Is my boyfriend (40) poly or just a commitment-phobic?
**My boyfriend says he doesn’t believe in prioritizing romantic relationships over friendships. Am I being unreasonable?**
I’ve (32F) been dating my boyfriend (40M) for 8 months. He’s only ever had monogamous relationships, but he’s skeptical that lifelong monogamy is realistic. He says attraction to other people is inevitable and isn’t convinced choosing one person forever is necessarily the right model. I told him attraction is inevitable for me too, but commitment is choosing your partner anyway. He wasn’t sure he agreed, but said he’s ‘willing tk explore it with me’ and that so far, I’m the healthiest relationship he’s been in.
He’s also friends with several ex-lovers. The one I’m struggling with is a woman he friend-zoned just before we met. She admitted she had feelings for him, and I’m fairly sure she still does. He insists he has zero romantic interest in her and that ‘if he had a crush on her, he’d tell me.’
This week I’m about to leave for three weeks, and my visa situation is uncertain, so I told him I’d really like our last few days together to feel intentional. Instead, on our second-to-last evening together, I didn’t hear from him all day. I checked in at 8 pm and he said he was just now walking into a lecture and performance and that i should join him after at the bar.
I later found out that he had gone to that performance with this woman who has feelings for him and didn’t tell me. I blew up his phone and spiraled — I’m so embarrassed. He got defensive and didn’t comfort me. When I called to talk about it the next day, be he was open about telling me he ‘met her at the lecture’ but insisted he did nothing wrong and if i wanted to see him i could have reached out.
When I told him I felt hurt and deprioritized, he said he doesn’t believe romantic relationships should take priority over friendships - he doesn’t like traditional hierarchal relationship statuses. He also said telling him I felt anxious about him spending time with her made him feel controlled.
For people who lean poly or relationship anarchist: is this a common philosophy? Or are we just fundamentally incompatible?
Is it unreasonable to expect your partner to prioritize your relationship, especially when you’re about to spend weeks apart, or is that just a monogamous assumption?