r/harrypotter

Like im rereading the deathly hallows and its the most egregious in that book but she sounds like pain in the ass to argue with. Like i get it its her character but lovegood was in a way right about how shes more close minded tho he was wrong in that situation

Shes the type of person to get into an argument give points and get pissed off when you gove your own points and never counter it properly..

Like obviously on rewatch you know harry is right on the deathly hallows thing so your naturally annoyed at Hermione but she doesnt give him the time of day like it pisses me off yk

Great character otherwise tho, dont come at me.

For me I think Sirius and Snape both were not from a happy household.

I believe this because of the amount of material it just bypasses by Filch posting another rule.

So much could’ve been done with this movie….I was so disappointed when I watched it the day it came out. And every time I watched it again. And yes I know I shouldn’t have watched it again if I disliked it so, but my mother wanted to watch it about 8 years ago…and since then my daughter has wanted to watch it.

Sanpe - ‘i see no difference’ . That shitty guy!!
Book - GoF

This made me furious..he was through and through a shitty guy.

He was named Remus (raised by wolves) Lupin (wolf) by his parents. He was not born a werewolf. Was it a sick joke or prophecy that a kid named after wolves would be bitten by a werewolf?

How in the hell did Voldemort not know that disarming someone gives you control over their wand? Like someone with his magical knowledge surely should know this. It just seems ridiculous to me.

Or was it just Harry having plot armor?

I’m not sure why this just came to mind, but do we know if Rowling changed anything in the later books because she had the films in mind while writing them?

It seems hard to imagine writing the same way when you know some of the biggest movies of the decade will be based on what you’re working on. Maybe she thought “This scene would look great on screen,” and went that way becauseof that.

I was listening to the audiobook where Crabbe loses control of fiend fire in the room of requirement and it sounded a lot like the fire that Voldemort used against Dumbledore in the ministry in Order of the Phoenix.

Was that fiend fire? And Voldemort was just more powerful and could wield it?

Edit: I know the duel in the book is different from the movie and there's no fire. But I'm asking in the context of the movie.

Was Eileen pronounced EYE-leen or EE-leen? Asking because I always read it as the second, since it was translated that way into Serbian. Only listened to Come On, Eileen recently, and realized Eileen was pronounced EYE-leen.

So, if you are expelled from school you have your wand destroyed. Yet when you go to jail it looks like your wand sits somewhere you can retrieve at your earliest convenience after break out. What’s up with that? And that seems to only apply to the bad guys. Sirius doesn’t seem to have wand until later and I’m guessing he had to procure one?

I'm sad that now there is no point of waiting for my Hogwarts letter. I'm 18 and I feel too old to be talking about harry potter all day

I started reading Harry Potter at the age of 11. I was the same age as the characters and from there it has played a very big role in my life as it has given me some of my happiest memories.

I used to talk about it all day with my father who passed away 2 years ago when I was 16. I watched the movies with him. Told him the stories of all characters in detail and discussed about which Hogwarts house we would be in.

I remember telling my dad that we would go to the universal studios together and have butterbeer