r/askarchitects

Image 1 — Looking for feedback
Image 2 — Looking for feedback
▲ 38 r/askarchitects+2 crossposts

Looking for feedback

Currently under contract on this 1940s colonial in New England and have been playing around with some ideas to give the exterior more character.

I like craftsman and arts & crafts style homes which is some of the inspiration. I’m considering a covered portico with decorative woodwork, new window trim, lighting, wood front door, cornice/wave detailing, shutters, cedar fence and possibly some landscaping upgrades (the goal would be to do this in phases).

I’m curious what everyone thinks of my overall design. First is the current exterior and second is an ai generated rendering. I’m open to feedback that would give the house more character.

Last thing, I’m not entirely sure how to go about getting something like this done. I obviously need to hire professionals but would I need an architect or could a contractor handle it? Also is it appropriate to share an AI rendering with a professional as a starting point or is that frowned upon? If anyone has ever done something similar, especially in New England, I’d love to hear you experience and any info you’re willing to share.

Appreciate any thought or suggestions!

u/zcartwright01 — 5 days ago
▲ 21 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

Architects Marking Property Lines

I know i’m not the only one who comes across plans where an architect or drafter marks “property lines” or “boundaries”. No PLS. No boundary survey on file. Correct me if i’m wrong but this is very illegal and wrong.

ALSO———- Why does the county always require site plans to show property lines, but they also say you don’t need a boundary survey. This has been a re occurring question from my colleagues, clients etc.

-California

reddit.com
u/Emotional_Army_1650 — 5 days ago
▲ 26 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

What are some extreme, 180 career changes you’ve seen?

I frequently see posts about moving on from conventional architectural practice to work in a related field, maybe in construction management or real estate.

But I’m curious to hear about extreme career or lifestyle changes, where someone totally noped out of architecture and the built environment altogether, and started a flower shop or opened a bar.

reddit.com
u/HareevHajina — 5 days ago

Holding Brand Specs

Architects, why do you insist on brands like Armstrong Ceilings, Sherman Williams, etc when no one can tell the difference and the performance is the same?

reddit.com
u/Key_Judgment9601 — 5 days ago

What is the purpose of this rotated window?

A few years ago I was biking around Berlin and found this unusually placed window. I know enough (very little) about architecture to think "well, that's not distributing weight correctly to be functional so I guess it's a little architect's joke, haha, only in Berlin" and so on.

The other day I randomly came across a picture of Aarhus cathedral, not going to link a picture here but easily googleable, and you can see the same thing, arched windows rotated 135 degrees dotted around the high reaches of the exterior.

Googling around wasn't able to confirm the purpose so I ask here, why is this a thing? And is it only contained to these two buildings, or was it a wider practice?

My only guess of what it could possibly be for is casting a light onto the floor, that when taking into account the angle of the sun the shape of the shadow is then orthogonal to the walls at a particular time of day that is meaningful. Which seems insane, but that's all I've got.

Please, if you know the answer to this let me know, or if you have a good guess (but let me know you're guessing so I don't spread incorrect explanations!) Thanks

u/negamuse — 7 days ago
▲ 10 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

Houseplan review

This is a houseplan in a plot area of 2400sqft for a family of three in Southindia. There is a semi independent studio space for the father on the ground floor and a large open garden area on the eastern side.
Kindly review the plan and give honest feedbacks and suggestions.
Thankyou

u/Creative-Ad-6809 — 5 days ago
▲ 3 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

architecture club ideas

im not sure if this is the right sub to ask, but I wanted to start an architecture club at school.

my school recently took down our only architecture class and I want to have an opportunity to participate in architectural activities. the only issue is i dont know what it should have. many of the clubs at my school are focused around medical and business and theyre mainly competition based. so i dont know how it should be set up.

any ideas or advice would be appreciated!

reddit.com
u/Hearts4Kura — 4 days ago
▲ 0 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

Houseplan Review

This is a houseplan in a plot area of 2400sqft for a family of three in Southindia. There is a semi independent studio space for the father on the ground floor and a large open garden area on the eastern side.
Kindly review the plan and give honest feedbacks and suggestions.
Thankyou

u/Creative-Ad-6809 — 5 days ago

Attitude Towards AI

I am a prospective M.Arch student who has become completely engrossed in architecture over the past couple years. My current job involves AI training and I despise it. The community college I've been taking architecture courses at is very pro-AI. Some students even use gemini and chat gpt for their final renderings, which have major inconsistencies with their plans and other drawings. Professors say it's important to know how to use AI and make sure it's accurate, but that's about it. The architecture specific AI softwares and add ons seem more reliable and helpful, but deep down I'm still hesitant to use it knowing how it came to be, among other reasons.

I don't expect for AI to disappear or for every firm to reject it, but I'm just wondering if there are architects out there who don't involve it in their workflow. Am I doomed if I want to avoid AI in my long-term career?

reddit.com
u/diettwizzlers — 5 days ago
▲ 4 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

Help with floor plan!

Hi everyone! We need some help with the floorplan for a future in-law suite we’ll be building. For background, we’ll be buying my in-laws house and then adding this addition to it. We’ve gotten a few variations of this but we’re not happy. (My father-in-law has chosen this building company and is spear heading it. If it were up to me I’d be looking elsewhere but that’s not the point.) So if anyone is bored and wants to offer some advice, that would be lovely!

Here’s the must haves -
It has to be no more than 822 sq ft
We need to have a door to the garage (west/left side)
A second half bath (could be combined with laundry room)
Ideally living spaces would be south facing (right now they are east facing)
Ideally ADA compatible or at least close to it

Here’s what we don’t like -
No windows facing east and not enough windows facing south
Entry from garage seems bizarre and awkward and there’s no second toilet
No pantry
**Edited to add the front door way in the corner is weird

Thanks in advance!

u/dogmomMal — 4 days ago

Choosing Design-Build vs. Architect-Designer

Hi! I'm in escrow for a historical house, and I'd like to get some guidance on feasibility and cost for a kitchen renovation and also possibly converting part of the house into an ADU. Would you recommend I have an architecture firm (that also has a design team) or a design-build firm to come out for a site visit? Any recommendations for those that do great work in Pasadena? Thank you!

reddit.com
u/BKtoLAgirl — 5 days ago
▲ 1 r/askarchitects+1 crossposts

Need help on Vastu for my construction

I am planning to buy my ancestors home from scratch.

My current house is 50 year old and weal now and lot of seepage issue.

Please review my design and share feedback on vastu

u/iam_tyagi — 14 days ago

One help Guys 😭🥺

Hii guys I want to do

Heat transfer

Simulation of wind flow

Thermal analysis

HVAC

Energy conception in building

Lighting analysis

Mass transfer

For a simple 3bhk/2bhk single floor, can anyone please give me ideas how to do it I am not Rich enough to pay for those costly subscription for different apps. Can anyone please guide me or help me out

Please 🥺🤌

reddit.com
u/chaoticbutcute_9694 — 14 days ago