r/Citibike

I mapped all 2,458 Citi Bike stations to their borough. Manhattan has 19% of the people and 45% of the docks
▲ 49 r/Citibike+1 crossposts

I mapped all 2,458 Citi Bike stations to their borough. Manhattan has 19% of the people and 45% of the docks

I pulled Citi Bike's live station feed, every station, every dock dropped each one into its actual borough (point-in-polygon on the city's official boundaries) and lined it up against 2020 population. Here's who actually has Citi Bike.

Borough Docks Docks per 10k % of docks % of people

Manhattan 31,927 188 45% 19%

Brooklyn 20,138 74 28% 31%

Queens 11,223 47 16% 27%

Bronx 7,792 53 11% 17%

Staten Island 0 0 0% 6%

So, the headline: Manhattan has 45% of every Citi Bike dock in the city but only 19% of the people 2.3x its fair share. A Manhattan resident gets 188 docks per 10,000 people; a Queens resident gets 47. Four times the access for the same membership.

Manhattan alone (1.7M people) has more docks — 31,927 — than Queens and the Bronx combined (19,015 docks, 3.9M people).

And Staten Island, half a million people, has zero. Not "a few." Zero.

"But Manhattan's denser, so obviously" — I checked, and density doesn't explain it. Manhattan is about twice as dense as the Bronx (74k vs 35k people/sq mi), but it has seven times the dock density (1,398 vs 185 docks/sq mi).

The Bronx is actually denser than Queens and still gets fewer docks per person than Brooklyn. If Citi Bike tracked where people actually live, Queens and the Bronx would have roughly double what they've got. It doesn't track density — it tracks the rollout map, which went Manhattan and brownstone Brooklyn first and worked outward.

To be fair: it's expanding — the Bronx only got real coverage recently, and more is planned. But right now, this is the map. The most central, most-Manhattan blocks are swimming in docks; the outer boroughs, where most New Yorkers actually live, get the leftovers.

So what: Citi Bike moves well over 100,000 rides a day — it's basically public transit now. But it's distributed like a luxury amenity. "Bike share for New York" is really bike share for the third of New York that already had the best transit to begin with.

Sources: Citi Bike's public GBFS station feed (live dock counts), 2020 Census borough populations, and NYC's official borough boundary polygons. Happy to share the numbers or break it down by neighborhood if anyone wants. NYC Intel

u/Kitchen_Cable6192 — 3 days ago

Normalize "Slow Zones" in Parks

You know how boats have "no wake zones" in high collision-risk areas? E-Bikes need a no wake zone.

Recommended slow zones:
- Pedestrian paths.
- Sidewalks (I don't think E-Bikes should be on sidewalks at all, but if you are, go slow please).
- Congested open streets with lots of pedestrians (like Berry in Greenpoint on busy days).

Bike lanes / roads = full speed.

u/josiah_clagett — 3 days ago

Flat rate to Manhattan?

They don’t do this anymore? Used to be that if you’re traveling from the outer boroughs (in my case Queens) into Manhattan, it’d be a flat rate of like $5.84 or something like that. I notice that anytime I cycle into the city they’re charging me for the full thing now.

Wondering if anyone else noticed this.

reddit.com
u/Famous_Ad536 — 4 days ago
▲ 176 r/Citibike+2 crossposts

CitiBike Forest Hills, Queens expansion: 75 % complete; Austin St near LIRR, neckdowns, daylighting; 10/10 would ride again.

Stations use the new round dock mini-tower; most stations have no kiosk. Many stations are positioned upstream of intersections, which is excellent for intersection daylighting. CitiBike access to Forest Hills LIRR from Austin St is an important supplement to Woodside LIRR. Station by Jewel Ave and GCP is perfect for rides through FMCP. No complaints !

u/TwoWheelsTooGood — 6 days ago

BikeAngels- no more than 1 point for drop offs?

Am I crazy or has it always been this way? That for any drop off station, there’s never more than 1 point for dropping it off? Like the only way to increase your point intake is from picking up at a high point station but dropping off will never earn you more than 3 points (with the 3x multiplier)… I thought that there used to be more than 1 point available at drop off stations.

But maybe I imagined that?

reddit.com
u/Tylersaysnamaste — 4 days ago

When does it make sense to use citi bike over train in nyc?

I just recently got hyped over citi bikes and want to use them more often. I loved the fresh air and feeling of being on a bike instead of cramped on a hot subway.

my problem is, the few e-bike rides i’ve taken have been far more expensive than just hopping on a train. Biked from LES (~delancey/allen) to HK (~46th st) and it was $20! Then biked from HK to 8th Ave L stop, another $16 (granted in both these instances i did waste time getting situated after I had already pulled the bike from the dock). I don’t have a lyft pink or citi bike membership.

Biking vs uber is obviously more economical and likely faster, but you can’t beat $3 for the subway. While there’s likely never a situation where e-biking will be cheaper than the subway, what are the best use cases for e-biking instead of subway? Is it worth getting a membership? Do you citi bike because of cost, speed, the experience, or something else?

Likely biking scenarios for me are maybe doing

A. ~2 longish distance one-way rides a week between either UWS and williamsburg, UWS and chelsea, or chelsea and williamsburg (or a multi-stop ride where I go UWS > Chelsea > Wburg,) — whichever makes the most sense.

B. and/or 2-3 shorter distance rides per week (could be one-way or round trip) within williamsburg.

reddit.com
u/boomchickacity7 — 8 days ago

New Brownsville stations are being set up

Huge deal for those in/near the area like me! Original expansion map plans (Community Boards 16 and 17) are available here.

FYI these are different from the East New York plans (Community Board 5) which are available here, I imagine those will be coming shortly as well. I'm super looking forward to being able to bike to Highland Park.

u/ThatsMarvelous — 6 days ago

Which NYC Citi Bike stations are completely empty right now

If you ever try to grab a bike and find nothing there you are not alone because right now 69 Citi Bike stations are completely empty which is like 3 percent of the whole entire system. It is super annoying when you are rushing and you show up to a dead dock and it turns out midtown is getting hit the hardest by this.

  • 🥇 E 47 St & 2 Ave — 102 docks and 9 bikes
  • 🥈 11 Ave & W 41 St — 55 docks and 0 bikes
  • 🥉 E 43 St & 2 Ave — 52 docks and 4 bikes
  • Hudson Blvd W & W 36 St — 47 docks and 0 bikes
  • W 36 St & 9 Ave — 43 docks and 5 bikes

So basically if you are trying to commute around the 30s and 40s right now you are probably going to be walking instead. And honestly this is exactly why people end up switching back to the subway or just taking an Uber because it does not matter how many new docks Lyft puts down if they can't even van the bikes around fast enough to keep up with the morning rush hour.

u/Kitchen_Cable6192 — 7 days ago

They have got to figure out parking in midtown Manhattan, full stop

When the subway fucks up and suddenly my train won't stop anywhere near my office, and I choose to get off the train and ride the rest of the way in the rain, and then there's zero parking spots within 4 avenues of my office, or there's supposedly one dock but that dock seemingly does not exist, and support either doesn't respond quickly or tells me tough shit because both parking and overflow parking are full, meanwhile the clock is ticking and they're getting more and more of my money, what are we even doing here guys

Sorry for the rant I just do not understand why for the eBikes we can't just end the ride from the app and it locks the gears versus needing to find an open dock in the most commuter dense district in the whole country

I don't care about points or rewards or whatever I just want to end my ride reasonably near my office!!!

reddit.com
u/littlebev — 13 days ago
▲ 71 r/Citibike+1 crossposts

I spent all of April trying to dethrone NS143 as NYC's #1 Citi Bike Angel. Here's day one.

You know the leaderboard — and you know that #1 spot belongs to NS143, who somehow holds down a full-time job and still averages about 475 points a day. So I gave myself 30 days to try to beat him. Day one alone: 15+ hours on the streets, 57 bikes moved, 54,000 steps (which my phone says equals about 27 miles on foot)... and I was still nowhere close. I filmed the whole thing. Episode 1 is up and I'd genuinely love this community's take:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C0gog76JwQE&t=46s

u/pvp10027 — 13 days ago

CitiBike Leaderboard

I love going fast on the blue bikes for exercise. But I didn't know how fast I was compared to other riders. I wanted to change that.

I built a website that ranks the fastest times on manual bikes between any two stations.

Note that the data CitiBike publishes is a month delayed. This website is also anonymous— if you want to know how you rank, you'll need to compare the times and dates in your CitiBike app to the times listed here.

Let me know what you think! Check it out: https://citibike-leaderboard.up.railway.app/

reddit.com
u/International-Song22 — 10 days ago

yft/charged me $100 and is threatening a $1,300 lost bike fee after telling me I'd be refunded

I wanted to share my experience to see if anyone else has gone through something similar and to warn others.

Yesterday, I rented a Citi Bike and returned it to a docking station. As I always do, I pushed the bike into the dock until it appeared to be secured. I had no reason to believe the bike had not been returned properly.

Later, I discovered that my ride had never ended. I immediately contacted Citi Bike/Lyft support. After explaining exactly what happened, the customer service representative told me that I would receive a refund and that the issue would be taken care of. Based on those representations, I believed the matter had been resolved.

Instead, Lyft has now:

  • Charged me $100.
  • Told me they are investigating whether to charge me up to $1,300 for a supposedly "lost" bike.
  • Contradicted what their own representative previously told me.

If a dock malfunctions or fails to properly register a returned bike, customers have almost no way to prove they did everything correctly. We don't receive a confirmation from the physical dock itself, and unless someone happens to record themselves returning every bike, we're expected to somehow prove that the system failed rather than us.

Even more concerning is that customer support initially acknowledged the issue and told me I would be refunded, only for another representative to later reverse that position. It feels like different departments aren't communicating, while customers are left facing hundreds or even thousands of dollars in potential charges.

Unfortunately, I did not keep track of the historical conversation. I filed to consumer worker protection.

I've also contacted my credit card company to discuss disputing the charge if this isn't resolved.

Has anyone here successfully fought a similar charge? If so, what finally worked? Did you have to file a chargeback, contact consumer protection, or continue escalating with Lyft?

reddit.com
u/OneEmergency9426 — 10 days ago

Did the citibike e-bike contribute to a herniated disc injury?

Multiple things can add up to a herniated disc, a common back injury if you are over 40. Our spines aren’t perfect, and most people in their fifties would have a bulge or two if they took an MRI (source: my doctor).

But I experienced a very slow onset of sciatica that eventually progressed into what was found to be a herniated disc. But here’s the funny thing- only experienced the pain while riding a citibik e-bike.

If you go to any amusement park many rides will say flat out “do not ride if you have prior back or neck injuries”. For some rides it’s obvious - intense roller coasters. But many rides aren’t coasters and still have this warning due to “bumping up and down, jerking side to side, and shaking seating”.

E-bikes are HEAVY. They have ZWRO suspension. And if you ride over a small bump you FEEL it. Even bumps you can’t see. And NYC streets are ROUGH. A regular citibike doesn’t even compare in bumpiness. Which is why I kiss the modded e-bikes. They were lighter.

Now imagine you’re me and riding an e-bike to work 3-5 times a week both ways.

“That is absolutely a candidate for the cause of your back injury. You should t ride them anymore”

reddit.com
u/Tempest_Fugit — 11 days ago

Docks Around Grand Central

Anybody else have issues finding a place to dock your bike around Grand Central the past couple of days? I needed to run to an appointment so I couldn’t keep searching for a dock. The chat support has been totally unhelpful.

u/GDmQh4Jt — 12 days ago

Blocked Bike Lane

Citi bike removed the station in front of Wegmans @Asor Pl for paving. DOT has decided to make the old station a bike lane. Big Mistake. Delivery bikes, scooters & cars are using the bike lane for parking pushing bike riders into traffic. That's when cyclists get killed.

u/stevenghill — 12 days ago

Changing to Lyft Pink

I’m contemplating changing my membership to Lyft Pink since I will be in Chicago next month & think that will allow me to use Divvy.

I am concerned about doing it wrong and losing my 5000+ accumulated angel points. Also, I use points to extend my membership; I’ve only actually paid for annual membership in 2020 when I first joined.

As a Lyft Pink member, can I continue using points to extend my membership monthly? And what is the correct way to switch and retain my existing points? Thanks to anyone who’s done this and responds.

reddit.com
u/ileentotheleft — 10 days ago

Network down for anyone else?

I tried multiple docks in Brooklyn, same message every time.

u/CataclysmClive — 12 days ago