Donors parents found tree - what do we do?
Looking for advice from others in open/known donor situations because my wife and I are really torn on how to handle something.
We had our son in March 2025 through an open donor arrangement. He was responsive up until he congratulated us for our pregnancy, but never responded to the birth or any subsequent updates of our son. Completely ghosted after it was real.
Recently, I made my son an Ancestry family tree. Unexpectedly, the donor’s father found the tree and messaged me (now 10 days ago) very kindly saying he noticed a grandmother of his wife on my tree and wanted to compare trees to find more relatives she may not have on hers.
Here’s the dilemma:
- We have no idea whether our donor ever told his family about our son. We’re assuming he didn’t.
- We don’t want to blindside or out him if he intended to tell them himself someday.
- We would love our son to have a relationship with his bio father if that’s what he wants someday and don’t want to impact that.
- If we DO tell the donor and he says “no, don’t respond. I’ll talk to them” how are we supposed to feel confident that’s happening and not have that door close?
- We also don’t want to lose what could potentially be a meaningful biological family connection for our son.
Would you:
- Respond directly to the donor’s father?
- Reach out to the donor first as a heads up?
- Keep things vague at first?
- Open the tree/share context?