What makes you actually keep a party game instead of playing it once and shelving it?
My group churns through party games — Herd Mentality, Wavelength, Codenames, the "most likely to" stuff — and I've noticed most get played hard for a month and then just… die on the shelf. A rare few stay in rotation for years.
Trying to understand what actually separates the two. Is it replayability, the humour, the group, the length, the box? What's a party game that's stayed in your rotation — and what's one you were sure you'd love that you quietly stopped pulling out, and why?
Also curious about the dark side: has a "roast your friends" type game ever genuinely soured the mood in your group? Where's the line between "funny because it's true" and "that actually stung"?