My wishlist for Persona 5 after doing a (final?) replay of Persona 5 Royal
A voiced protagonist. Or at least a protagonist that actually takes part in conversations. I never noticed before just how little the protagonist in P5R is involved in conversations. There are entire long text conversations in which he doesn't say a single word. And the plant has a bigger part in some discussions in the hideout.
Female protagonist. Either only a female protagonist or at least the choice between male and female. It just should be a standard.
No new team members three quarters through the game. Both Futaba and Haru could have a had a lot bigger parts in the story. At least introduce them as confidants early and let them become team members later.
Shorter and tighter dungeons/palaces. Many of the palaces in P5R overstayed their welcome.
Shorter tutorial, optional on replays. This gets really boring on replays.
No endless periods of not being able to play the game. You can go out on exam days. There's no need to stay at home during exams. Or make it a mechanic. If you don't study before exams, you do worse in them. But stop taking away control for days on end, not for exams, not for any plot points. An occasional day here and there, but not entire weeks.
And one final observation, not a wish: Damn, the Japanese voices were so much better. This was my first Japanese playthrough after several English ones over the years and I liked everyone a lot more. Morgana is so much less annoying, it's not even funny.
Edit: Obviously a wishlist for Persona 6. Too bad you can't edit titles. 😂