Homeowners insurance in Naples is getting completely out of hand. Any broker recs?
I knew the insurance market here in SWFL was a mess, but shopping for a new policy this month has been an absolute nightmare.
Our current premium for the house just went up by almost 40% and they’re offering way less coverage. Looked at the print last night and the hurricane deductible is crazy, plus they basically excluded water backup. Feels like if a bad storm hits the coast again, we’re just paying out of pocket anyway.
A neighbor of mine told me to stop wasting time with mass-market companies if the house has a higher valuation. He said the big retail guys just screw you over on claims anyway and suggested finding a private broker to look into a proper high net worth insurance policy instead. Apparently those private client setups actually cover storm damage and water backup without all the crazy sub-limits, but idk, I’ve never used a private broker before. Always just got standard online quotes.
Kinda lost here. Anyone in the Naples/Collier area actually happy with their coverage? Did you find a decent independent agent or are you just biting the bullet and overpaying the big carriers?