Login

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516

r/wilco r/petergabriel r/theverve r/PaulMcCartney r/Genesis r/neworder r/Muse r/elbowmusic r/AlignmentChartFills r/yesband r/philcollins
▲ 21 r/philcollins

What is your favourite Phil Collins album?

  1. Face Value (1981)

Includes: In the Air Tonight, I Missed Again, If Leaving Me is Easy

  1. Hello, I Must Be Going! (1982)

Includes: You Can't Hurry Love, I Don't Care Anymore

  1. No Jacket Required (1985)

Includes: Sussudio, One More Night, Don't Lose My Number, Take Me Home

  1. But Seriously (1989)

Includes: Something Happened on the Way to Heaven, Another Day in Paradise, I Wish it Would Rain Down, Hang in Long Enough

  1. Both Sides (1993)

Includes: Both Sides of the Story, Everyday, We Wait and We Wonder

  1. Dance into the Light (1996)

Includes: Dance into the Light, Wear My Hat, Lorenzo, It's In Your Eyes

  1. Testify (2002)

Includes: Can't Stop Loving You, Wake Up Call

  1. Going Back (2010)

Includes: (Love is Like A) Heatwave, Going Back

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 1 day ago
▲ 13 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #18 - Age of Consent

Age of Consent is the first track on New Order's second album, Power, Corruption and Lies.

What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here:

https://youtu.be/gG9fEaITgCk?si=lAs-2SUXV7rEcC7N

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Overall Average Score: 7.69/10)

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial - 7.2

1981 - 1982 B-Sides (Overall Average Score: 9.12/10)

Ceremony (Version 1) - 9.63

In A Lonely Place - 8.62

Ceremony (Version 2) - 9.76

Procession - 9.18

Everything's Gone Green - 9.31

Cries and Whispers - 9.41

Mesh - 7.98

Temptation - 9.95

Hurt - 8.26

Power, Corruption and Lies

Age of Consent -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 3 days ago
▲ 13 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #17 - Hurt

Hurt is the second track from New Order's fourth single, Temptation.

What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here:

https://youtu.be/CiZeUSkg35U?si=ZZ-Hsk4Fy3BnNoZG (7" Version)

https://youtu.be/vS0rSiVHqPw?si=htA2PzW72GFTKvjq (12" Version)

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Overall Average Rating: 7.69/10)

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial - 7.2

1981 - 1982 B-Sides

Ceremony (Version 1) - 9.63

In A Lonely Place - 8.62

Ceremony (Version 2) - 9.76

Procession - 9.18

Everything's Gone Green - 9.31

Cries and Whispers - 9.41

Mesh - 7.98

Temptation - 9.95

Hurt -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 4 days ago
▲ 15 r/wilco

Where should I go now in terms of their discography?

I posted here a while back, and decided to listen to Yankee Hotel Foxtrot, which I needed time at first to actually understand it (not in a bad way, if an album confuses me like that, it means it's really good).

I followed this by listening to A Ghost is Born and that hit me instantly with those guitars and more looser playing.

Finally, I decided to finish with Sky Blue Sky, and this one was pretty solid, I was slightly disappointed as the change in style threw me off a little, but I overall enjoyed it.

With all of these in mind, I actually came back to each of them and listened to their tracks, my opinions changed on them, Yankee I completely understand now and is absolutely my favourite out of the 3, Ghost is second as some tracks I just can't get the feel of, I like them but I don't love them?, I think thats the same with Sky Blue Sky however the production on SBS is a little too dry and tight, I feel like it needs some of that looseness and I was missing the synths and other effects for this one,

however regardless of my placement they each have amazing songs: I Am Trying to Break Your Heart, Kamera, War on War, Ashes of American Flags, Jesus etc, I'm the Man Who Loves You, At Least That's What You Said, Hell is Chrome, Spiders (Kidsmoke), Hummingbird, Handshake Drugs, Theologians, Sky Blue Sky, Impossible Germany, You Are My Face, Hate it Here, Walken.

Overall, where should I go from here? I've listened to some tracks from Summerteeth, A.M, Self Titled, and the track Art of Almost.

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 6 days ago
▲ 10 r/petergabriel

Which Mix of i/o do you prefer?

I was just thinking as I'm listening to i/o more, and after listening to the Bright-Side Mix today, I overall prefer it.

It feels well... Brighter! and more alive and less of a sinister and dark as the Dark-Side Mix, which while is solid and was my favourite, I just feel the Bright Side suits the songs more, especially Olive Tree, Panopticom, and The Court, the only weak track I think on Bright Side is Road to Joy, Tchad's mixing feels a lot more pronounced and real on that one.

What do you guys think?

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 7 days ago
▲ 12 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #14 - Cries and Whispers

Cries and Whispers is the second track from New Order's third single, Everything's Gone Green.

What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here: https://youtu.be/Vh-7wOCfg1I?si=gru3cdYgGUhhRPht

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Overall Average Rating: 7.69/10)

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial - 7.2

1981 - 1982 B-Sides

Ceremony (Version 1) - 9.63

In A Lonely Place - 8.62

Ceremony (Version 2) - 9.76

Procession - 9.18

Everything's Gone Green - 9.31

Cries and Whispers -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 7 days ago
▲ 12 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #12 - Procession

Procession is New Order's second single. What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here: https://youtu.be/H-gNesiu56c?si=QBwN2k2tscuPeyB8

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Overall Average Rating: 7.69/10)

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial - 7.2

1981 - 1982 B-Sides

Ceremony (Version 1) - 9.63

In A Lonely Place - 8.62

Ceremony (Version 2) - 9.76

Procession -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 10 days ago
▲ 8 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #11 - Ceremony (Version 2)

Ceremony is the first track from New Order's first single, Ceremony / In a Lonely Place.

This is the second version of the single, released in September 1981 after Gillian Gilbert joined the band, and re-recorded the song with her added guitar parts.

What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here: https://youtu.be/ldxQA9W2474?si=uj545-U1lrrHyFI1

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Overall Average Score: 7.69/10)

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial - 7.2

1981 - 1982 B-Sides

Ceremony (Version 1) - 9.63

In A Lonely Place - 8.62

Ceremony (Version 2) -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 11 days ago
▲ 20 r/petergabriel

Heavily come around to Up + i/o

I was listening to a lot of the songs on these albums today, and something clicked. I'm not sure why, but I felt like I enjoyed them a whole lot more than a month back when I first listened to them, and posted my tierlist.

My favorite mix for i/o is the Dark Side Mix by far, I think it suits the album and PG's style a whole lot more, the album is a little too loud and in your face in my opinion, when I'm listening to the Bright Side, the DS Mix opens up the album and allows me to listen to the more intricate aspects and sounds more similar to how US sounds with its layers of sound, grand but also simultaneously subdued when it needs to be.

My favourites from UP are: Growing Up, Darkness, Sky Blue, I Grieve, Signal to Noise and More than This.

My favourites from i/o are: Panopticom, i/o, The Court, Olive Tree, Road to Joy, Playing For Time, Four Kinds of Horses.

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 11 days ago
▲ 7 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #10 - In A Lonely Place

In A Lonely Place is the second track from New Order's first single, Ceremony / In a Lonely Place.

This post will be covering two versions of the song, which are practically identical unlike Ceremony, which was re-recorded for the Ceremony single re-issue. The only difference is where the digital thunderclaps appear, and some mixing differences.

What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here: https://youtu.be/yqU0c9Hxaa4?si=dl6DZopi5ocX-SeJ (Original Release Mix)

https://youtu.be/I3qPo5ys_J4?si=x9DfNRJWaR2dqtAp (Ceremony Version 2 Re-issue Mix)

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Overall Average Score: 7.69 / 10)

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial - 7.2

1981 - 1982 B-Sides

Ceremony (Version 1) - 9.63

In a Lonely Place -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 12 days ago
▲ 3 r/philcollins

My Attempt at Re-Arranging and Changing Dance into the Light and Testify's tracklist.

This is a kind of follow up post to the last one about Dance and Testify, I had thought about doing this for a while, as both the albums could've been trimmed a little, and some B-Sides were better than the album tracks, I just did this with Genesis' We Can't Dance, and so after a few revisions here they are.

Dance into the Light

Original Run Time: 1 hour 33 seconds

🔽

New Run Time: 44 minutes 42 seconds

New Tracklist:

  1. Dance into the Light

  2. It's Everywhere (B-Side)

  3. It's in Your Eyes

  4. That's What You Said

  5. Love Police

  6. Wear My Hat

  7. Lorenzo

  8. No Matter Who

  9. The Same Moon

  10. Another Time (B-Side)

Testify

Original Run Time: 57 minutes 25 seconds

🔽

New Run Time: 49 minutes 58 seconds

New Tracklist:

  1. Wake Up Call

  2. Can't Stop Loving You

  3. Don't Get Me Started

  4. Testify

  5. It's Only Loving - Demo (2016 Deluxe Track)

  6. TV Story (2016 Deluxe Track)

  7. High Flying Angel (B-Side)

  8. The Least You Can Do

  9. Tearing and Breaking (From Love Songs Compilation)

  10. Thru My Eyes

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 13 days ago
▲ 91 r/petergabriel

First PG album I have on Vinyl

Just got a copy of US on vinyl, after wanting it for a long time, I already have it on CD along with Shaking the Tree and PG III / Melt.

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 14 days ago
▲ 15 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #8 - Denial

Denial is the eighth and final track from New Order's first studio album, Movement. What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here: https://youtu.be/UNwFlESWHnE?si=y8ABTmdsBUJuUmHx

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement

Dreams Never End - 9.08

Truth - 7.25

Senses - 7.5

Chosen Time - 7.85

ICB - 7.56

The Him - 6.67

Doubts Even Here - 8.42

Denial -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 14 days ago
▲ 14 r/Genesis

Attempt at Re-Arranging We Can't Dance's Tracklist.

I've always been annoyed at how bloated WCD is in both tracks and lengths of some songs, so I decided to re-arrange /change and cut down the length of the album by nearly 20 minutes.

Here's what I've come up with:

I re-titled the album to Fading Lights

  1. No Son of Mine

  2. Driving the Last Spike

  3. I Can't Dance

  4. Jesus He Knows Me

  5. On the Shoreline

  6. Living Forever

  7. Dreaming While You Sleep

  8. Fading Lights

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 14 days ago
▲ 2 r/elbowmusic

Elbow Album Tierlist

Audio Vertigo would be infront of Flying Dream 1, but behind Little Fictions.

Favourites from each:

Asleep - Powder Blue

Cast - Fugitive Motel

Leaders - Title Track

Seldom - The Loneliness of a Tower Crane Driver

Rocket - With Love

Taking Off - My Sad Captains

Fictions - Gentle Storm

Giants - Seven Veils / Dexter & Sinister

Flying - Six Words

Audio - Things I've Been Telling Myself For Years

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 18 days ago
▲ 3 r/elbowmusic

Info on the Mr. Soft / Soft era of the band?

Hi,

Does anyone have any info on this era of the band, as I'm curious, like photos, videos or if there were any tracks recorded under these names?

Thanks.

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 19 days ago
▲ 14 r/neworder

Daily Song Discussion #1 - Dreams Never End

Dreams Never End is the first track from New Order's first studio album, Movement. What do you think about the track both in general and in comparison to the rest of the band's discography, and how would you rate it out of 10 (decimals allowed)?

Listen Here: https://youtu.be/WS1X0EBlQ3Y?si=GZgRS-jfRKV702QE

Rating Scale:

1 - 4: Not Good, would skip.

5: Okay, but I would have to be in a specific mood to listen to it.

6: Slightly better than average, but I wouldn't choose to listen to it.

7: It's a good song, I can enjoy it quite a bit.

8 - 9: It's a really enjoyable song, I rank it pretty high overall.

10: Masterpiece and other associated terms.

Song Ratings:

Movement (Album)

Dreams Never End -

u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 23 days ago
▲ 15 r/neworder

Considering starting a Daily Song Discussion of NO tracks and B-Sides?

Hi,

Would anyone be interested in this idea?

Also, when calculating the scores for a song is it just the mean score or is there another way to work it out, this is just my first time doing this?

Thanks.

reddit.com
u/Beautiful_Gap_3516 — 24 days ago