TKWNKM Crackpot Theory Time: Battle Location & Timeline for the Second Book

I got to thinking last night about the battle that I think is coming in the second book and the location and timeline.

In Chapter 24, the day after >!Reynald reveals himself to be Everard!< when Maggie is eating breakfast, she internally notes that "The Dukedom of Selva shared its eastern border with the Crimson Empire in the south and the Goryni Kingdom in the north. Goryni, a small nation, occupied a mountainous area and was renowned for its mineral wealth and unbeatable military. They imported a lot of their food. Its treacherous, rocky coastline made commercial fishing and trade difficult, and in a few months, an underwater earthquake would take out their largest functional harbor. When the Crimson Empire invaded Rellas, which would be bleeding from Hreban’s rampage, the Gorynians would be on the edge of starvation."

We know that the timeline is >! speeding up events due to Maggie's interference and am wondering if the Crimson Empire will speed up their invasion as well?!<.

In Chapter 16, Maggie details Solentine Dagarra's land: "This portion of the continent was split between Rellas in the West and the Crimson Empire in the East. The two countries shared a long border, interrupted by the Corios Sea. When they warred, their invasions happened either in the south, across a vast plain, or in the north, where three mountain ranges formed the Trihorn."

I wonder, with Maggie's knowledge of the future earthquake, try to lure the Crimson Empire from over the mountains and, if it can happen naturally or with some assistance, have an avalanche help take out a portion of the Crimson Empire?

Would an earthquake cause an avalanche?

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 3 days ago

Silverian &amp; the Hair Ornament

>!In the epilogue, Silveren orders Maggie to put the ornament in her hair when he abducts her. Do you think he knows he significance of the hairpiece?!<

Edited because I can't spell names apparently.

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 6 days ago

Why Didn't Maggie Go into Government?

Maggie states that she got a political science degree. Why didn't she go into local/state/federal government? Become a Foreign Service Officer? She wanted to make a change in the world, why not that route?

Edited to add: in real life, not in Rellas.

I am also going off the top of my head and do not have the book at hand.

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 10 days ago

Crackpot Theory Time:

Ok, so I have a completely crackpot theory that's been rattling in mind for a few weeks and I may be making connections out of thin air, but I need to share it:

>!In the beginning of Chapter 8, Maggie recalls that in the later chapters of the second book that a "talented young thief who went by River Fog traveled to Kair Toren at the request of a prominent noble family. They hired him to steal a child from Derog. It was a particular child, and Derog had referred her as a "custom order for a special customer." The family had tried to purchase her, but the slavemonger refused to sell her even at a sky-high price, which meant whoever had hired him to obtain the child in the first place had to powerful enough to scare him." !<

>!Then, a few paragraphs later, "I usually skipped that chapter during my rereads because in the end, once River Fog delivered the child to prearranged place, an assassin murdered him and the girl."!<

>!In Chapter 16, Maggie states, "[t]here was something I was missing here, which wasn't surprising. Latour was infamous for inserting seemingly random scenes into the narrative. They would sit there without any obvious reason for their existence, until three hundred pages later some shocking revelation would make them crucial and relevant."!<

>!In Chapter 8, is Maggie mimicking the author (Latour) in that she randomly remembered a scene from book 2 of the series and then will there be revelation about this scene she recalled?!<

>!Note that in the scene in Sonndor (Chapter 22) Maggie states "[i]t was one of those random Latour scenes. No hint when or where it took place. No names. No explanation as to why it was in the narrative. It was just there to drive the fandom out of their minds with speculation" and proceeds to tell Reynald that there was boy with a puppy trapped in a house engulfed in flames who fell through two floors and landed in the stone basement. He survived and a man who once loved his mother rescued him. We now know this to be Mirabor Savaric. !<

>!On HA's blog, there's a list of characters that state there is a third child of of the king that wasn't mentioned in Book 1 of Maggie the Undying: Princess Lavia who is 10 years old. !<

>!I'm wondering if the Crimson Empire contracted Derog to kidnap Princess Lavia when they invaded and then an agent of the Crimson Empire killed River Fog and the girl--who could possibly be Lavia. !<

>!I have absolutely no proof whatsoever. This is just me speculating. !<

>!Thoughts?!<

u/attachedtothreads — 11 days ago

Art Therapy Workshop - Feelings Color Wheel for Adults at Hospice of the Piedmont on Thurs., July 2nd @ 4-5pm

Grief is more than just sadness; it is a spectrum of emotions that can be difficult to name. This workshop helps organize the complexity of loss by inviting participants to create a color wheel filled with colors, patterns, and symbols representing the emotions they are navigating. By creating this visual map, participants gain a clearer picture of how their emotions interact and evolve.

1801 Westchester Drive

u/attachedtothreads — 12 days ago

How did Arale do it in the original timeline?

>!Maggie notes while in Galiene's office to tell who is messing with the shipments, that "Arale took over Galiene's job, but she kept making mistakes. Shortly after the failed raid, Hade died suddenly. A purple pouch containing traces of poison was found in her room. I'd always thought Arale was the one who'd done it. Without Hade she had free rein [sic], and within a year she had run the Garden into the ground." Pages 346-347!<

>!How would she run the Garden into the ground? I think what Arale thinks it takes to be proprietress of the Garden is to practice the Three Arts (dancing; singing; what's the third? needlework? flower arranging?) and be seductive, but I say it's management. That's de-escalating fights, tempers, egos between wealthy merchants and nobility, soothing hurt feelings, etc. and for staff as well. !<

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 19 days ago

Eye Color of the Man from the Garden:

>!Is Silverian dampening his eye color so as to not draw too much attention? I know when Everard uses magic, it intensifies his original eye color, but when Silverian uses his magic, is it because he's revealing the true color of his eyes or intensifying the original?!<

>!Maggie's first impressions of Silverian. I don't think he's using magic at this moment: "His eyes were striking, a rich golden hazel." Page 35; later on page 35: "He wasn't afraid of Hreban. Who the hell was he? Brown hair, hazel eyes, beautiful face".!<

>!I think he's using his magic here to lure Maggie away from her household at the Dog Market: "The man from the Garden stood next to me. He wore a plain brown cloak and lancer's coif that hid his face, but the eyes were unmistakable. A rich, golden hazel, slightly wild." Page 176!<

>!"Beautiful. Like the kind of face that makes you stop and stare. He has these captivating eyes, light hazel, like golden amber. They almost glow." Page 196!<

>!Here, he is definitely using his magic: ""Mother..." he said. His face was slack with shock. Tears wet his golden eyes" page 463 !<

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 20 days ago

What do you think 'Razmur' means?

It's Everard's home in the Kair Toren. We know 'zmur' generically means large predatory bird from Maggie mulling over a word, but do we get any indication what "Ra" means? I know this is a different world, but can't think of Ra the Egyptian Sun God.

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 20 days ago

The Fall of the Man from the Garden?

On page 223, Reynald mentions to Maggie that >!"Ralinbor didn't lose his war on the battlefield. He lost it weeks before, when he failed to adequately equip his troops, neglected to put together a functioning supply chain, and chose the wrong place and time to engage his enemy. He counted too much on the dursans, but they are just animals. No matter how powerful a magical beast is, it's no substitute for proper planning and strategy."!<

On page 460, >!"Dursans rained down, slicing through the clouds. Five, ten, no, more, landing all over the courtyard."!<

>!Silverian relies on Cai of Sunder and, as his backup plan, the dursans to kill the Sun Margrave. He doesn't involve the Order of the Redeemer Knights at all. While I think this because it's a combination of personal revenge and he didn't want to expose the Redeemers' involvement at this point in case Cai did succeed, it seems to me that this might be his downfall. Or do you think he will learn from his father's mistakes and have a good supply chain?!<

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 21 days ago

Why is 25 an important number?

I'm re-listening the audiobook for the time and Maggie mentioned that 15 is an important number in Rellas. Why do you think that would be?

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 21 days ago

Is this for effect or do you think magic is involved?

On page 333 when Tillmar is taking his oath to Everard, Maggie notes that:

&#x200B;

Dark smoke boiled out of Everard. His eyes turned a piercing, scalding green.

&#x200B;

I understand that the dark smoke he sometimes uses just for theatrics, but are the piercing, scalding eyes also for theatrics? Earlier in the book, Maggie says it's a precursor to Everard using his Fatefire. Is there some kind of magic bonding Everard and Tillmar during the oath scene?

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 22 days ago

Help Figuring Out Familial Ties in TKWNKM:

There's something on page 212 of the book where Drugh is explaining his family and I'm completely confused.

>!"Hedena knew her uncle was after her dowry, but he gave her a safe place to stay. When she was scared and grieving, he put a roof over her head and food on her table. She was not along. She belonged somewhere, and when she was ready, he pulled in all his favors to apprentice her to the weaver of her choice. He treated us as his own. He sat at our wedding for both of our fathers, and he left everything he owned to us."!<

>!Is Hedena cousin to Drugh? Wife? Is Filderon Hedena's father? Uncle? I am so confused.!<

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 24 days ago

Maggie brought her soap-making abilities. What object would you invent/improve upon to survive Keir Toren?

Maggie is bringing her knowledge of making an improved soap for Kair Toren that will revolutionize the soap industry (and probably hygiene), not to mention bringing a boatload of money. That got me thinking what I knowledge I have that would be useful for me to make money and survive in Kair Toren? I'm a quilter, so I think making the rotary cutter would be popular among tailors, dressmakers, and sewists. But then I wouldn't have a cutting mat and would need to invent that, right?

u/attachedtothreads — 26 days ago

What is this sub's stance on fan art? The authors'?

I like to cross-stitch and quilt and want to make something related to TKWNKM, but don't know the stance HA takes showing on social media.

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 28 days ago

Savaric's Children

I've tried searching my e-book, but can't come up with the results and I don't know if I'm making things up or not. I know Savaric has two sons, but isn't there a one-time mention of him having a daughter? Or am I making things up?

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 30 days ago

Change My Mind:

>!The middle initials of George R.R. Martin are Raymond and Richard. HA is honoring George by having the MMC named Ramond.!<

u/attachedtothreads — 1 month ago

Random Thought:

When Maggie saw the first member of the Harzi clan, she noted that the tips of the teenage girl's hair was bleached and dyed Carolina blue. I thought this an odd reference to describe a color. She doesn't mention if she or her brother went to the University of North Carolina--Chapel Hill (UNC-CH) after noting the color or even before. There's also no note that her parent(s) went to it and passed down their love of the university to her. Did anyone else find this odd?

u/attachedtothreads — 1 month ago

Fan Theory Groups for TKWNKM:

Is there a Facebook group or another place where I can obsessively talk about TKWNKM? I don't want to overwhelm this sub and I want to delve into the weeds and talk about fan theories.

reddit.com
u/attachedtothreads — 1 month ago