Tokyo Akazukin/Red Hood thoughts
Just finished this manga, not 100% sure what to think of it but I was a bit disappointed.
To start, I don’t think I would even classify it as horror, it’s not really trying to scare the reader at all, and if you can get over the sexual content there’s nothing else particularly disturbing. It’s more like an action seinen, and the action isn’t incredible. All of what I’d read about it was about how disturbing and gorey it is so I assumed it was gonna be horror, but I guess not. I don’t even think there was that much gore, it felt pretty typical for seinen. For example when people get shot in the head it’s not like there’s any visible wound or brain matter or anything, it’s just a big circle cut out of their head, pretty standard stuff. The main character can regenerate from wounds but you never really see that happen, it’s usually in shadow. I guess in the grand scheme of things it’s relatively gorey, but it’s very tame compared to something like Franken Fran. There was some more intense gore in the early chapters but it stops pretty quickly, which is a problem I had with the manga in general. After a certain thing happens to the main character it feels like the tone shifts a lot and there are no more horror elements at all, it mostly becomes pretty tame fight scenes and characters explaining plot stuff. The horrible protagonists you follow also start being treated more sympathetically which felt a bit weird, one of the side characters is a paedophile who murders people to sell their organs and I think you’re genuinely supposed to care about him by the end.
Once that shift happens it also becomes a lot more focused on the overarching plot, and I may be a bit stupid here but I had a lot of difficulty following what exactly was going on and what all the characters wanted. I never really even understood why she wanted to be eaten by the wolf which is the main mystery of chapter one, or what the main villain wanted. I also have no idea what happened at the end, spoilers: >!She finally meets the wolf, there’s a big explosion and they both die? Why did that happen? Why did she want that to happen? Why did her regeneration even stop working? No idea.!< Maybe it’s something to do with the English translation which seemed a bit odd at times. The manga also has a habit of showing dialogue with loads of floating speech bubbles with no people visible, so it can be hard to track who’s saying what. Maybe that’s easier to follow in Japanese where they might have distinct styles of speaking?
The sexual stuff was a bit weird too. Obviously I knew a bit about that before reading. Not something I enjoy but not a complete deal breaker either. In the first few chapters though it’s quite disturbing and violent so thought it fit with the more horror tone, but then in the second half it just becomes like weird softcore porn, it gets more protracted and often has little to do with the plot. There’s standard manga censoring so I don’t know who this is for exactly, surely you could just go look at actual porn if you wanted? It’s still only a relatively small part of the manga I guess, but definitely did not help my impressions.
The art was pretty good overall, I guess that's the one mostly positive thing I have to say about it. Some of the fights are a bit hard to follow, but the still panels usually look good, and what gore there is is quite good too. The gritty style works pretty well, it reminds me of Q Hayashida's style a bit, but definitely not on her level.
I did think I’d enjoy it more since most of what I’d heard was it’s extreme horror with a villain protagonist, and dark Red Riding Hood stuff is always cool to me. Feel like I got baited a bit though. The first half or so I genuinely enjoyed, up until the necromancer fight it was pretty good, but just felt like it dragged after that, which wasn’t helped by me having trouble following the plot. It was definitely an interesting experience though, so I guess I’d recommend it if that’s what you’re looking for, it made me feel like typing all this out at least lol. I just don’t think it was particularly good overall, at least as a horror manga. So yeah, anyone else read the manga and have an opinion? Or have a recommendation for something I might like more? Thanks.