r/americandad

I had an idea for an episode that I just needed to get out of my head. It's a single plot episode where Roger is seen for the first few minutes before making an incredibly obvious excuse and leaving the scene. Throughout the rest of the episode we are introduced to several new outlandish characters who each member of the family is conviced one of them is Roger. The family tries to test each character to determine who is Roger but the answers are just vague enough to keep everyone guessing. The main story concludes where each new character leaves the scene for an also outlandishly fake reason. Riger comes back into the scene immedietly after the last new character leaves, he is certain that he has no idea what the family is talking about and he wssnt any of the characters, he plays their questions off enough where it's semi believable but leaves it open.

Throughout the rest of the season, each new character pops up as a background or throwaway character in scenes without Roger. This leaves the question of who if any were Roger, up to the viewer and the community.

Will this happen? Of course not, fox doesn't read reddit. But it seemed like a fun idea and a nod to the fans so I just wanted to express it.

Earlier I asked what episode people thought was underrated or not talked about enough. It also got me thinking what episodes do you think are the most popular or the most talked about? Not necessarily an overrated episode but just a really popular one. I feel that maybe hot water or hurricane might be two really popular ones but I’m not sure.