email flows that generated $150.8k in sales?
Install EmailWish — Shopify App for Abandoned cart & email flows already built in
👉Want customers to keep coming back and increase lifetime value?
Use GetJacked to launch points, rewards, referrals, VIP tiers, and customer loyalty programs without the complexity. 

If you want, drop your store.
I’ll tell you what ads + email setups would work for you.

u/AnabelBain — 3 days ago

Why isn't there a cross-promotion network for Shopify apps?

We have helped many apps grow and realized it's a huge issue. Ads are becoming expensive and out of budget for most of the apps. Many big brands spend thousands on partner ships. Yet there is no platform for it.

Every app wants more users.

Yet almost nobody is helping each other grow.

Instead, everyone spends money on ads, SEO, sponsorships, or content while thousands of potential partnerships never happen.

So we built a cross-promotion network.

Here's how it works:

• Add a small "Recommended Apps" section inside your app.
• Other participating apps are automatically rotated in that space.
• Your app gets shown inside their apps as well.
• More participating apps = more exposure for everyone.

No manual outreach.
No partnership negotiations.
No swapping banners every week.

The goal is to make app discovery feel more like a network instead of everyone competing alone.

50 free spots left and you get only 24 hours to activate it. Once 24 hours are over, you can never claim the free forever spot.

https://www.heyquarry.com/

u/AnabelBain — 10 days ago

Why isn't there a cross-promotion network for Shopify apps?

https://preview.redd.it/vy2flnsz0p9h1.png?width=1627&format=png&auto=webp&s=8b763c519f592a1deebb52eaf73caa576dc16049

We have helped many apps grow and realized it's a huge issue. Ads are becoming expensive and out of budget for most of the apps. Many big brands spend thousands on partner ships. Yet there is no platform for it.

Every app wants more users.

Yet almost nobody is helping each other grow.

Instead, everyone spends money on ads, SEO, sponsorships, or content while thousands of potential partnerships never happen.

So we built a cross-promotion network.

Here's how it works:

• Add a small "Recommended Apps" section inside your app.
• Other participating apps are automatically rotated in that space.
• Your app gets shown inside their apps as well.
• More participating apps = more exposure for everyone.

No manual outreach.
No partnership negotiations.
No swapping banners every week.

The goal is to make app discovery feel more like a network instead of everyone competing alone.

50 free spots left and you get only 24 hours to activate it. Once 24 hours are over, you can never claim the free forever spot.

https://www.heyquarry.com/

reddit.com
u/AnabelBain — 10 days ago

We built a HeyMantle alternative focusing more on growth because getting installs is still the hardest part.

https://preview.redd.it/x9wvw4sco99h1.png?width=2217&format=png&auto=webp&s=807ecf6e9936363b9e001a2e9cea564683f42b0e

Like many Shopify app founders, we were caught off guard by the HeyMantle announcement.

We started looking for alternatives and quickly realized we'd probably end up building something ourselves anyway.

The thing is, most app founders don't struggle with finding dashboards.

They struggle with growth.

Getting installs is hard. Getting consistent installs is even harder.

So while building our replacement, we decided to focus on growth from day one.

We added an affiliate system and a cross-promotion network where apps can help drive installs for each other.

These are the core features we are focusing on

1. Affiliate Network (create your own affiliate program)
2. Cross promotion Network (Cross promote apps, apps keep auto rotating so every apps get a visibility boost )
3. Lifecycle emails. (Send emails when someone installs/uninstalls etc.

We're opening it up for free to the first 50 apps. In return, we ask founders to participate in the cross-promotion network so everyone benefits from it.

Honestly, we originally built this for ourselves because we needed it. Then a few other founders asked if they could use it too.

You can try it here
https://heyquarry.com/

reddit.com
u/AnabelBain — 12 days ago
▲ 132 r/DropshippingTips+1 crossposts

8 high-value tips you can easily implement right now that will guarantee a 3x increase in sales.

Few days ago someone here asked me how to increase sales for their store.
I responded quickly. In hindsight, it wasn’t the full answer.
I hate half-answers. So here are 8 high-value tips you can implement right now.

  1. If you're selling physical products, start with Google Shopping Ads.Why? Because Shopping Ads show your product, price, and store rating to people who are already searching with buying intent. They don’t need education. They don’t need storytelling. They just need to see: the product, the price, the store and click. Shopping Ads is the cleanest and most direct way to convert traffic when intent is high. Search ➜ see ➜ buy.
  2. To create a branded experience for your audience, don’t buy products in bulk, buy packaging in bulk instead. It’s a much cheaper way to make your brand feel premium and consistent.
  3. A/B test product pages   Insightful or any other similar app, it will help you increase your conversion rate by a lot.
  4. If your website looks cluttered and unprofessional, change your font to Futura to make your website feel more premium and branded. It’s very similar to the font used by Louis Vuitton. If your theme doesn’t support it, use Afacad, which has a very similar look.
  5. Use Email Wish to set up your flows automatically. You’ll get a complete email flow system that will 2x your sales without having to write a single email.
  6. Start retargeting ads with awareness objective instead of conversions. This will keep the cost down and convert much better. 
  7. Connect your store with Google Search Console to understand where your organic is traffic is coming from and what they are searching.
  8. Use  Lurk  to spy on competitor pricing and get alerts if they drop their price. This will help you keep a tab on your competitors and pivot away from a saturated product with no margins.
  9. Bonus tip, Use Celirox to continuously analyze your store and to optimize the conversion rate of your store without you having to do much.
  10. And a bonus 10th tip. Keep healthy margins and offer partial refunds for delays. It helps solve delivery issues and can turn frustrated customers into customers with a memorable experience.

TL:Dr: Don't want to do anything yourself? No worries. Just read below.

👉 Want to spy on your competitors and spot dying products quickly?
Install Lurk and get real time pricing alerts.

👉 Want to increase conversion rate automatically?
Use Insighter to run A/B tests to see what works.

👉 Want to create smart store workflows, upsells, and back-in-stock alerts ?
Use Celirox Store Operator to launch backend automations without coding.

👉 Want the exact email flows that generated $150.8k in sales?
Install EmailWish — Shopify App for Abandoned cart & email flows already built in.

👇👇👇👇 If you want, drop your store below. I'll tell you what ads and email setups would work for you.

u/AnabelBain — 22 days ago
▲ 101 r/Dropshipping_Guide+1 crossposts

7 high-value tips you can easily implement right now that will guarantee a 3x increase in sales.

Few days ago someone here asked me how to increase sales for their store.
I responded quickly. In hindsight, it wasn’t the full answer.
I hate half-answers. So here are 7 high-value tips you can implement right now.

  1. To create a branded experience for your audience, don’t buy products in bulk, buy packaging in bulk instead. It’s a much cheaper way to make your brand feel premium and consistent.
  2. A/B test product pages   Insightful or any other similar app, it will help you increase your conversion rate by a lot.
  3. If your website looks cluttered and unprofessional, change your font to Futura to make your website feel more premium and branded. It’s very similar to the font used by Louis Vuitton. If your theme doesn’t support it, use Afacad, which has a very similar look.
  4. Use Email Wish to set up your flows automatically. You’ll get a complete email flow system that will 2x your sales without having to write a single email. 
  5. Start retargeting ads with awareness objective instead of conversions. This will keep the cost down and convert much better. 
  6. Connect your store with Google Search Console to understand where your organic is traffic is coming from and what they are searching.
  7. Use  Lurk  to spy on competitor pricing and get alerts if they drop their price. This will help you keep a tab on your competitors and pivot away from a saturated product with no margins.
  8. Use Formiva to collect customer feedback before they purchase and improve your ads. Its AI survey creation helps you dial in your target audience faster.
  9. And a bonus 8th tip. Keep healthy margins and offer partial refunds for delays. It helps solve delivery issues and can turn frustrated customers into customers with a memorable experience.

If you want, drop your store.

I’ll tell you what  setup would work for you.

u/AnabelBain — 1 month ago

If you want to make over $52,341/month, STOP CHASING GURUS

TL:DR; 5 Step process

  • Feedback  →  tells you what’s wrong  →   Use Formiva to create forms quickly
  • Testing  →  validates what actually  works  →  Use Insighter to run a/b tests to see what works  
  • Competitors  →  help you track positioning, pricing, and market saturation  →  Use Lurk to check competitor pricing.  
  • Retargeting ads  →  keep your brand familiar before people are ready to buy   →   Choose Awareness in facebook as goal & google
  • Email  →  helps you retarget, recover lost visitors, and build loyalty  →  Use Emailwish to automatically setup exact email flows I used to generate $150.8k from email. ( don’t let its low rating fool you, it’ works well)

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Background

I was one of those fools who thought  dropshipping was luck

Find a winning product, scale to the moon, buy a Lambo. Simple.

That was the dream lol, but reality was very different.

Most of my stores failed. Ads, Shopify fees, and dozens of apps slowly drained money while I kept chasing “winning products” and following generic guru advice.

Eventually I realized most of the advice was just recycled theories made to sell courses.

Ads and demand still matter, but after a point you need to stop relying on generic advice and start understanding why people actually buy.

-------------------------------------------------------------

1. Stage 1 (~2 minute ) : Fixed my ads (based on real objections)

So instead of guessing, I started asking.

Added a short flow before/after purchase with questions like:

  • what made you click this ad?
  • what almost stopped you from buying?
  • what were you looking for?

Nothing fancy, but the answers gave me real insights.

If you are unsure on what kind of questions to ask, just use something like Formiva. It has great templates to get you started. 
Offer a small incentive like a discount to get engagement.

From the data i collected, I realized people kept saying:

“not sure if this works” That made me realize my ads lacked trust.

So I started showing ads with:

  • UGC
  • before/after
  • proof-based ads

Simple changes based on actual feedback, not theories.

-------------------------------------------------------------

2. Stage 2 (~2 minute ): Fixed my product page through testing

A lot of people said:

“shipping feels too long”

So I didn’t touch the price, I didn’t optimize ads, I tested a few UI design changes. 

  • made delivery timelines clear above the fold
  • added “arrives by”
  • reviews position

Small changes, nothing ground breaking which increased checkout rate from ~0.9% to ~1.4%.

Used a simple A/B testing app to run clean tests without messing data. Many different A/B Testing apps in the market but I found insighter, with most relaxed limits in the free plan.

New apps generally have very good limits in the free plan and that’s the best time to use them ;)

-------------------------------------------------------------

3. Stage 3 (~1 minute ): Started keeping a tab on my competitor pricing.

This one sounds obvious now, but I used to constantly check competitor stores for pricing manually every other day.

Eventually I just set up competitor tracking on Lurk  and enabled alerts instead. There are many apps out there, this was the only one I found with real time alerts included in the free plan.

Way less mental overhead and honestly, it helped more with positioning than copying prices

A few times competitors started pushing aggressive discounts, so instead of joining a race to the bottom, I changed the ad angle and emphasized quality and reviews instead.

And when margins became too thin, I moved on before wasting more money on ads.

Honestly, competitor tracking is one of the easiest ways to understand when a market is becoming saturated.

-------------------------------------------------------------

4. Stage 4  (5 ~ 10 minute ) : Fixed retargeting

Most people don’t buy on the first visit. That’s normal.

But a lot of stores either ignore retargeting or run it poorly.

I know showing ads 10–11 times can get expensive, but that’s why retargeting ads on facebook and google should usually be impression/awarness-based, not conversion-based. Your ads were already optimized for conversions the first time, no need to optimize it again while retargeting.

Awareness based ads are generally much cheaper than conversion based ads. This will help you bring your conversion rate from 1.4~1.5% to easily  2~ 2.2%

-------------------------------------------------------------

5. Stage 5  (30 sec ~ 1 minute ) : Retargeting & Improving brand loyalty (through emails)

Once you are done with retargeting ads, you need a cheaper and more scalable way to keep reaching those users and that is through email !!

Most people think email marketing means blasting campaigns to purchased lists. That’s usually where stores go wrong.

The real value comes from automated emails (flows) triggered by user behavior:

  • Welcome Series→ introduce your brand and build trust
  • Abandoned cart Series→ recover lost checkouts
  • Review request Series→ build social proof for future buyers
  • Post-purchase Series→ increase repeat purchases and loyalty

There are many more flows but these are enough to get you started. For email marketing, there are quite a few apps but If you don’t want to write any emails and get started with essential flows I will recommend   Emailwish ( don’t let its low rating fool you, it’ works well) 

Emails will help you increase your conversion rate from ~2.2 % to around 2.8% ~ 3%

-------------------------------------------------------------

Over time, I realized the stores performing best weren’t just running ads better.

They had better systems. Miss one part of the system, and results become unpredictable.

To summarize 

  • Feedback  →  tells you what’s wrong  →   Use Formiva to create forms quickly
  • Testing  →  validates what actually  works  →  Use Insighter to run a/b tests to see what works  
  • Competitors  →  help you track positioning, pricing, and market saturation  →  Use Lurk to check competitor pricing.  
  • Retargeting Ads  →  keep your brand familiar before people are ready to buy   →   Choose Awareness in facebook as goal & google
  • Email  →  helps you retarget, recover lost visitors, and build loyalty  →  Use Emailwish to automatically setup exact email flows I used to generate $150.8k from email. Despite it's poor rating, it works
u/AnabelBain — 2 months ago

Built an adaptive MTA deliverability & reputation management system for ESP operations.

Built an adaptive MTA operations & deliverability platform focused on automation first, while still keeping every layer configurable.

Features include:

  • Automated bounce intelligence with pattern-based classification, throttling, suppression, retries, and provider-aware actions
  • Dynamic IP warmup engine with growth/decay logic based on real delivery utilization and deferral signals
  • Adaptive throttling/backoff that reacts to ISP behavior, temporary blocks, complaint spikes, and rate limits in real time
  • Automated IP pool reputation management with scoring, promotion/demotion rules, and pool isolation
  • ISP intelligence dashboards with provider-level delivery, bounce, and defer analytics
  • Traffic shaping, routing, and queue orchestration across domains, IPs, and providers
  • Multi-tenant ESP operations tooling with centralized monitoring, logging, and policy control
  • Fully configurable override system, every automated decision can still be manually tuned when needed

The goal was to reduce manual operational overhead while still giving deliverability teams full control over infrastructure behavior.

Do you think you would be interested in something like this?

u/AnabelBain — 2 months ago

Hi guys, over the last couple of years, we ended up building our own MTA management layer focused on deliverability, reputation recovery, IP warmup, ISP-specific throttling, and automated traffic routing.

The easiest way to describe it is probably: imagine a PMTA console manager on 100x steroids.

Right now we’re still relatively small, handling roughly around a million emails, but the system has been performing surprisingly well for us, especially compared to the amount of manual work we used to do before.

The interesting part is that most of the logic is fully automated. Instead of static rules and fixed warmup schedules, the system continuously reacts to ISP behavior, bounce spikes, throttling patterns, and reputation signals in real time.

We’ve been considering whether there would actually be interest in this kind of system if we cleaned it up properly. Potentially open-sourcing parts of it, while maybe offering a paid hosted/enterprise version later on.

Some of the things it currently handles:

1. Smart IP Warmup

When you get a new IP address, you cannot send 1 million emails on the first day. You have to "warm it up" so providers like Gmail or Yahoo trust you.

  • Per ISP: Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, etc. are all warmed separately because each provider behaves differently.
  • Success-Based Scaling: Instead of blindly increasing volume every day, limits only increase if delivery health remains good and a minimum % of capacity was utilized.
  • Automatic Decay Handling: If traffic stops for a few days, the system slows things back down automatically to safely re-warm the IP.

https://preview.redd.it/d6he5ycd3rzg1.png?width=2528&format=png&auto=webp&s=9cf4e712dd652e5323c2a78e8d72bf979e93c7e7

2. Bounce-Based Actions

A bounce is when an email cannot be delivered, which hurts sender reputation.

The system monitors bounce/error patterns continuously and reacts automatically:

  • Throttle: Slow down sending to a provider
  • Suspend: Pause sending temporarily if errors become serious
  • Redirect: Shift traffic to safer IPs while recovery happens.

https://preview.redd.it/g8wcx3a43rzg1.png?width=2537&format=png&auto=webp&s=cbe5c6fcfa438dc4a7fc3d14cb3a4aefbf761722

3. Reputation-Based IP Pools

Not all IPs are treated equally.

  • High Reputation Pool: Reserved for the cleanest traffic/senders
  • Warmup Pool: For newer IPs still building trust
  • Recovery Pool: For IPs that need slower traffic and recovery time

The main goal was basically to build a more self-healing infrastructure where the MTA layer can make intelligent decisions automatically instead of relying on constant manual intervention.

We’ve been debating whether it makes more sense to:

  • Open-source it: potentially build reputation in the email infrastructure space, contribute something useful to the community, and hopefully bring in clients for our main business.
  • License/self-host it: similar to enterprise infrastructure software, where companies can run it themselves while creating an additional revenue stream for us.
  • Offer a hosted enterprise version: where we manage the infrastructure layer entirely.

What people running serious email infrastructure would prefer?

reddit.com
u/AnabelBain — 2 months ago

Due to recent spam, app promotions are no longer allowed unless you’ve already been verified by the mods.
This was one of the few places that allowed free app sharing, but we have to tighten things up.
We’re not accepting new verification requests for now.
Unverified promotional posts will be removed, and offenders will be banned.

reddit.com
u/AnabelBain — 2 months ago

My first Shopify store didn’t “struggle”… it failed.

Not in a dramatic way, but in that slow, frustrating way where you’re doing everything right on paper and still losing money every week.

I tested products, worked on creatives, optimized the product page, tweaked ads over and over… and yet nothing really clicked. Some days were okay, but there was no consistency, no predictability, no real growth.

At the time, I was convinced the problem had to be external. Maybe the product wasn’t good enough, maybe the market was too saturated, maybe my ads just needed more optimization.

Looking back, none of that was the real issue.

The actual problem

I didn’t understand my customers at all.

Every single person who landed on my store saw the exact same thing, got the exact same message, and was pushed toward the exact same offer. In other words, I was treating completely different people as if they were identical.

Which meant that everything I was doing was based on assumptions.

I was guessing what they wanted, guessing what mattered to them, guessing what would convince them to buy.

And most of the time, I was wrong.

What I changed for my second store

For my second store, I made a very simple but uncomfortable shift: I stopped trying to sell immediately, and I focused first on understanding who was actually in front of me.

Instead of sending traffic directly to a product page, I added a conversational step before the offer. Not a boring survey, but something that actually felt like a guided flow where the customer could express what they were looking for.

That one change ended up making a bigger difference than anything else I had tried before.

What I started collecting (and why it matters)

Before that, the only thing I was collecting was name and email, which sounds useful but is basically useless if your goal is to actually convert.

This time, I focused on information that directly impacts buying decisions.

I started understanding what people were really looking for, not just what product they clicked on. I added questions that gave context about their situation, so I could differentiate between someone just exploring and someone who was ready to buy.

I also paid attention to their main problem or goal, because that’s what should drive your messaging, not your product features.

And maybe most importantly, I started getting signals about budget, expectations, and urgency, which completely changes how you should present an offer.

What this changed in practice

The biggest difference wasn’t just “more data”, it was how that data changed everything downstream.

First, my messaging became way more precise because I wasn’t guessing anymore. I could literally see patterns in what people were saying and adjust accordingly.

Second, my offers became more relevant. Instead of showing the same thing to everyone, I could adapt the experience based on what the user actually needed.

Third, my conversion rate improved, not because I “optimized a button”, but because the whole experience felt more aligned with the person going through it.

And finally, I stopped wasting traffic. I wasn’t trying to force every visitor into the same funnel anymore.

Important: this only works if the form is actually useful

A lot of people misunderstand this part and think “okay I’ll just add more questions”.

That’s not the point.

If your form feels long, irrelevant, or disconnected from the experience, people will drop instantly.

The key is that every question should feel logical and should influence what happens next. Otherwise, you’re just collecting data for no reason and creating friction.

How I set it up

I used Formiva to build those conversational flows, mainly because it made it easy to structure questions in a way that adapts to each user instead of forcing everyone through the same path.

What mattered to me wasn’t “having a form”, but being able to turn user input into something actionable, without ending up with messy data and manual work behind the scenes.

The real takeaway

Most Shopify stores are trying to scale while still guessing who their customers are.

That’s the real bottleneck.

You don’t necessarily need more traffic, better creatives, or a new product.

You need to understand the people you’re already getting in front of.

Because once you do that, everything else becomes easier: your messaging gets sharper, your offers make more sense, and your conversions improve naturally.

My first store failed because I was guessing.

My second one worked because I stopped guessing and actually listened. If you want to quickly get some feedback from real visitors I would suggest try👉Formiva on Shopify (No Code)

Curious what’s something you wish you knew about your customers before they decide to buy?

reddit.com
u/AnabelBain — 2 months ago

I run a Shopify store doing around $18k/month with a pretty messy catalog, lots of variants, non-standard products, the kind of setup that works fine early on but gets harder to manage as you grow.

At some point, growth started slowing down. I assumed it was a traffic issue, so I pushed ads harder, tested creatives, tweaked landing pages… the usual stuff.

But something didn’t add up. People were coming to the site, they just weren’t finding what they were looking for.

 

So I started digging into search, and honestly it was worse than I expected.

People were typing really specific things like “lightweight packable rain jacket” or exact color combinations, and the results were just… off.

Not completely broken, but wrong enough that you’d leave.

 

The weird part was, we actually had those products.

Search just didn’t understand the catalog.

 

While looking into this, I came across a case study on Cotopaxi.

Their catalog is even more complex:

products made from repurposed materials
every item slightly different
colors varying per piece

They were using Fast Simon and ran into the same issue.

At one point, they even considered building something custom on   Google Vertex AI , but that’s a whole project on its own.

 

Instead, they switched to something already built on top of it and saw:

+44.78% higher search conversion
~29% better relevance
~98% accurate results

 

That’s what made me take this seriously.

I ended up doing something similar, switched our store to Retail Cloud Connect and got it live in about 3 days.

Didn’t touch ads or funnels, just fixed product discovery.

 

Within a few weeks, revenue went from about $18.4k → $22.1k/month.

No extra ad spend.

 

We didn’t change pricing.
We didn’t change creatives.

People were already telling us what they wanted, search was just failing them.

reddit.com
u/AnabelBain — 2 months ago