Just completed the series. Here are my thoughts on it all
So overall I had a lot of fun watching the series. Id recommend it to others somewhere between my top 7-15.
Overall it had i think one of the better conclusions. The last conversation between Pope and J is spectacular. From the look on Hatosy's face when J said "you all deserve it for what you did to my mom". To J screaming "YOU DESERVED IT". To Popes breakdown when he pulls him out of the water saying "your mother was the strong one I was the weak one". Legit brought tears to my eyes.
However. The series and the finale as a whole is imperfect. Deran is a loose end, hes smart, he knows J, he learned from Smurf, and boy oh boy does he have a good reason for a Vendetta. But hes just. Alive. Gonna raise Nick? Thats all we know? Side note. Raising Nick is a huge development considering this story only plays out the way it does because he too abandoned his sisters kid. In a way a lesson was learned here. It wasnt long ago you could see J visibly angry when he had to tell Deran his nephews name cause he called him "the kid".
But let's start with the revolving door cast. That largely shot the series in the foot. So many story lines that ended up going nowhere because the actor wanted out. This is made obvious by the flashbacks. Which, while it was very useful in the final moments of showing what was done to Julia, most of the flashbacks were pointless. A way to keep smurfs presence alive long after the actress had left. But so much of it was unneeded and so many things were left untouched. Like. We get an ISNANE amount of character development for Manny, a character we literally never met. Yet, they dont introduce us to a young Cath and show us why Andrew felt she belonged with him. As a matter of fact. They dont show us a lot of people who claim to have known the boys since they were 16. Cath, Lucy, Angela. None of them show up in the flashbacks to the period they were allegedly a part of.
Last but not least. I think the series biggest failure is that they did not do enough to show Daren and Craig's culpability for Julia. It makes them seem like innocents caught in the crossfire of a war between J and Pope/Smurf/Baz. But Craig and Daren were both grown ass men hip to Smurfs bullshit and sick of it by the time Julia died. They left her hanging too and the flashbacks dont show that good enough
All and all. While I found the series to be kind of an exciting mesh of Sons of Anarchy meets Fast and Furious/oceans 11. I think id give the series an overall 7-8 out of 10. If they made it like 4 or 5 seasons and went with a faster pace a lot of stuff could be forgotten. But overall its one of the best series ive ever seen still. Top 15 for sure