Looking for 5 DMs to try a prototype fantasy town tool

Hi everyone! Im working on a hobby project, and I'm looking for 5 DMs who haven't seen it before to try an early prototype.

The idea is to help DMs model local events to determine how they would change a towns economy and prices, and use those consequences when preparing a session.

The current prototype tests a scenario orc raid near phandalin. You choose its timing and severity and compare the consequences and decide whether to apply thw result to your campaign.

It runs on a browser, you dont need spreadsheet or economics experience.

Im hoping for about 10 minutes exploring the prototype followed by a short questionairre.

Honest criticism, including "I wouldn't use this" is helpful.

If youre interested, let me know and Ill sent you a link. New and experienced DMs both welcome.

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 11 days ago

Grateful for the rain today

It's my favorite kind of day so far, as far as weather anyway. gentle, consistent rain.

I was fired from my job today. My fault, in a way, too many dumb mistakes lately. I have a Dr's appointment today so that I can start figuring out what kind of issues are causing my performance to slip......but I didn't make it in time.

It's probably undiagnosed ADHD. I'm hoping to get answers soon. I'm hoping to have a new job even sooner.

But for now, at least I have the rain, a day off, and a dry porch on which to enjoy it.

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 1 month ago

All-Time NFC East 53-Man Roster (rough draft)

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, and I tried to consider the right balance of both.

This is a rough draft, make your cases for why you think certain players ive snubbed deserve to be here, I will consider them.;

Only each player's seasons with the Dallas Cowboys, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles and Washington franchise are considered.

Quarterbacks - 3

- Sammy Baugh - Washington (1937-1952)

- Roger Staubach - Dallas Cowboys (1969-1979)

- Sonny Jurgensen - Philadelphia Eagles (1957-1963); Washington (1964-1974)

Running Backs - 4

- Emmitt Smith - Dallas Cowboys (1990-2002)

- Steve Van Buren - Philadelphia Eagles (1944-1951)

- Frank Gifford - New York Giants (1952-1960, 1962-1964)

- Tony Dorsett - Dallas Cowboys (1977-1987)

Wide Receivers and Ends - 6

- Pete Pihos - Philadelphia Eagles (1947-1955)

- Charley Taylor - Washington (1964-1977)

- Bob Hayes - Dallas Cowboys (1965-1974)

- Del Shofner - New York Giants (1961-1967)

- Michael Irvin - Dallas Cowboys (1988-1999)

- Art Monk - Washington (1980-1993); Philadelphia Eagles (1995)

Tight Ends - 3

- Jason Witten - Dallas Cowboys (2003-2017, 2019)

- Pete Retzlaff - Philadelphia Eagles (1956-1966)

- Mark Bavaro - New York Giants (1985-1990); Philadelphia Eagles (1993-1994)

Offensive Tackles - 4

- Roosevelt Brown - New York Giants (1953-1965)

- Rayfield Wright - Dallas Cowboys (1967-1979)

- Bob Brown - Philadelphia Eagles (1964-1968)

- Lane Johnson - Philadelphia Eagles (2013-present)

Guards - 3

- Larry Allen - Dallas Cowboys (1994-2005)

- Zack Martin - Dallas Cowboys (2014-2024)

- Russ Grimm - Washington (1981-1991)

Centers - 2

- Mel Hein - New York Giants (1931-1945)

- Jason Kelce - Philadelphia Eagles (2011-2023)

Edge Rushers and Defensive Ends - 5

- Reggie White - Philadelphia Eagles (1985-1992)

- Michael Strahan - New York Giants (1993-2007)

- DeMarcus Ware - Dallas Cowboys (2005-2013)

- Andy Robustelli - New York Giants (1956-1964)

- Harvey Martin - Dallas Cowboys (1973-1983)

Interior Defensive Line - 4

- Bob Lilly - Dallas Cowboys (1961-1974)

- Randy White - Dallas Cowboys (1975-1988)

- Arnie Weinmeister - New York Giants (1950-1953)

- Fletcher Cox - Philadelphia Eagles (2012-2023)

Linebackers - 6

- Lawrence Taylor - New York Giants (1981-1993)

- Chuck Bednarik - Philadelphia Eagles (1949-1962)

- Chuck Howley - Dallas Cowboys (1961-1973)

- Chris Hanburger - Washington (1965-1978)

- Sam Huff - New York Giants (1956-1963); Washington (1964-1967, 1969)

- Harry Carson - New York Giants (1976-1988)

Cornerbacks - 5

- Deion Sanders - Dallas Cowboys (1995-1999); Washington (2000)

- Mel Renfro - Dallas Cowboys (1964-1977)

- Darrell Green - Washington (1983-2002)

- Everson Walls - Dallas Cowboys (1981-1989); New York Giants (1990-1992)

- Cornell Green - Dallas Cowboys (1962-1974)

Safeties - 4

- Emlen Tunnell - New York Giants (1948-1958)

- Jimmy Patton - New York Giants (1955-1966)

- Brian Dawkins - Philadelphia Eagles (1996-2008)

- Cliff Harris - Dallas Cowboys (1970-1979)

Special Teams - 4

- K David Akers - Washington (1998); Philadelphia Eagles (1999-2010)

- P Sean Landeta - New York Giants (1985-1993); Philadelphia Eagles (1999-2002, 2005)

- LS Zak DeOssie - New York Giants (2007-2019)

- KR/PR Brian Mitchell - Washington (1990-1999); Philadelphia Eagles (2000-2002); New York Giants (2003)

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 2 months ago
▲ 16 r/ftlgame

Best mods

I love this game. I recently tried the multiverse mod and did not like it.

My issue was that it didnt understand the design goals of the original game and made too many decisions outside the spirit of the original. No offense to those who like it.

Are there any mods that expand the game while understanding the original design intent?

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 2 months ago

All-Time Washington Commanders 53-Man Roster (Final Draft)

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, and I tried to consider the right balance of both.

I've taken your opinions from the rough draft post and implemented most of them.

Only each player’s contributions with the Commanders/skins are considered.

The most controversial change is probably Twrrion Arnold for Santana Moss. It felt wrong to not include both of them, but ultimately there are too. Many great WRs in Commanders history.

Quarterbacks

  1. Sammy Baugh - 1937-1952

  2. Sonny Jurgensen - 1964-1974

  3. Joe Theismann - 1974-1985

Wide Receivers and Ends

  1. Charley Taylor - 1964-1977

  2. Art Monk - 1980-1993

  3. Bobby Mitchell - 1962-1968

  4. Gary Clark - 1985-1992

  5. Wayne Millner - 1936-1941, 1945

  6. Terry McLaurin - 2019-present

Tight Ends

  1. Jerry Smith - 1965-1977

  2. Chris Cooley - 2004-2012

  3. Don Warren - 1979-1992

Running Backs

  1. John Riggins - 1976-1979, 1981-1985

  2. Cliff Battles - 1932-1937

  3. Larry Brown - 1969-1976

  4. Clinton Portis - 2004-2010

Offensive Line

  1. Turk Edwards - 1932-1940

  2. Joe Jacoby - 1981-1993

  3. Trent Williams - 2010-2019

  4. Jim Lachey - 1988-1995

  5. Russ Grimm - 1981-1991

  6. Dick Stanfel - 1956-1958

  7. Brandon Scherff - 2015-2021

  8. Len Hauss - 1964-1977

  9. Jeff Bostic - 1980-1993

Defensive Line and Edge Rushers

  1. Dexter Manley - 1981-1989

  2. Gene Brito - 1951-1953, 1955-1958

  3. Charles Mann - 1983-1993

  4. Ryan Kerrigan - 2011-2020

  5. Dave Butz - 1975-1988

  6. Diron Talbert - 1971-1980

  7. Jonathan Allen - 2017-2024

  8. Daron Payne - 2018-present

Linebackers

  1. Chris Hanburger - 1965-1978

  2. Sam Huff - 1964-1967, 1969

  3. London Fletcher - 2007-2013

  4. Wilber Marshall - 1988-1992

  5. Monte Coleman - 1979-1994

  6. Ken Harvey - 1994-1998

Cornerbacks

  1. Darrell Green - 1983-2002

  2. Champ Bailey - 1999-2003

  3. Pat Fischer - 1968-1977

  4. Mike Bass - 1969-1975

  5. Lemar Parrish - 1978-1981

  6. DeAngelo Hall - 2008-2017

Safeties

  1. Ken Houston - 1973-1980

  2. Sean Taylor - 2004-2007

  3. Paul Krause - 1964-1967

  4. Brig Owens - 1966-1977

Special Teams

  1. Ethan Albright - LS - 2001-2009

  2. Mark Moseley - K - 1974-1986

  3. Tress Way - P - 2014-present

  4. Brian Mitchell - KR/PR - 1990-1999

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 3 months ago
▲ 34 r/cowboys

All-Cowboys 53-Man Roster (Final Draft)

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, and I tried to consider the right balance of both.

I've taken your opinions from the rough draft post and implemented most of them. You've been really enjoyable to discuss this with. (Holy fuck were the Eagles fans the opposite)

Only each player’s contributions with the Dallas Cowboys are considered.

Quarterbacks - 3

  1. Roger Staubach - 1969-1979

  2. Troy Aikman - 1989-2000

  3. Danny White - 1976-1988

Running Backs and Fullbacks - 4

  1. Emmitt Smith - 1990-2002

  2. Tony Dorsett - 1977-1987

  3. Ezekiel Elliott - 2016-2022, 2024

  4. Daryl Johnston - 1989-1999

Wide Receivers - 6

  1. Michael Irvin - 1988-1999

  2. Bob Hayes - 1965-1974

  3. Drew Pearson - 1973-1983

  4. CeeDee Lamb - 2020-present

  5. Dez Bryant - 2010-2017

  6. Tony Hill - 1977-1986

Tight Ends - 3

  1. Jason Witten - 2003-2017, 2019

  2. Jay Novacek - 1990-1995

  3. Billy Joe DuPree - 1973-1983

Offensive Line - 10

  1. Rayfield Wright - OT - 1967-1979

  2. Larry Allen - G/T - 1994-2005

  3. Travis Frederick - C - 2013-2019

  4. Zack Martin - G - 2014-2024

  5. Erik Williams - OT - 1991-2000

  6. Ralph Neely - OT - 1965-1977

  7. Nate Newton - G/T - 1986-1998

  8. Tyron Smith - OT - 2011-2023

  9. Mark Stepnoski - C - 1989-1994, 1999-2001

  10. John Niland - G - 1966-1974

Defensive Line and Edge Rushers - 10

  1. Bob Lilly - DT - 1961-1974

  2. Randy White - DT - 1975-1988

  3. DeMarcus Ware - DE/OLB - 2005-2013

  4. Harvey Martin - DE - 1973-1983

  5. Ed “Too Tall” Jones - DE - 1974-1978, 1980-1989

  6. Charles Haley - DE/OLB - 1992-1996

  7. Micah Parsons - DE/OLB - 2021-2024

  8. DeMarcus Lawrence - DE - 2014-2024

  9. Jim Jeffcoat - DE - 1983-1994

  10. George Andrie - DE - 1962-1972

Linebackers - 6

  1. Chuck Howley - 1961-1973

  2. Lee Roy Jordan - 1963-1976

  3. Sean Lee - 2010-2020

  4. Eugene Lockhart - 1984-1990

  5. Bob Breunig - 1975-1984

  6. Ken Norton Jr. - 1988-1993

Cornerbacks - 5

  1. Mel Renfro - 1964-1977

  2. Deion Sanders - 1995-1999

  3. Everson Walls - 1981-1989

  4. Cornell Green - 1962-1974

  5. Dennis Thurman - 1978-1985

Safeties - 4

  1. Cliff Harris - 1970-1979

  2. Darren Woodson - 1992-2004

  3. Charlie Waters - 1970-1981

  4. Bill Bates - 1983-1997

Special Teams - 3

  1. L.P. Ladouceur - LS - 2005-2020

  2. Brandon Aubrey - K - 2023-present

Danny White serves as both the third quarterback and punter.

Deion Sanders serves as the primary punt and kick returner.

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 3 months ago

All-Time Washington Commanders/Redskins 53-Man Roster (rough draft)

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, and I tried to consider the right balance of both.

Only a player’s contributions with the commanders are considered. Players are listed with the years they played for the team

Feel free to pick this apart, let me know of any glaring omissions, it can be hard to find every player to research.

Quarterbacks - 3

- Sammy Baugh - 1937-1952

- Sonny Jurgensen - 1964-1974

- Joe Theismann - 1974-1985

Theismann over Mark Rypien: Rypien’s 1991 season and Super Bowl run were better than any single Theismann season, but Theismann gave Washington a much longer stretch of high-level quarterback play. He won an MVP, reached consecutive Super Bowls, provided real rushing value and remains the franchise’s career passing leader. Rypien had the higher one-year peak, but not enough sustained excellence to take the third quarterback spot.

Running Backs and Fullbacks - 4

- John Riggins - 1976-1979, 1981-1985

- Cliff Battles - 1932-1937

- Larry Brown - 1969-1976

- Clinton Portis - 2004-2010

Portis over Stephen Davis: Davis was the more imposing pure power runner at his best, but Portis carried a larger offensive burden for longer. Portis also separates himself as a blocker - he was one of the best pass-protecting backs of his era and routinely sacrificed his body to keep Washington’s quarterbacks upright. Davis was excellent, but Portis provided slightly more total value.

Wide Receivers and Ends - 6

- Charley Taylor - 1964-1977

- Art Monk - 1980-1993

- Bobby Mitchell - 1962-1968

- Gary Clark - 1985-1992

- Wayne Millner - 1936-1941, 1945

- Santana Moss - 2005-2014

Tight Ends - 3

- Jerry Smith - 1965-1977

- Chris Cooley - 2004-2012

- Don Warren - 1979-1992

Offensive Tackles - 4

- Turk Edwards - 1932-1940

- Joe Jacoby - 1981-1993

- Trent Williams - 2010-2019

- Jim Lachey - 1988-1995

The tackle group over Chris Samuels: Samuels was a six-time Pro Bowler and one of the franchise’s most dependable modern players. He did not miss because he lacked an all-time résumé - he missed because Washington is unusually loaded at tackle. Edwards was one of the NFL’s first dominant linemen, Jacoby was the defining Hog, Williams had the greatest physical talent and Lachey had the most dominant short peak. Samuels is probably the best player left off the entire roster.

Guards - 3

- Russ Grimm - 1981-1991

- Dick Stanfel - 1956-1958

- Brandon Scherff - 2015-2021

Centers - 2

- Len Hauss - 1964-1977

- Jeff Bostic - 1980-1993

Defensive Ends and Edge Rushers - 4

- Dexter Manley - 1981-1989

- Gene Brito - 1951-1953, 1955-1958

- Charles Mann - 1983-1993

- Ryan Kerrigan - 2011-2020

Defensive Tackles - 4

- Dave Butz - 1975-1988

- Diron Talbert - 1971-1980

- Jonathan Allen - 2017-2025

- Darryl Grant - 1981-1990

Linebackers - 6

- Chris Hanburger - 1965-1978

- Sam Huff - 1964-1967, 1969

- London Fletcher - 2007-2013

- Wilber Marshall - 1988-1992

- Monte Coleman - 1979-1994

- Ken Harvey - 1994-1998

Cornerbacks - 6

- Darrell Green - 1983-2002

- Champ Bailey - 1999-2003

- Pat Fischer - 1968-1977

- Mike Bass - 1969-1975

- Lemar Parrish - 1978-1981

- Joe Lavender - 1976-1982

Safeties - 4

- Ken Houston - 1973-1980

- Sean Taylor - 2004-2007

- Paul Krause - 1964-1967

- Brig Owens - 1966-1977

Special Teams - 4

- Mark Moseley - K - 1974-1986

- Tress Way - P - 2014-present

- Brian Mitchell - KR/PR - 1990-1999

- Ethan Albright - LS - 2001-2009

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 3 months ago

New York Giants All-Time 53-Man Roster

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, and I tried to consider the right balance of both.

Only a player’s contributions with the Giants are considered. Players are listed with the years they played for the team

Feel free to pick this apart, let me know of any glaring omissions, it can be hard to find every player to research.

Quarterbacks - 3

- Eli Manning - 2004-2019

- Y.A. Tittle - 1961-1964

- Phil Simms - 1979-1993

Running Backs - 4

- Frank Gifford - 1952-1960, 1962-1964

- Tiki Barber - 1997-2006

- Tuffy Leemans - 1936-1943

- Ken Strong - 1933-1935, 1939, 1944-1947

Wide Receivers and Ends - 6

- Amani Toomer - 1996-2008

- Del Shofner - 1961-1967

- Kyle Rote - 1951-1961

- Homer Jones - 1964-1969

- Ray Flaherty - 1929, 1931-1935

- Odell Beckham Jr. - 2014-2018

Tight Ends - 3

- Mark Bavaro - 1985-1990

- Bob Tucker - 1970-1977

- Howard Cross - 1989-2001

Offensive Line - 9

- OT Roosevelt Brown - 1953-1965

- C Mel Hein - 1931-1945

- G Chris Snee - 2004-2013

- OT Al Blozis - 1942-1944

- G/OT Jack Stroud - 1953-1964

- G Darrell Dess - 1959-1964, 1966-1969

- OT Jumbo Elliott - 1988-1995

- OT Brad Benson - 1978-1987

- C Bart Oates - 1985-1993

Defensive Line - 9

- DE Michael Strahan - 1993-2007

- DE Andy Robustelli - 1956-1964

- DT Arnie Weinmeister - 1950-1953

- DE Jim Katcavage - 1956-1968

- DE George Martin - 1975-1988

- DE/DT Leonard Marshall - 1983-1992

- DE/DT Justin Tuck - 2005-2013

- DE Osi Umenyiora - 2003-2012

- DT Rosey Grier - 1955-1962

Linebackers - 7

- OLB Lawrence Taylor - 1981-1993

- ILB Harry Carson - 1976-1988

- MLB Sam Huff - 1956-1963

- OLB Carl Banks - 1984-1992

- OLB Brad Van Pelt - 1973-1983

- OLB Jessie Armstead - 1993-2001

- OLB Brian Kelley - 1973-1983

Defensive Backs - 8

- S Emlen Tunnell - 1948-1958

- S Jimmy Patton - 1955-1966

- CB Richard Lynch - 1959-1966

- CB Erich Barnes - 1961-1964

- CB Mark Haynes - 1980-1985

- S Terry Kinard - 1983-1989

- S/CB Spider Lockhart - 1965-1975

- CB Corey Webster - 2005-2013

Special Teams - 4

- K Pete Gogolak - 1966-1974

- P Sean Landeta - 1985-1993

- LS Zak DeOssie - 2007-2019

- KR/PR Dave Meggett - 1989-1994

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 3 months ago

Dallas Cowboys All-Time 53-Man Roster (rough draft)

I thought you might like my rough draft "all Cowboys" team.

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, and I tried to consider the right balance of both.

Only a player’s contributions with the Cowboys are considered. Players are listed with the years they played for Dallas.

Feel free to pick this apart, let me know of any glaring omissions, it can be hard to find every player to research.

Quarterbacks - 3

  1. Roger Staubach (1969-1979)

  2. Troy Aikman (1989-2000)

  3. Dak Prescott (2016-present)

Running Backs and Fullbacks - 4

  1. Emmitt Smith (1990-2002)

  2. Tony Dorsett (1977-1987)

  3. Don Perkins (1961-1968)

  4. Daryl Johnston (1989-1999)

Wide Receivers - 6

  1. Michael Irvin (1988-1999)

  2. Bob Hayes (1965-1974)

  3. Drew Pearson (1973-1983)

  4. CeeDee Lamb (2020-present)

  5. Dez Bryant (2010-2017)

  6. Tony Hill (1977-1986)

Tight Ends - 3

  1. Jason Witten (2003-2017, 2019)

  2. Jay Novacek (1990-1995)

  3. Billy Joe DuPree (1973-1983)

Offensive Tackles - 4

  1. Rayfield Wright (1967-1979)

  2. Tyron Smith (2011-2023)

  3. Erik Williams (1991-2000)

  4. Ralph Neely (1965-1977)

Offensive Guards - 3

  1. Larry Allen (1994-2005)

  2. Zack Martin (2014-2024)

  3. Nate Newton (1986-1998)

Centers - 2

  1. Travis Frederick (2013-2019)

  2. Mark Stepnoski (1989-1994, 1999-2001)

Defensive Tackles - 3

  1. Bob Lilly (1961-1974)

  2. Randy White (1975-1988)

  3. Jethro Pugh (1965-1978)

Defensive Ends and Edge Rushers - 6

  1. DeMarcus Ware (2005-2013)

  2. Harvey Martin (1973-1983)

  3. Ed “Too Tall” Jones (1974-1978, 1980-1989)

  4. Charles Haley (1992-1996)

  5. Micah Parsons (2021-2024)

  6. Jim Jeffcoat (1983-1994)

Linebackers - 6

  1. Chuck Howley (1961-1973)

  2. Lee Roy Jordan (1963-1976)

  3. D.D. Lewis (1968-1981)

  4. Bob Breunig (1975-1984)

  5. Ken Norton Jr. (1988-1993)

  6. Dat Nguyen (1999-2005)

Cornerbacks - 5

  1. Mel Renfro (1964-1977)

  2. Deion Sanders (1995-1999)

  3. Everson Walls (1981-1989)

  4. Cornell Green (1962-1974)

  5. Dennis Thurman (1978-1985)

Safeties - 4

  1. Cliff Harris (1970-1979)

  2. Darren Woodson (1992-2004)

  3. Charlie Waters (1970-1981)

  4. Bill Bates (1983-1997)

Specialists - 4

  1. Dan Bailey - Kicker (2011-2017)

  2. Mat McBriar - Punter (2004-2011)

  3. L.P. Ladouceur - Long Snapper (2005-2020)

  4. Kelvin Martin - Kick/Punt Returner and Wide Receiver (1987-1992, 1996)

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 3 months ago

NFC West All-Time 53-man roster

I've spent time in all of your meatball subs having you guys destroy my karma in order to put this together. This is a rough draft of an NFC West all-time team.

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, although every player on this list had both.

In cases where I could not split hairs to make a decision, the tie-breaker was the most recent player. That only affected a few decisions on this list.

There are a couple of adjustments from your arguments on the rough draft, Terrell Owens moved up a couple of spots, Vernon Davis slides in at TE, and Chandler Jones edged out Nick Bksa for the final DE spot.

A lot of you wanted to see Kam Chancellor in at safety, but I still think he's quite a ways off the list.

Theres always at least 1 error and in this case its Torry Holt in the HoF and Steve Hutchinson who was a Seahawk.

u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 3 months ago

NFC West All-Time 53-Man Roster (rough draft)

I've spent time in all of your meatball subs having you guys destroy my karma in order to put this together. This is a rough draft of an NFC West all-time team.

Obviously, the players from today are better athletes than the part-time milkmen of the Halas era, but If I were to create a list based on who would be the best team played today, there would hardly be anyone prior to 2000 on this list. For this reason, to truly appreciate the greats, this list has been created primarily based on dominance over their peers, not who would play better in a game today.

Peak was considered along with longevity, although every player on this list had both.

In cases where I could not split hairs to make a decision, the tie-breaker was the most recent player. That only affected a few decisions on this list.

Feel free to make your case as to why you feel a certain player who was snubbed belonged and destroy my karma even further. I will consider your arguments and cone back with an improved list.

u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

NFC West All-Time 53-man roster (rough draft)

​

Quarterbacks

​

QB - Joe Montana - 49ers

​

QB - Steve Young - 49ers

​

QB - Kurt Warner - Rams

​

Wide Receivers

​

WR - Jerry Rice - 49ers

​

WR - Larry Fitzgerald - Cardinals

​

WR - Steve Largent - Seahawks

​

WR - Terrell Owens - 49ers

​

WR - Isaac Bruce - Rams

​

WR - Torry Holt - Rams

​

Tight Ends

​

TE - George Kittle - 49ers

​

TE - Jackie Smith - Cardinals

​

TE - Vernon Davis - 49ers

​

Running Backs

​

RB - Marshall Faulk - Rams

​

RB - Eric Dickerson - Rams

​

RB - Joe Perry - 49ers

​

RB - Ollie Matson - Cardinals

​

Offensive Line

​

LT - Orlando Pace - Rams

​

G - Steve Hutchinson - Seahawks

​

C - Kevin Mawae - Seahawks

​

G - Tom Mack - Rams

​

RT - Jackie Slater - Rams

​

T - Walter Jones - Seahawks

​

T - Dan Dierdorf - Cardinals

​

G - Randy Cross - 49ers

​

C - Rich Saul - Rams

​

Defensive Line

​

DT - Aaron Donald - Rams

​

DE - Deacon Jones - Rams

​

DT - Merlin Olsen - Rams

​

DL - Leo Nomellini - 49ers

​

DT - Cortez Kennedy - Seahawks

​

DE - Jack Youngblood - Rams

​

DL - Calais Campbell - Cardinals

​

DT - Bryant Young - 49ers

​

DE - Fred Dean - 49ers

​

Linebackers

​

LB - Patrick Willis - 49ers

​

LB - Bobby Wagner - Seahawks

​

LB - Dave Wilcox - 49ers

​

LB - Fred Warner - 49ers

​

LB - Les Richter - Rams

​

LB - Jack Pardee - Rams

​

Cornerbacks

​

CB - Dick "Night Train" Lane - Cardinals

​

CB - Aeneas Williams - Cardinals

​

CB - Jimmy Johnson - 49ers

​

CB - Richard Sherman - Seahawks

​

CB - Eric Wright - 49ers

​

Safeties

​

S - Ronnie Lott - 49ers

​

S - Larry Wilson - Cardinals

​

S - Kenny Easley - Seahawks

​

S - Earl Thomas - Seahawks

​

Special Teams

​

LS - Brian Jennings - 49ers

​

K - Jim Bakken - Cardinals

​

P - Johnny Hekker - Rams

​

KR - Tyler Lockett - Seahawks

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

NFC West all-time team 53-man roster rough draft.

NFC West All-Time 53-man roster (rough draft)

Quarterbacks

QB - Joe Montana - 49ers

QB - Steve Young - 49ers

QB - Kurt Warner - Rams

Wide Receivers

WR - Jerry Rice - 49ers

WR - Larry Fitzgerald - Cardinals

WR - Steve Largent - Seahawks

WR - Terrell Owens - 49ers

WR - Isaac Bruce - Rams

WR - Torry Holt - Rams

Tight Ends

TE - George Kittle - 49ers

TE - Jackie Smith - Cardinals

TE - Vernon Davis - 49ers

Running Backs

RB - Marshall Faulk - Rams

RB - Eric Dickerson - Rams

RB - Joe Perry - 49ers

RB - Ollie Matson - Cardinals

Offensive Line

LT - Orlando Pace - Rams

G - Steve Hutchinson - Seahawks

C - Kevin Mawae - Seahawks

G - Tom Mack - Rams

RT - Jackie Slater - Rams

T - Walter Jones - Seahawks

T - Dan Dierdorf - Cardinals

G - Randy Cross - 49ers

C - Rich Saul - Rams

Defensive Line

DT - Aaron Donald - Rams

DE - Deacon Jones - Rams

DT - Merlin Olsen - Rams

DL - Leo Nomellini - 49ers

DT - Cortez Kennedy - Seahawks

DE - Jack Youngblood - Rams

DL - Calais Campbell - Cardinals

DT - Bryant Young - 49ers

DE - Fred Dean - 49ers

Linebackers

LB - Patrick Willis - 49ers

LB - Bobby Wagner - Seahawks

LB - Dave Wilcox - 49ers

LB - Fred Warner - 49ers

LB - Les Richter - Rams

LB - Jack Pardee - Rams

Cornerbacks

CB - Dick "Night Train" Lane - Cardinals

CB - Aeneas Williams - Cardinals

CB - Jimmy Johnson - 49ers

CB - Richard Sherman - Seahawks

CB - Eric Wright - 49ers

Safeties

S - Ronnie Lott - 49ers

S - Larry Wilson - Cardinals

S - Kenny Easley - Seahawks

S - Earl Thomas - Seahawks

Special Teams

LS - Brian Jennings - 49ers

K - Jim Bakken - Cardinals

P - Johnny Hekker - Rams

KR - Tyler Lockett - Seahawks

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

NFC West All-time team, 53 man roster, rough draft.

Quarterbacks

QB - Joe Montana - 49ers

QB - Steve Young - 49ers

QB - Kurt Warner - Rams

​

Wide Receivers

WR - Jerry Rice - 49ers

WR - Larry Fitzgerald - Cardinals

WR - Steve Largent - Seahawks

WR - Terrell Owens - 49ers

WR - Isaac Bruce - Rams

WR - Torry Holt - Rams

​

Tight Ends

TE - George Kittle - 49ers

TE - Jackie Smith - Cardinals

TE - Vernon Davis - 49ers

​

Running Backs

RB - Marshall Faulk - Rams

RB - Eric Dickerson - Rams

RB - Joe Perry - 49ers

RB - Ollie Matson - Cardinals

​

Offensive Line

LT - Orlando Pace - Rams

G - Steve Hutchinson - Seahawks

C - Kevin Mawae - Seahawks

G - Tom Mack - Rams

RT - Jackie Slater - Rams

T - Walter Jones - Seahawks

T - Dan Dierdorf - Cardinals

G - Randy Cross - 49ers

C - Rich Saul - Rams

​

Defensive Line

DT - Aaron Donald - Rams

DE - Deacon Jones - Rams

DT - Merlin Olsen - Rams

DL - Leo Nomellini - 49ers

DT - Cortez Kennedy - Seahawks

DE - Jack Youngblood - Rams

DL - Calais Campbell - Cardinals

DT - Bryant Young - 49ers

DE - Fred Dean - 49ers

​

Linebackers

LB - Patrick Willis - 49ers

LB - Bobby Wagner - Seahawks

LB - Dave Wilcox - 49ers

LB - Fred Warner - 49ers

LB - Les Richter - Rams

LB - Jack Pardee - Rams

​

Cornerbacks

CB - Dick "Night Train" Lane - Cardinals

CB - Aeneas Williams - Cardinals

CB - Jimmy Johnson - 49ers

CB - Richard Sherman - Seahawks

CB - Eric Wright - 49ers

​

Safeties

S - Ronnie Lott - 49ers

S - Larry Wilson - Cardinals

S - Kenny Easley - Seahawks

S - Earl Thomas - Seahawks

​

Special Teams

LS - Brian Jennings - 49ers

K - Jim Bakken - Cardinals

P - Johnny Hekker - Rams

KR - Tyler Lockett - Seahawks

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

Seattle Seahawks All-time 53-man roster, final draft

1| Russell Wilson| QB| 2012–2021

2| Dave Krieg| QB| 1980–1991

3| Matt Hasselbeck| QB| 2001–2010

4| Steve Largent| WR| 1976–1989

5| Tyler Lockett| WR / KR / PR| 2015–2024

6| Jaxon Smith-Njigba| WR| 2023–present

7| DK Metcalf| WR| 2019–2024

8| Doug Baldwin| WR| 2011–2018

9| Brian Blades| WR| 1988–1998

10| Jimmy Graham| TE| 2015–2017

11| Itula Mili| TE| 1997–2006

12| Zach Miller| TE| 2011–2014

13| Mike Tice| TE| 1981–1988, 1990–1991

14| Shaun Alexander| RB| 2000–2007

15| Marshawn Lynch| RB| 2010–2015, 2019

16| Curt Warner| RB| 1983–1989

17| John L. Williams| RB / FB| 1986–1993

18| Mack Strong| FB| 1993–2007

19| Walter Jones| T| 1997–2009

20| Steve Hutchinson| G| 2001–2005

21| Kevin Mawae| C / G| 1994–1997

22| Max Unger| C| 2009–2014

23| Robbie Tobeck| C| 2000–2006

24| Bryan Millard| G| 1984–1991

25| Chris Gray| G / C| 1998–2007

26| Russell Okung| T| 2010–2015

27| Cortez Kennedy| DT| 1990–2000

28| Jacob Green| DE| 1980–1991

29| Joe Nash| DT| 1982–1996

30| Michael Sinclair| DE| 1992–2001

31| Jeff Bryant| DL| 1982–1993

32| Michael Bennett| DL| 2013–2017

33| Cliff Avril| DE| 2013–2017

34| Leonard Williams| DL / DT| 2023–present

35| Bobby Wagner| LB| 2012–2021, 2023

36| K.J. Wright| LB| 2011–2020

37| Chad Brown| LB| 1997–2004

38| Lofa Tatupu| LB| 2005–2010

39| Fredd Young| LB| 1984–1987

40| Rufus Porter| LB| 1988–1994

41| Richard Sherman| CB| 2011–2017

42| Dave Brown| CB| 1976–1986

43| Devon Witherspoon| CB| 2023–present

44| Marcus Trufant| CB| 2003–2012

45| Shawn Springs| CB| 1997–2003

46| Kenny Easley| S| 1981–1987

47| Earl Thomas| S| 2010–2018

48| Kam Chancellor| S| 2010–2017

49| Eugene Robinson| S| 1985–1995

50| Quandre Diggs| S| 2019–2023

51| Tyler Ott| LS| 2017–2021

52| Jason Myers| K| 2019–present

53| Michael Dickson| P| 2018–present

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

Seattle Seahawks all-time team. 53-man roster (rough draft)

​

1| Russell Wilson| QB| 2012–2021

2| Dave Krieg| QB| 1980–1991

3| Matt Hasselbeck| QB| 2001–2010

4| Steve Largent| WR| 1976–1989

5| Tyler Lockett| WR / KR / PR| 2015–2024

6| DK Metcalf| WR| 2019–2024

7| Doug Baldwin| WR| 2011–2018

8| Brian Blades| WR| 1988–1998

9| Darrell Jackson| WR| 2000–2006

10| Jimmy Graham| TE| 2015–2017

11| Itula Mili| TE| 1997–2006

12| Zach Miller| TE| 2011–2014

13| Mike Tice| TE| 1981–1988, 1990–1991

14| Shaun Alexander| RB| 2000–2007

15| Marshawn Lynch| RB| 2010–2015, 2019

16| Curt Warner| RB| 1983–1989

17| John L. Williams| RB / FB| 1986–1993

18| Mack Strong| FB| 1993–2007

19| Walter Jones| T| 1997–2009

20| Steve Hutchinson| G| 2001–2005

21| Kevin Mawae| C / G| 1994–1997

22| Max Unger| C| 2009–2014

23| Robbie Tobeck| C| 2000–2006

24| Bryan Millard| G| 1984–1991

25| Chris Gray| G / C| 1998–2007

26| Russell Okung| T| 2010–2015

27| Cortez Kennedy| DT| 1990–2000

28| Jacob Green| DE| 1980–1991

29| Joe Nash| DT| 1982–1996

30| Michael Sinclair| DE| 1992–2001

31| Jeff Bryant| DL| 1982–1993

32| Michael Bennett| DL| 2013–2017

33| Cliff Avril| DE| 2013–2017

34| Brandon Mebane| DT| 2007–2015

35| Bobby Wagner| LB| 2012–2021, 2023

36| K.J. Wright| LB| 2011–2020

37| Chad Brown| LB| 1997–2004

38| Lofa Tatupu| LB| 2005–2010

39| Fredd Young| LB| 1984–1987

40| Rufus Porter| LB| 1988–1994

41| Richard Sherman| CB| 2011–2017

42| Dave Brown| CB| 1976–1986

43| Marcus Trufant| CB| 2003–2012

44| Shawn Springs| CB| 1997–2003

45| Brandon Browner| CB| 2011–2013, 2018

46| Kenny Easley| S| 1981–1987

47| Earl Thomas| S| 2010–2018

48| Kam Chancellor| S| 2010–2017

49| Eugene Robinson| S| 1985–1995

50| Quandre Diggs| S| 2019–2023

51| Tyler Ott| LS| 2017–2021

52| Jason Myers| K| 2019–present

53| Michael Dickson| P| 2018–present

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

Arizona Cardinals All-Time 53-Man Roster (Final Draft)

​

1| QB| Kurt Warner| 2005–2009

2| QB| Jim Hart| 1966–1983

3| QB| Paddy Driscoll| 1920–1925

4| WR| Larry Fitzgerald| 2004–2020

5| WR| Roy Green| 1979–1990

6| WR| Anquan Boldin| 2003–2009

7| WR| Sonny Randle| 1959–1966

8| WR| Bobby Joe Conrad| 1958–1968

9| WR| DeAndre Hopkins| 2020–2022

10| TE| Jackie Smith| 1963–1977

11| TE| J.V. Cain| 1974–1978

12| TE| Trey McBride| 2022–Present

13| RB| Ollie Matson| 1952, 1954–1958

14| RB| Charley Trippi| 1947–1955

15| RB| Ottis Anderson| 1979–1986

16| RB| Terry Metcalf| 1973–1981

17| FB| Larry Centers| 1990–1998

18| RB| Marshall Goldberg| 1939–1943, 1946–1948

19| OT| Dan Dierdorf| 1971–1983

20| OT| Duke Slater| 1926–1931

21| G| Ken Gray| 1958–1969

22| OT| Luis Sharpe| 1982–1994

23| C/T| Stan Mauldin| 1946–1948

24| G| Conrad Dobler| 1972–1977

25| OT| Ernie McMillan| 1961–1974

26| C| Bob DeMarco| 1961–1973

27| DL| Calais Campbell| 2008–2016

28| DE| Chandler Jones| 2016–2021

29| DE| Simeon Rice| 1996–2000

30| DE| Freddie Joe Nunn| 1985–1993

31| DT| Darnell Dockett| 2004–2014

32| DT| Eric Swann| 1991–1999

33| DE| Curtis Greer| 1980–1987

34| DL| Bob Rowe| 1967–1975

35| LB| Larry Stallings| 1963–1976

36| LB| E.J. Junior| 1981–1988

37| LB| Karlos Dansby| 2004–2009, 2013, 2017

38| LB| Dale Meinert| 1958–1967

39| LB| Ken Harvey| 1988–1993

40| LB| Daryl Washington| 2010–2013

41| CB| Aeneas Williams| 1991–2000

42| CB| Dick "Night Train" Lane| 1954–1959

43| CB| Roger Wehrli| 1969–1982

44| CB| Patrick Peterson| 2011–2020

45| CB| Pat Fischer| 1961–1967

46| S| Larry Wilson| 1960–1972

47| S| Adrian Wilson| 2001–2012

48| S| Budda Baker| 2017–Present

49| S| Tim McDonald| 1987–1992

50| LS| Mike Leach| 2009–2015

51| K| Jim Bakken| 1962–1978

52| P| Scott Player| 1998–2006

53| KR/PR| Mel Gray| 1971–1982

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

Arizona Cardinals All-Time 53-Man Roster (rough draft)

​

Quarterbacks

QB1 – Kurt Warner (2005–2009)

QB2 – Jim Hart (1966–1983)

QB3 – Paddy Driscoll (1920–1925)

Running Backs / Fullbacks

RB1 – Ollie Matson (1952, 1954–1958)

RB2 – Charley Trippi (1947–1955)

RB3 – Ottis Anderson (1979–1986)

RB4 – John David Crow (1958–1964)

FB – Larry Centers (1990–1998)

Wide Receivers

WR1 – Larry Fitzgerald (2004–2020)

WR2 – Roy Green (1979–1990)

WR3 – Anquan Boldin (2003–2009)

WR4 – Sonny Randle (1959–1966)

WR5 – Bobby Joe Conrad (1958–1968)

WR6 – DeAndre Hopkins (2020–2022)

Tight Ends

TE1 – Jackie Smith (1963–1977)

TE2 – J.V. Cain (1974–1978)

TE3 – Trey McBride (2022–Present)

Offensive Line

LT – Dan Dierdorf (1971–1983)

RT – Duke Slater (1926–1931)

LT – Luis Sharpe (1982–1994)

T – Stan Mauldin (1946–1948)

LG – Ken Gray (1958–1969)

RG – Conrad Dobler (1972–1977)

OT – Ernie McMillan (1961–1974)

C – Bob DeMarco (1961–1973)

Defensive Line

DL – Calais Campbell (2008–2016)

DE – Chandler Jones (2016–2021)

DE – Simeon Rice (1996–2000)

DE – Freddie Joe Nunn (1985–1993)

DT – Darnell Dockett (2004–2014)

DT – Eric Swann (1991–1999)

DE – Curtis Greer (1980–1987)

DL – Bob Rowe (1967–1975)

Linebackers

LB – Larry Stallings (1963–1976)

LB – E.J. Junior (1981–1988)

LB – Karlos Dansby (2004–2009, 2013, 2017)

LB – Dale Meinert (1958–1967)

LB – Ken Harvey (1988–1993)

LB – Daryl Washington (2010–2013)

Cornerbacks

CB1 – Aeneas Williams (1991–2000)

CB2 – Dick "Night Train" Lane (1954–1959)

CB3 – Roger Wehrli (1969–1982)

CB4 – Patrick Peterson (2011–2020)

CB5 – Pat Fischer (1961–1967)

Safeties

S1 – Larry Wilson (1960–1972)

S2 – Adrian Wilson (2001–2012)

S3 – Budda Baker (2017–Present)

S4 – Pat Tillman (1998–2001)

Special Teams

LS – Mike Leach (2009–2015)

K – Jim Bakken (1962–1978)

P – Scott Player (1998–2006)

KR/PR – Mel Gray (1971–1982)

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 4 months ago

Feeling like life is harder since waking up.

Hey folks, does anyone else feel like sometimes life is harder since waking up?

Having changed my beliefs somewhat about what's most important in life and now wanting to take things slower, I can't help but feel like society kinda wont allow that.

I work a high pressure corporate job, I'm the sole provider for my family, and I dont have the ability to switch careers without completely upending their lives. We would lose the house.

Yet, since waking up, my motivation to work these extra hours to feed capitalist greed is completely gone. Im trying to change my mental focus to point out that im doing it in service to my family, which is an admirable thing, but Im just not able to turn that into the intense productivity thats needed.

Recently I messed up a few things and feel like im knocking on the door of getting fired. Not a good feeling.

Anyway, just opening up about it. I know there's a lot of advice out there that amounts to "just dont worry about it" but.....that lack of anxiety has consequences haha, and they led me to today, where now I have the anxiety again but also the consequences.

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 5 months ago

Rams All-Time 53 man roster

Quarterbacks

Kurt Warner — QB — (1998–2003)

Norm Van Brocklin — QB — (1949–1957)

Roman Gabriel — QB — (1962–1972)

Wide Receivers

Isaac Bruce — WR — (1994–2007)

Torry Holt — WR — (1999–2008)

Elroy Hirsch — WR — (1949–1957)

Tom Fears — WR — (1948–1956)

Cooper Kupp — WR — (2017–present)

Jim Benton — WR — (1938–1947)

Tight Ends

Tyler Higbee — TE — (2016–present)

Bob Boyd — TE — (1956–1964)

Billy Truax — TE — (1964–1969)

Running Backs

Marshall Faulk — RB — (1999–2005)

Eric Dickerson — RB — (1983–1987)

Steven Jackson — RB — (2004–2012)

Todd Gurley — RB — (2015–2019)

Lawrence McCutcheon — RB — (1972–1980)

Offensive Line

Orlando Pace — T — (1997–2008)

Jackie Slater — T — (1976–1995)

Tom Mack — G — (1966–1978)

Bob Brown — G/T — (1964–1968)

Rich Saul — C — (1970–1981)

Dennis Harrah — G — (1975–1987)

Doug Smith — C — (1987–1995)

Kent Hill — G/T — (1979–1988)

Duval Love — G — (1985–1991)

Defensive Line

Aaron Donald — DT — (2014–2023)

Deacon Jones — DE — (1961–1971)

Merlin Olsen — DT — (1962–1976)

Jack Youngblood — DE — (1971–1984)

Andy Robustelli — DE — (1951–1955)

Fred Dryer — DE — (1972–1981)

Larry Brooks — DT — (1972–1981)

D'Marco Farr — DT — (1994–2000)

Linebackers

Les Richter — LB — (1954–1962)

Jack Pardee — LB — (1954–1970)

Kevin Greene — LB — (1985–1993)

Isiah Robertson — LB — (1971–1982)

Jim Youngblood — LB — (1975–1985)

Maxie Baughan — LB — (1960–1966)

London Fletcher — LB — (1998–2001)

Cornerbacks

Aeneas Williams — CB — (2001–2004)

Jalen Ramsey — CB — (2019–2022)

Clancy Williams — CB — (1961–1969)

Night Train Lane — CB — (1952–1953)

Safeties

Eddie Meador — S —(1959–1970)

Nolan Cromwell — S —(1977–1987)

Dave Elmendorf — S — (1971–1979)

Johnnie Johnson — S — (1980–1988)

Special Teams

Jake McQuaide — LS — (2011–2020)

Jeff Wilkins — K — (1997–2007)

Johnny Hekker — P — (2012–2020)

LeRoy Irvin — KR/PR — (1980–1989)

reddit.com
u/ExplanationCrazy5463 — 5 months ago