u/Resident-Book-6256

If you’re seeing this, you’re probably a bit confused. Basically, this is a roster challenge I’ve been doing on the main sub for a few days, where we make the best possible, 128-character Nintendo roster, but now today’s post got removed, so I’m moving it to here. Luckily, we weren’t very far, so the current choices should be fine. (Also, yes, I did something like this before, but I wasn’t satisfied with the rules for that one.)

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) video game characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. All development time restraints do not need to be considered, but characters should still make sense to be chosen (so no jokes).
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.
2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.
3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.
4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.
5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).
6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.
7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.
8. No downvoting.

Exactly what the title says. 128 total characters, starting with 64. Most upvoted comment wins.

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned (as of June 2022) characters are allowed.

2. Any characters removed from one installment are permanently removed from the franchise.

3. The post order will determine the Ultimate fighter order, so keep the canon order in mind.

4. Don’t try to be TOO realistic, but also not too UN-realistic.

5. Only characters created before January 1999 (for now).

6. Transformation characters (Sheik, ZSS, etc.) only count as one roster slot.

7. Echo Fighters have to be specified as such in the comments.

8. No downvoting.

Good luck! (Also, yes, I know it‘ll probably be basic at first, I just want to cover all the bases.)

Prime Time never ends, baby!

Olimar crash lands!

Rules:

1. Only Nintendo-owned characters allowed (duh).
2. Only characters created before August 2004 (NOT 2001).
3. Characters not included in one game (i.e. Jigglypuff) cannot be re-added in the future.
4. Development limitations don’t need to be taken into consideration.
5. Transformation characters (i.e. Sheik, ZSS) will only take up one roster slot.