r/AskChemistry

Question about high school experiment

Ill quickly explain the experiment first:

My teacher took an open can with a small hole at the bottom, which was first sealed with a cork. He placed the can upside down, hole facing up, and on a block such that the box was angled and had contact to air on the big opening.

He then filled the can with hydrogen gas, took away the cork, and lit the hydrogen, which was now streaming out slowly, on fire.

It was sizzling on for a while with only a small flame at the top, but at some point, it exploded and threw the can into the air.

The teacher asked why we had to wait for an explosion, afterwards he answered by saying at the point of explosion the ideal ratio 2:1 for the reaction 2 H2 + O2 -> 2 H2O was reached, because he wanted to illustrate that reactions need concrete ratios of substances.

However, i doubt this explanation, because there doesnt seem to be a way for the flame reaching the inside because the hydrogen was constantly flowing out, and i assumed the density of hydrogen causes layer separation between air, not a mixture.

Could this have to do with the flow rate of the hydrogen or with the shape of the distribution of hydrogen in the can? Or is the teachers explanation correct?

reddit.com
u/raph3x1 — 1 day ago

How to prevent quantum chemistry from making me Quit Grad School (or cognitive function altogether)

I need 8 graduate credit hours for my stipend but this semester my university doesn’t offer any grad courses other than “Intro” to QChem and Advanced Organic Synthesis. I literally have to take QChem because if I don’t I won’t be eligible for a stipend.

I hate quantum chemistry. I “cheated” my way through it in undergrad (was a joke bc we had a zoom class, all hw and tests were open book and group work, and the prof gave us “Jedi master”, and “Jedi Knight”, etc. as grades). I never even learned spherical coordinates in calc iii bc I stopped showing up to classes due to depression. Now I’m forced to take this hellspawn of a class my first semester of grad school. I don’t even know how to do calculus if the variables aren’t written X, Y, Z like in math class.

But the worst part isn’t that I don’t know it. It’s that I’m mentally blocking myself from learning it. I don’t want to learn it. It’s not relevant to an organic chemist to normalize wavefunctions or use rigid rotor. Computational Chem is the only part of the class I’m excited about. I’m spiraling and it’s only my second day I’m afraid I made a terrible mistake and my life will be useless if I dropout of grad school

Is this just a shit the bed and now I have to face the consequences and lay in it

reddit.com
u/nigmusmaximus — 2 days ago
▲ 16 r/AskChemistry+1 crossposts

Metals vs minerals

Help a teacher out. I’m an elementary teacher without a science background. I do enjoy teaching science to my kiddos but I can’t teach science beyond 6th grade level (please keep in mind while answering). A few years ago I taught a geology unit and this past spring I taught the same unit again and remembered being confused about this question back then. So, I tried googling, I tried stack exchange, quora, everything, and NO resource could break this down for me: what in the world is the difference between metals and minerals? I know metals can be extracted FROM ores found in rocks but apparently, elements like silver, gold and copper are considered both a metal and a mineral. Are there others like this? If so, which ones? And please confirm for me: most minerals are not metals at all, but are most metals also minerals? (The science book I use, which I normally love, was talking about minerals’ qualities and showing pictures of things like chalk and limestone and then suddenly when explaining the uses of minerals, it’s taking about coins, electric wiring and musical instruments and the kids and I were all confused). I also asked the chemistry high school teacher and she wasn’t sure how to explain it.

u/Acceptable-Cash-2464 — 2 days ago
▲ 1 r/AskChemistry+1 crossposts

Could you use the CO2 in a manmade material to guess it's production date?

This question isn't based on anything specific - It's just a shower thought - But could the production date of a plastic or metal or any other material be reasonably estimated by the amount of CO2 in it? And how accurate would it be?

reddit.com
u/Chezelh — 2 days ago
▲ 9 r/AskChemistry+1 crossposts

Why does my powdered ginger surround the spoon after I stirr my tea?

Title. Sounds like a joke but, like, there must be some sort of explanation right? Is this a more serious sub? I think this is a sort of question you could ask in r/askmath where there are some silly questions, but if it isn't that sort of sub, please point me somewhere where I can ask. But this is a real thing and google gave me no answer. The sub doesn't allow images but if anybody needs to know what I'm talking about, I have a photo. There are some air bubbles behind the spoon, if anybody needs to know.

u/--Queso-- — 2 days ago
▲ 52 r/AskChemistry+2 crossposts

My Brother wants to process waste egg shells into CaCO3

Hey guys,

I don’t have a lot of experience in chemistry so i thought this subreddit could help me. I hope i do get some valuable advice and understanding.

Recently my brother has been planning on starting a small business project to process waste eggshells specifically to obtain pure calcium carbonate (CaCO3).

To be honest, I'm kind of worried he might be risking his money on this. I was reading somewhere that limestone is already mined at a massive, cheap scale everywhere for calcium carbonate, so I'm not sure how this makes financial sense. Plus, the whole processing and chemical extraction part of it looks super tedious.

To try and help him out, I actually went ahead and spoke to a few local farms myself. But the catch is, they said they're only willing to supply the shells with all the inner membrane and materials completely intact they aren't going to clean or prep them at all.

Since I don't know much about chemistry or manufacturing, I wanted to ask you guys: Is this actually a practical idea to get pure CaCO3, or is he walking into a total headache? Any advice or warnings would be awesome before he drops cash on equipment.

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/ForInfinity — 3 days ago

iv heard that some elements like helium have like... variants? like i know there’s "helium 3" in moonrock. are there other elements that have variants? and can such variants also move to things those elements are in? like is there a water 2?

reddit.com
u/YLASRO — 3 days ago

Hi all there’s a small debate about soda water. 1. Is soda water filled with carbonic acid which makes it acidic or filled with bicarbonates which is alkaline? 2. Assuming it is alkaline, why do we have lemonade which still taste sour when the bicarbonates should have already neutralized the acid?

3.Is acid rain still a concern? Can we drink it? Some splashed into my eyes why it seemed fine?

reddit.com
u/LisanneFroonKrisK — 3 days ago
▲ 7 r/AskChemistry+2 crossposts

Freeze drying conditions

We have a methanolic extract that needs to be freeze dried. The issue is that we don't have our own freeze dryer and we will just be sending our sample to have a freeze drying service. Their condition is that it should not have alcohol content which I am already aware because it will cause damage to the equipment.

Is using rotary evaporator be enough to remove the methanol in our extract before freeze drying or should we resort to just using water to be safe? We are just students and we dont want to be paying for the damage if ever :/

reddit.com
u/Complete_Flamingo_34 — 3 days ago
▲ 2 r/AskChemistry+1 crossposts

A bonding question

if the peripheral atoms are all identical around a central atom without any lone pairs, would the bond angle remain same, regardless of the electronegativity of the peripheral atoms for a given steric number? For example, we know that SiH4 and SiF4 have the same tetrahedral geometry and 109.5° bond angle even though H and F are vastly different in electronegativity. Does this hold for all steric numbers though?

reddit.com
u/PensionMany3658 — 3 days ago

Could "hard well water" form raised, acid-insoluble nodules on PVD stainless steel, or is this a synthetic polymer?

Substrate / Material Details:

  • Substrate: 304-Grade Stainless Steel (18/8 Cr-Ni alloy)
  • Surface Finish: Dark PVD (Physical Vapor Deposition) titanium-based ceramic nano-coating (Lefton brand sink)
  • Age / Usage: Brand-new installation; spots were present post-remodel.

Physical Characteristics of the Residue:

  • Localized, opaque white droplets/bumps.
  • Distinct, tangible raised edges (readily caught with a fingernail or plastic edge).
  • Visually darkens/disappears under refractive liquid/oil, but physical texture remains.
  • General contractor claims these are standard "hard well water mineral deposits."

Chemicals Tested & Results:

Product Used Active Chemical Compounds Exposure Time Observed Result
CLR (Calcium Lime Rust) Lactic Acid (C3H6O3), Gluconic Acid (C6H12O7), Lauramine Oxide surfactant ~5 min direct contact / scrub Zero effect. No effervescence, no dissolution, no softening.
Pure Acetone Dimethyl Ketone / Propan-2-one ((CH3)2CO) 2–3 min surface contact (rag) Zero effect. Did not dissolve or wipe away.
Hope's Perfect Sink Fine mineral abrasive slurry, surfactants, silicone/polymer conditioner Mechanical buffing Only masks surface optically; does not remove physical bumps.

Questions for Chemists / Material Scientists:

  1. Inorganic / Mineral Solubility: Is there any plausible scenario where potable well water precipitates calcium carbonate (CaCO3), magnesium carbonate (MgCO3), or calcium sulfate (CaSO4) into discrete, raised nodules that show zero reactivity or dissolution when exposed to concentrated lactic and gluconic acids (pH ~2.5)?
  2. Silicate Scale vs. Organic Polymer: Even in high-silica well water (SiO2), can silica scale form localized, raised droplets with defined edges in under 3 weeks of light domestic use?
  3. Polymer / Trade Splatter Hypothesis: Given the insolubility in alpha-hydroxy acids and resistance to brief ketone exposure, does this profile point almost exclusively to cross-linked organic polymers (e.g., 2-part epoxy grout, polyurethane/acrylic mastic, cured silicone, or solvent-based penetrating tile sealer) from the remodel?
u/whynotthebest — 3 days ago

Short Path Distillation

Hey

Looking for some help setting up a distillation process to maximize recovery. The current setup uses an Allihn condenser to distill out the product of interest. I was wondering if a switch to a short-path distillation head will increase product recovery as there will be less surface area to retain the product. I understand the distillation will be significantly slower.

Thanks

reddit.com
u/skyzzze — 3 days ago
▲ 1 r/AskChemistry+2 crossposts

how can I make a powdered methanolic extract into liquid again?

I have searched that to add methanol again on the powder but I am confused if there is a specific ratio of methanol to powdered extract that I must follow?

reddit.com
u/Complete_Flamingo_34 — 4 days ago

Is this oxidation of copper? Why only parts of it? It’s on the cold water pipe but not the hot water pipe - any reason for that? Does it mean it is deteriorating? Water tank/heater.. asking just from curiosity really, not concerned.

Please remove if this isn’t the place to ask.

Edit!! Blue and red isn’t to do with heat. I assumed it because when I made the post the blue inlet was cold and the red outlet was warm. Both are warm/hot now.

u/moerlingo — 5 days ago

A question about the equilibrium constant

Doing a research for a work to my classroom, going by the kinectics definition of K, which I'll explain shortly justo to get my point.

Considering an reaction: aA + bB ⇌ cC + dD

we have that the rate of equation (in portuguese we call it reaction velocity) for the forwards and backwards direction is:

vf = kf [A]a [B]b and v^(b)=k^(b)[C]^(c)[D]^(d)

We can use this to build the equilibrium constant, K=CD/AB, which does not have any units.

Now here is my question, K doesnt have any units because we consider the activity of the species (and because by the gibbs energy the argument is inside a logarithm so it needs to be dimensioneless). But if we need to consider activitys in K, so it must be that the concentration in the rate equations must be activity instead, which bugs me out because if that's is true, for the units of the velocity to be mols/L.s the entire rate constant should be mols/L.s, which dont seems right to me. If someone could clarify this to me I would be really happy, thanks!!

reddit.com
u/LeozinhoBackflip — 4 days ago

Random chemicals in street art

Hi folks, I've noticed some art in Toronto depicting chemicals. I'm not a chemist so I'm coming to this community for help. What are these?

This is at Trillium Park. I also saw one in an art installation under the gardener but sadly it was removed before I took a picture of it.

Thanks in advance kind people :)

u/FlakyDevelopment1103 — 7 days ago
▲ 13 r/AskChemistry+2 crossposts

Seeking help to mix graphene oxide nanoparticles with soy wax

Hello, a mech eng grad student here! Had problem with dispersing graphene oxide on soy wax, which the graphene oxide wouldnt stick to the wax and instead pools at the bottom. Are there any ways to avoid this problem by using specific method or substance? Thanks in advance!

u/adityaputra2005 — 6 days ago