Why do older blokes point to tales of a topographic ocean specifically as being bad
My dad would always say to me "I mean, what would someone rather listen to? Tales of a topographic ocean, or PILE DRIVER". Tbh even as a kid tales of a topographic ocean sounded like a much cooler name, and I got into prog rock as an adult.
When I worked at a pub, a lot of old geezer types would come in and we'd get talking about music. They all said the same sort of thing "simplicity is best when it comes to music. Bob Dylan just needed the basic chords and he made some of the best music of all time"
Has anyone in this sub heard this sort of thing? Where does this sentiment come from? And why is it always tales of a topographic ocean they choose as an example? Because imo I find music fun to listen to when it's complex and gives me a lot to chew on. I don't find simplicity all that fulfilling anymore, there's only so many ways to make a simple chord progression on your basic rock band arrangement sound fresh and interesting. That's not to knock em, some people like that, it's just not for me (most of the time)