



Rules question: charge and maximizing contact
Hi all. I played a game last week and we encounter a situation which was very clear to my opponent but not to me. I did not want to spend so much time clarifying the rule and I agreed to their view of the ruling, but I wanted to ask to be sure in case it happens again. Pictures attached.
- fell bats declare a charge into one cannon (picture 1)
- rule says they have to maximize contact
- I thought that given that the cannon base is 50mm and the fell bats 40mm, you can squeeze the three bats into the front line
- this would result in: contact with the adjacent cannon, and having to move the other unit one inch to fulfill the 1 inch rule (pictures 2 and 3).
My opponent argued that the clansmen unit cannot be moved, and therefore, only two bats could fit in contact with the cannon to fulfill the 1 inch rule, which would result in not making contact with the adjacent cannon as well (picture 4).
What are your thoughts? Thanks in advance.