Small nonprofit stuck with 3 disconnected time-tracking systems — looking for a real solution
We're a small nonprofit (under 10 people: staff, contractors, seasonal field crew) and our time tracking is a patchwork:
- Toggl Track for staff — logs hours by project, but doesn't sync to payroll (Gusto), and that project data mostly isn't used to allocate pay. Each person's pay just defaults to one accounting class, reconciled manually (if at all).
- Gusto Time Tracking for contractors and seasonal employees — contractors can't tag hours to a project, just a memo.
- Paper hitch reports → Google Sheet for our field crew — collected on paper, transcribed by a supervisor, then manually entered into payroll, bypassing Gusto entirely.
Nothing syncs, there's a lot of manual re-entry, and we don't get accurate project-level labor cost data.
Ideally: one tool that lets staff, contractors, and field crew all log time by project, integrates with Gusto for payroll, and gives real cost-by-project reporting without manual splitting every pay period.
Anyone solved this for a nonprofit with office + contractor + seasonal/field staff? Looking for recommendations.