How do I tell whether its time to give up on my ex and move on
I know this is something pretty cliche that a lot of people end up asking post breakup, but I honestly need to ask this if I want a chance to move on. A while ago, I got dumped by a girlfriend of 4 years. It was incredibly painful as I'm young, she was my first serious relationship, and I had believed she was the one(like I said this is pretty cliche, I'm not breaking any new ground here). We stayed in contact for about a month, realized our feelings weren't going to disappear if we were still in contact, and then went no contact for a period of 3 weeks with hopes of rebuilding a friendship after as we still wanted to be in each others lives. By the time we started talking again, I was genuinely getting ready to move on, work on myself, and open up to the possibility of trying again with someone new(not exactly looking for love, but being open to it again).
However, when we started talking again, I felt myself starting to "relapse". Not because I was still pining over her, but because I got the sense a part of her still wanted to be with me. It isnt exactly obvious, so I'll give a list of signs that she does want to be with me, and a list of things to make me think the opposite
Positive signs:
- One night when we were talking and getting vulnerable, she broke into tears and said she missed me. Later that night she said she loves me(I took it as a platonic type of love so not really a silver bullet), and when I said it back she asked "As a friend right?" in a somewhat hopeful tone and seemed disappointed when I answered yes. Do take my reading of her tone with a HUGE grain of salt though because I could just be hearing what I want to hear
- She has admitted that she's had a hard time adjusting to finding other people attractive
- Whenever we reminisce, she tends to get emotional which sometimes leads me to think she's still emotionally attached
- She once said she hopes things work out between us in the long run, but she specifically said "a long time from now". It seems like an orange flag to me, because it makes me feel like she just wants to explore other options
- We sometimes get pretty flirty when we talk
Negative signs:
- She acts hot and cold. One time she acknowledged it and told me its because acting cold to me makes it easier for her to move on, but I'm not sure if I believe that.
- Someone asked her out not long after the breakup when we were in no contact. She said she considered it, but she ultimately rejected him so again its kind of an orange flag
- While the relationship wasn't perfect, the majority of the problems we had were external and out of our control. I truly believe that if you took off even some of the external pressure that was on the relationship, it could have worked out.
- Obviously the biggest sign is that she hasn't asked to try again
This is really tough, because I'm not even sure if I should move on anymore. Right now my two options are
- Commit to moving on, but risk permanently losing this relationship when theres still a chance it could work out.
- Try to rekindle the relationship, but risk ultimately prolonging the heartbreak for no real reason
Any advice is welcome. Please help me out