u/Top40Weekly

Inspired by the steel drum music that surrounded him in Trinidad, Lester Sebastian Charles banged away on instruments he made out of old milk cans. At around age six, he picked up the ukulele and began singing in the school choir.

After moving to London with his family, teenage Les left school and started working as a tailor, playing piano in his spare time. One day he came up with a riff which led to the first song he ever wrote “Love Really Hurts Without You” which later became his first hit single, reaching #2 in the UK and #22 in the US in 1976.

His early singles were credited to Les Charles, but “Love” bore the name Billy Ocean (inspired by Ocean's 11, a Trinidad soccer team that had, in turn, taken its name from the 1960 Rat Pack heist movie).

Several of Billy’s follow-up singles were hits in Britain, but not in America. By 1980, he was a chart no-show.

In 1984, with a new label and fellow Trinidadian Keith Diamond on board as producer and co-writer, Ocean released the Michael Jackson-inspired “European Queen (No More Love On The Run).” It was a hit in Switzerland and West Germany, and nowhere else.

Apparently, “European” didn’t exactly conjure up the kind of fun-in-the-sun fantasy that most consumers wanted to buy into.

A label executive liked the song, but told Billy that the title didn’t work.

So, using the exact same track and vocal, with only the word “Caribbean” edited into the recording in place of “European,” a 12” single was released.

That one word change made all the difference.

In September 1984, “Caribbean Queen” hit #1 on the US Billboard Dance chart, and then in an edited 7” version reached #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 and R&B charts, and #6 in the UK. It was also a major hit in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.

But wait…there’s more!

On the 12” there was yet another variation “African Queen” which was popular in parts of that continent.

“Caribbean Queen” capped off a great year for Ocean when it won him a Grammy for Best Male R&B Performance.

More importantly, it also made Billy Ocean a star.

He went on to place eight more singles in the US Top 20, including the #1s “There’ll Be Sad Songs (To Make You Cry)” and “Get Outta My Dreams, Get Into My Car.”

And, if you watch the official video closely, you can spot brief shots of a poster bearing the song title “African Queen” and then another with “European Queen,” which changes to “Caribbean Queen.”

Can you think of another song where a seemingly small change whether it was the title, a lyric, or even the marketing ended up completely changing its success?

In the spring of 1974, Bruce Springsteen's career was hanging in the balance.

His first two albums had sold poorly, he had only one album left on his Columbia contract, and the label was reportedly considering dropping him.

Then came April 1974.

Bruce was opening for Bonnie Raitt at Charlie's Place in Cambridge, Massachusetts, when he noticed a positive review of The Wild, The Innocent & The E Street Shuffle posted in a window. The review had been written by music critic Jon Landau.

Landau later attended another Springsteen performance at the Harvard Square Theater on May 9, 1974.

Afterward, he wrote one of the most famous lines in rock journalism:

>

The review changed everything.

Columbia quickly built a major publicity campaign around Landau's endorsement. Bruce appreciated the article itself, although he later spoke about the pressure that came with the hype.

More importantly, Springsteen and Landau developed a working relationship. At the time, Bruce had completed only one track for what would become Born To Run. Landau soon joined the project and shared production duties.

Born To Run was released in August 1975 and became the breakthrough album that transformed Springsteen's career.

Bruce and Jon would go on to build a friendship and professional partnership that has lasted more than 50 years.

For longtime fans:

How important do you think Jon Landau was to Springsteen's success?

Would Bruce have eventually broken through anyway, or was Landau's review and subsequent involvement a genuine turning point?

On December 6, 2023, Brenda Lee's "Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree" topped the Billboard Hot 100. Two days later, she celebrated her 79th birthday.

What makes that achievement even more remarkable is that Brenda first reached the charts at age 12.

Born Brenda Mae Tarpley in 1944, she began singing professionally as a child after winning a Georgia talent contest at just five years old. Her big break came when country star Red Foley heard her perform and invited her onto his national television show.

In 1957, her third single, "One Step At A Time," reached #15 on the country chart and #43 on the Hot 100. Brenda was only 12 years old.

Over the following decades, she became one of the biggest stars of the late 1950s and early 1960s, placing 28 songs in the Hot 100 Top 40 and earning induction into the Rock & Roll, Country, and Rockabilly Halls of Fame.

Ironically, the record-setting #1 hit that secured her place in chart history wasn't one of her early classics.

It was a Christmas song she recorded in October 1958.

At the time, "Rockin' Around The Christmas Tree" was only a modest success. Over the years it became a holiday staple, received a major boost from its appearance in Home Alone, and eventually found a new audience through streaming.

After reaching #2 four years in a row from 2019 through 2022, it finally climbed to #1 in 2023.

Sixty-five years after recording it, Brenda Lee achieved the most extraordinary chart accomplishment of her career.

Can you think of another artist who experienced such an unlikely comeback or late-career milestone?

I recently learned that three of the most famous female empowerment songs in pop history were all written by men:

• "You Don't Own Me" (John Madara & Dave White)
• "Respect" (Otis Redding)
• "I Will Survive" (Dino Fekaris & Freddie Perren)

But what's interesting is that most people don't associate those songs with the songwriters at all.

When people think of "You Don't Own Me," they think of Lesley Gore.

When people think of "Respect," they think of Aretha Franklin even though Otis Redding wrote and recorded it first.

When people think of "I Will Survive," they think of Gloria Gaynor.

In each case, the performer seems to have become inseparable from the song's message. Aretha transformed "Respect" from a man's plea into a declaration of self-worth. Gloria Gaynor turned "I Will Survive" into one of the most enduring resilience anthems in pop culture. And Lesley Gore gave "You Don't Own Me" a sense of independence that still resonates decades later.

Even "Girls Just Want To Have Fun" started as a song written by Robert Hazard before Cyndi Lauper reimagined it into something completely different.

So I'm curious:

At what point does a performer become the true author of a song's cultural meaning?

Are there other songs where you think the artist who recorded it completely transformed what the song represents?

No matter how much effort goes into recording a song, or how much money is spent promoting it, once a record is released its path to success is largely out of the artist's and record company's hands.

Some famous examples:

• Bill Haley's "(We're Gonna) Rock Around The Clock" was originally the B-side of "Thirteen Women (And Only One Man In Town)." After appearing in The Blackboard Jungle, it was reissued and became a #1 hit.
• Dion's "The Wanderer" was originally overlooked in favor of "The Majestic." Radio DJs disagreed and turned "The Wanderer" into a #2 hit.
• Rod Stewart's "Maggie May" began as the flip side of "Reason To Believe." Listeners quickly gravitated toward it, and Billboard eventually switched the designation from B-side to A-side before it reached #1.
• Kiss's "Beth" was tucked behind "Detroit Rock City" despite being completely different from the band's established sound. It became their only Top 10 hit.

These stories raise an interesting question.

Record labels, producers, and artists often spend months deciding which song should be pushed as the hit. Yet history is full of cases where radio programmers and listeners chose differently.

What do B-side success stories tell us about the limits of predicting audience taste?

And what are some other examples where the song everyone thought would be secondary ended up becoming the defining hit?

As a young man, Jim Weatherly juggled two passions: quarterbacking for Ole Miss and writing songs for his own bands. After graduating in 1964, he choose music over football.

It proved to be the right move.

His first major songwriting success came in 1973, when Gladys Knight & The Pips “Neither One Of Us (Wants To Be The First To Say Goodbye)” to #2 on the Billboard Hot 100 (#1 in Cash Box), followed by another Weatherly tune “Where Peaceful Waters Flow” (#6 R&B; Top 30 pop). Then came his crowning achievement, also with Gladys.

Gladys Knight had been performing most of her life: from a singing debut at age four at the Mt. Moriah Baptist Church in Atlanta to winning first prize on Ted Mack’s national TV show The Original Amateur Hour at seven.

She made her record in 1958 with family members — as The Pips (her cousin James’s nickname) — and scored a Top 10 pop/#1 R&B hit with “Every Beat Of My Heart” in 1961.

In 1966, the group was signed to Motown’s Soul label where they racked up 11 Top 10 R&B hits, several of which were also sizable pop hits, including “I Heard It Through The Grapevine,” “If I Were Your Woman,” and the aforementioned “Neither One Of Us.”

In spite of these successes, Gladys, brother Merald “Bubba” Knight, and cousins William Guest and Edward Patten, felt sidelined by Motown, and moved over to Buddah Records in 1973.

Meanwhile, Weatherly was working on his own material when a chance call changed everything. He was trying to reach his friend, actor Lee Majors. Instead, Lee’s girlfriend Farrah Fawcett answered and in passing mentioned that she was packing clothes for a “midnight plane to Houston.”

That sounded like a good title to Jim. He picked up his guitar and wrote the song in 45 minutes, as a country/pop ballad.

Cissy Houston covered it first: switching genders, changing the title to “Midnite Train To Georgia” [sic], and delivering a gospel-infused vocal. In Houston’s telling, the title change came about because her family was from Georgia and they didn’t take planes anywhere.

Gladys has given conflicting stories in interviews: that she “listened to Cissy’s version and loved it,” and also that she and the Pips initiated the title change. Weatherly recalls that his original Houston song was sent to the group.

Producer Tony Camillo’s initial attempts at “Midnight Train” were rejected by the group as too mellow. Gladys wanted an “Al Green vibe”: something “moody with a little ride to it.”

Gladys and The Pips were thrilled with Tony’s next arrangement. The Pips laid down their backing vocals. Next it was Gladys’s turn to record the lead, except she struggled with the freeform ad-libbed ending. Brother Bubba saved the day by feeding lines through her headphones, which she turned into a heart-stopping coda.

Camillo added some finishing touches — a string section, acoustic piano, Hammond organ, handclaps — and it was done.

In October 1973, “Midnight Train To Georgia” topped both the Billboard Hot 100 and R&B charts, sold over a million copies, and earned Gladys Knight & The Pips a Grammy.

For Gladys, the song also had a deeply personal meaning. Her constant touring and recording had strained her marriage, and ultimately proved too much for her husband. They divorced that year.

Just like the song said.

What has always fascinated me about this story is how many unlikely events had to happen for the song to become a classic: a missed phone call, an offhand remark from Farrah Fawcett, a title change by another artist, and a last-minute studio breakthrough from Gladys and Bubba.

What other classic songs can you think of that were inspired by a chance encounter, random conversation, or unexpected moment?

In May 1966, Beach Boy Bruce Johnston arrived in London carrying acetates of Pet Sounds.

On May 19, he played the album for Paul McCartney and John Lennon in his suite at the Waldorf Hotel.

According to later accounts, they were stunned.

Paul would eventually call Pet Sounds one of the greatest albums ever made and reportedly reacted by saying:

>

What's fascinating is that the inspiration had already flowed in the opposite direction.

Brian Wilson has often spoken about how deeply Rubber Soul affected him. He admired the way the album worked as a complete artistic statement rather than a collection of singles and filler tracks, and it motivated him to create Pet Sounds.

When John and Paul heard Pet Sounds, they were in the middle of recording Revolver.

I've always found it interesting that some of the most important albums of the 1960s seem to have emerged from artists inspiring and challenging one another rather than working in isolation.

So I'm curious:

How much influence do you think Pet Sounds ultimately had on The Beatles' later work?

Would Revolver and Sgt. Pepper have developed in largely the same way without it, or do you think hearing Brian Wilson's work changed the band's creative direction in a meaningful way?

If you were asked, “What band has had the most Top 40 singles in England,” how would you reply?

The Beatles?

No.

The Rolling Stones?

Nope.

How about... Status Quo... the band whose lone US hit was the 1968 psychedelic smash “Pictures Of Matchstick Men”?

According to Guinness World Records, Status Quo has amassed 68 separately recorded (credited) UK chart entries. (The Beatles have also had 68, but “only” 37 different ones; the remaining were reissues.)

Of those 68 Status Quo singles, 22 reached the Top 10.

The band’s story began in 1962 when schoolmates Francis Rossi and Alan Lancaster formed a group called The Paladins, later renamed The Spectres. Four years later the quartet released three failed singles.

Several changes happened in 1967. The band renamed themselves The Traffic Jam, released another unsuccessful single, added rhythm guitarist/vocalist Rick Parfitt, and became Status Quo.

In January 1968, Status Quo released “Pictures Of Matchstick Men.” Its ringing guitar line and swirling phasing effects produced a psychedelic sound like nothing else on the radio. It rose to #7 in the UK and #12 on the US Hot 100.

However, Status Quo was unable to maintain the momentum created by their hit in America.

Pye Records dropped them and two years passed before they returned to the UK Top 10 with “Paper Plane” in 1973.

During those lean years between “Pictures Of Matchstick Men” and “Paper Plane,” Status Quo with its simple riffs, catchy melodies, down-home “lads” image, and exciting live shows built a fiercely loyal fanbase that sustained them for decades.

What fascinates me is how a band could become one of the biggest chart acts in British history while remaining largely unknown to many American listeners.

For those familiar with Status Quo, why do you think their success never translated to the US on the same scale?

And more broadly, what other artists do you think were massive in one country but never received the international recognition their success would suggest?

I recently learned the term “mondegreen” for misheard lyrics. One famous example is people hearing CCR’s “Bad Moon Rising” as “there’s a bathroom on the right.”

I’m putting together a playlist of songs that people constantly mishear lyrics in funny or memorable ways. What are some good examples?

Could be classic rock, pop, hip-hop, anything - especially songs where the misheard version became almost as famous as the real lyric.

They can be from any genre; I'm just curious about what songs people would put on the "Mount Rushmore" of American music.

I've been listening to a lot of R&B from the early 2000's and I'm wondering if there are any artists that you guys think are underrated from that era and worth checking out. I'm trying to add some new songs to my playlist

Jefferson Airplane started in 1965 right in the middle of the San Francisco psychedelic explosion, with Marty Balin, Paul Kantner, and Jorma Kaukonen at the core. The turning point came when Grace Slick joined the band, bringing “Somebody to Love” and “White Rabbit” two tracks that pretty much defined the era.

Those late 60s records captured that moment perfectly, but by the early 70s the band was already fracturing. Out of that, Kantner and Slick pushed forward with Blows Against the Empire under the Jefferson Starship name, which still carried a lot of that experimental, countercultural energy.

Through the 70s, Jefferson Starship shifted more toward a polished rock sound (“Miracles,” “Count On Me”), and by the time it became just Starship in the 80s, the transformation was complete, full-on pop with tracks like “We Built This City.”

It’s a pretty wild trajectory: from Surrealistic Pillow and the height of psychedelic rock to chart-topping 80s pop all under variations of the same band identity.

Even now, versions of Jefferson Starship are still out there performing, which makes the whole evolution even more surreal.

Before rap fully broke into the mainstream, New Jack Swing carved out a lane that blended R&B with hip-hop-influenced production.

The sound, driven by artists like Teddy Riley, Guy, and Bobby Brown, brought harder drum patterns and swing into popular music and helped shape the late 80s / early 90s landscape. Tracks from that era still feel like an important bridge between genres.

There’s a case to be made that My Sharona by The Knack marked a turning point in 1979.

At a time when disco still dominated the charts, this track broke through with a stripped-down, guitar-driven sound that felt closer to power pop and early new wave than anything else in the Top 10.

The song itself came together fast. Doug Fieger wrote the lyrics in about 15 minutes, inspired by Sharona Alperin, and Berton Averre built that now-iconic riff with a raw, punchy feel. The stuttering vocal style even nods a bit to The Who’s “My Generation.”

“My Sharona” went to #1 and became the biggest single of 1979.

Not saying it killed disco on its own, but it definitely felt like a shift toward what the early ’80s would sound like.

Curious how people here see it, does this track feel more like power pop, proto–new wave, or just straight rock?

Prog fans usually have strong opinions on “classic run” debates, so I’m curious:

What artist or band had three consecutive albums where they basically didn’t miss?

For a non-prog example, I’d put Stevie Wonder’s run up there:

Music of My Mind
Talking Book
Innervisions

But for prog, I could see arguments for Pink Floyd, Yes, Genesis, King Crimson, Rush, Jethro Tull, Gentle Giant, Van der Graaf Generator, Camel, or ELP.

What’s your pick for the strongest three-album streak in prog, and why?

Did the band peak creatively, technically, conceptually, or all three?