r/shouldibuythiscar

Image 1 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 2 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 3 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 4 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 5 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 6 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 7 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 8 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 9 — Should I buy and fix this car?
Image 10 — Should I buy and fix this car?
▲ 9 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

Should I buy and fix this car?

One of my friends has an sq5 that recently has a piston head melt issue or something of the sort. and needs to get rid of his car, hes offering it to me for $4000. I just wanted to know whether or not the damage is bad enough to the point its not worth fixing myself or getting fixed for what the cars worth. It's a 2018 sq5 prestige with 145000 miles and everything ran great before this, ive driven the car on several occasions and have been eyeing sq5's for a minute. clean title. Any help appreciated, pictures attatched.

u/Familiar-Pipe7423 — 8 hours ago
▲ 5 r/shouldibuythiscar+4 crossposts

2018 Nissan Rouge SV AWD 124k miles with proper maintenance record and transmission fluid changed at 84k. Priced at $8500. Should I go ahead?

Please suggest me guys.

reddit.com
u/engimb — 20 hours ago
▲ 6 r/shouldibuythiscar+3 crossposts

What price should I sell my Scion tC for?

In northern nj. 2012 tC with 220k miles on it. No issues. Newer tires and brakes. Passed inspection with no engine issues or check lights. One owner me. Minor cosmetic wear outside inside. One minor car accident that scratched the rear bumper. But did nothing else to the car.

reddit.com
u/Secret-Shoe-6114 — 21 hours ago

2000 Honda crv

I really like crvs and this guy said he would take 4k for it, my biggest concern is the rust I don’t know how bad rust is he said he doesn’t need it anymore cause he has 4 cars it has 163k miles it’s on coilovers has an exhaust has push to start, I would love opinions, for context I need a car that won’t break down on me I’m moving to florida and might drive the car I get I can answer any questions thanks

u/DepressedMogi — 22 hours ago

What would you pay?

2014 Mazda 3 GS-Sky 2L In-Line PE
218,000km

All service records available
All weather tires
Brand new suspension
Oil undercoating annually
Oil changes every 6-8 months
No damage, no visible rust, no issues with the frame

Safetied vs not safetied. How much would you pay?

u/TheGentleComeback — 20 hours ago
▲ 3 r/shouldibuythiscar+2 crossposts

2015 Scion xB, 174k miles, for $6550… thoughts?

Main, general inquiry in the title.

I’m in SW PA (where we have both body and emissions inspections) and have desperately been looking for a new-to-me vehicle for 2 months now. Most of the vehicles I’ve found in my price range (with $7k being the out-the-door cap) have either been rusted out or need major, immediate work. This one, as far as I currently know, is in decent condition and know it’s currently inspected, but have yet to see it in person; it’s over an hour away from where I live.

Currently plan on my mum driving me out there tomorrow with intent to buy, but am very anxious at this prospect because I can’t get a PPI from someone I trust before purchase. Got a PPI from my mechanic on a nearly identical xB the other day, but with 249k miles and for $4500 firm. Mechanic said that one wasn’t a good deal, considering he saw that it would need an exhaust (~$1k) within the next year, and given that plus the high miles said it was worth closer to $3500; the owner wouldn’t budge on the price. Overall though, he said the xB’s are pretty solid cars and suggested I check out the $6550 one further.

reddit.com
u/SmokingGunontheRun — 18 hours ago
▲ 18 r/shouldibuythiscar+2 crossposts

2013 Transit connect xlt for 8k? 47k miles

Hello all, I was looking to convert this transit connect I found on fb marketplace into a camper van for me and my fiancé and wanted to know if this is worth it or if I should look in another direction.

It’s a 2013 and only has 47k miles on it. It does have the abs and traction control light on and the owner said he doesn’t know why as it just turned on. Otherwise it runs great with no issues.

I’m new to this and could use some advice, thanks!

u/TheCrusader42 — 1 day ago
▲ 10 r/shouldibuythiscar+2 crossposts

Should I Buy This Corolla?

Looking at this 2016 CVT S at a local dealership on Monday, and I wanted some input on the price and the accident reports. It is priced currently at 12k and has about 100k miles on it. 4 previous owners. I am bringing my uncle in-law to look at it with me and see if there’s any hidden damage.

Is this potentially a good buy? If so, what would be a good offer?

u/PishwualPhiscal — 2 days ago
▲ 4 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

Would you buy? 2012 Corolla

I have the opportunity to obtain a 2012 Toyota Corolla L with 12,000 miles.

It was owned as part of corporate fleet that included other more fun/faster cars and so it was only really driven when all the other cars were in use. Sounds like it spent 90% of it's life in a underground garage. CarFax doesn't have any service records but my mechanic took a look at the car and it's in pristine condition except for the tires which are original from 2012 and although with plenty of tread will need to be replaced.

I've been offered to purchase the car before it goes to auction for $14,899. No opportunity for negotiation.

It's a reliable car (probably the best generation of this car) but it's still 13 years old. The price is making me hesitate.

Would you buy it?

reddit.com
u/Mission-Research — 2 days ago
▲ 5 r/shouldibuythiscar+2 crossposts

Scared of getting this high mileage corolla, what do yall think?

Hey guys i’m looking into a 2022 Toyota Corolla SE hatchback with around 150,000 miles.

I’m using this car as college commute and just something decent I can drive. Only thing that scares me off is the mileage. Does anyone know how long it will last as well as any tips to maximize life span?

reddit.com
u/Terrible-Hawk-407 — 3 days ago
▲ 29 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

I did it.

So for those who hadn’t seen the post at https://www.reddit.com/r/shouldibuythiscar/s/IDGK1Y4VH5 basically I was contemplating buying this 2004 Acura TL for $1200. When I met up with the guy, I talked him down to $700. The oil dipstick was broken so we opened the oil cap and it looked like chocolate milk(head gasket) so we bought it for $700. Opened the dipstick today and found no chocolate milk. The car started up just fine and there was no white smoke that came out. The check engine light also went away. When you close and tighten the gas cap, you’re supposed to turn it at least 3 clicks or the CEL will come on. When I bought it, it wasn’t in the same position as those 3 clicks(possibly triggering the CEL). Came up just nicely on this purchase.

u/Jadsworth_YT — 3 days ago
▲ 23 r/shouldibuythiscar+2 crossposts

What would you pay for this 54,500 km 2000 Mk4 Golf 2.0 manual? Seller wants $8,000 CAD

I’m looking for a cheap, reliable commuter car to use while I’m at university, and I found this 2000 Volkswagen Golf Mk4 listed for $7,999 CAD in Ontario.

Details:
- 2.0L gasoline engine
- 5-speed manual
- 54,500 km
- One owner
- Seller says it was maintained at a VW dealership
- No warning or engine lights
- Being sold as-is
- Visible rust at the bottom of both front fenders
- Dent on the rear hatch

I have heard that the 2.0L manual Mk4 drivetrain can be very reliable and inexpensive to maintain, which is what attracted me to it. The mileage is extremely low, but I understand that the car is still 26 years old and low mileage does not prevent age-related problems.

The rust concerns me because it is located where the front fenders meet the rocker panels. I know the front fenders can be replaced, but I’m worried there may be more rust underneath or behind them.

The seller is calling it “collectible,” but $8,000 CAD seems high for an as-is car with visible rust. I would only consider buying it after a pre-purchase inspection and reviewing the dealership service records, especially the timing-belt and water-pump history.

What do you think this car is realistically worth? Would this be a good university commuter, or would I be overpaying because of the low mileage? What specific Mk4 issues should I have inspected?

Thanks for any help!

u/Classic_Lavishness25 — 3 days ago
▲ 4 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

2005 Tahoe z71 340k miles $2000

i have a coworker getting rid of their tahoe. it’s pretty nice. they were telling me the 4wd hub needs to be replaced they have a 2wd on it now. (something like that i’m not 100% i forget) also said in winter the oil pressure drops sometimes? but other than that it drives really good. better than my malibu with 240k miles on it. i think i want it but i need other with experience with these to tell me if its smart or not. thank you for your time! also the motor and transmission was rebuilt 2 years ago. is this a good buy or no? i will keep my malibu for daily driving or longer distance. but i want an suv for trips/ work.

reddit.com
u/Repulsive_Debate9180 — 3 days ago
▲ 8 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

is this a good deal?

test drove a 2002 tundra v8 today and looking to get some advice. priced at $6.9k, 182k miles. in decent condition other than non-functioning ac. it’s in upstate ny so there’s a little bit of rust on the frame from road salt but it seemed to be in good condition. ive read that ball joints can be a problem on older toyotas but the guy i talked to said they were in good condition.

is this a good deal? im interested but the ac has me concerned and idk how much it’ll cost to get that up and running. a few pics attached.

u/izzyvalentineisdead — 3 days ago
▲ 6 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

FOR SALE : NISSAN PATROL 2014 V8 PLATINUM ONLY 170K km ran.

PRICE : 48,000 ( NEGOTIABLE)
CONTACT - 0508067996

✅ 2014 Nissan Patrol V8 Platinum (Full Option)
✅ GCC Specifications
✅ Family Used Vehicle
✅ Powerful V8 Engine
✅ Well Maintained & Very Clean
✅ No Major Accidents
✅ All Maintenance Done Regularly
✅ Tires in Good Condition
✅ Smooth Drive & Strong Performance
✅ Spacious and Comfortable Interior
✅ Perfect for Family Use and Long-Distance Driving
✅ Ready to Drive – No Immediate Expenses

u/SmoothBoss3633 — 3 days ago
▲ 3 r/shouldibuythiscar+3 crossposts

Is this 2011 Subaru Forester with a brand-new dealer-installed engine a unicorn or a trap? ($7,000)

Hi everyone,
I’m looking for some honest feedback on a used car deal I am negotiating. It’s a 2011 Subaru Forester 2.5X Premium.
The Price: Listed at $7,000. The dealership gave me an out-the-door (OTD) price of $7,900
The Odometer: The chassis has around 108,000 miles on it.
The Good (Major Mechanical Work Done):
The CARFAX shows 45 detailed service records, and a certified Subaru dealer recently replaced major components.
Brand-new factory engine short block core installed by Subaru.
Brand-new timing belt installed.
Brand-new steering rack and pinion.
Brand-new power steering pump.
Fresh professional transmission fluid flush.
The Bad / Concerns:
Accident History: The CARFAX lists 3 separate "Minor Damage" incidents. No airbags deployed, and no structural/frame damage is noted. it looks like they were mostly cosmetic parking lot or bumper incidents, but it's still 3 accidents.
Immediate Maintenance Needed: It needs new tires, front brakes (pads and rotors), and spark plugs right away. I estimate this will cost me about $1,500 out of pocket.

reddit.com
u/engimb — 3 days ago
▲ 4 r/shouldibuythiscar+1 crossposts

Buy or not

Hello everyone,
I am currently driving a Ford Ecosport 2019 petrol model. The car is fine and driven 80k km till now. But since Ford has closed its shop and considering the ethanol fiasco I am contemplating the idea of buying a new car. I find the maths of EV totally solid and want to buy one. But here are my concerns:

  1. I am in a transferable job so I’m not sure if today I am ata place where I can get a home charger, tomorrow someplace else whether I can get one or not. So will be depending on public chargers.
  2. Whether i should sell my car in the first place or not just because I like EVs and want to buy one. My car is doing fine and has given me no problem except the fuel efficiency part.
  3. My budget is somewhere around 17-18lakhs and I want to get a top spec model of EV whichever I buy, so the options are fairly limited (Punch Nexon windsor)
    Should I continue driving my Ecosport till 15 years and see it then.
    Am I thinking right?
reddit.com
u/JageeraSpeaking — 3 days ago
▲ 7 r/shouldibuythiscar+3 crossposts

2026 Pathfinder SL 4WD Premium package with captain’s chairs- in PA zip is 18954 with zero Down

Just quotes below lease for 36 months / 12,000 mi

I do zero down and pay only the first month's payment at signing. I would like to know if there is more room to negotiate the sale price and how much more.

2026 Pathfinder SL 4WD Premium package with captain’s chairs
Exterior: Everest White Pearl TriCoat

MSRP- 51,150 (includes 1,545 destination and below options)
Options:
-SL Premium Captains Chair Package- 3,950
-Splash Guards-275
-Premium Paint-450
-Cross Bars- 435
-Captain chairs carpeted floor mats - 405

Dealer Quote
MSRP: $51,150
Selling price before rebate: $47,407 (Dealer discount: $3,743)
Rebate: $1,000
Adjusted price after rebate: $46,407

Fees included in the worksheet:
Acquisition fee: $695
Online fee: $23.54
Doc fee: $490
Title fee: $72
Registration fee: $48
Transfer fee: $11
Temp tag fee: $40

Worksheet balance: $47,786.54
Residual: $31,713 - 62%
Money factor: .00143

total Monthly payment: $611 (includes taxes)
611-Zero down, first month payment at signing.

Thoughts? Seems high

u/noahring — 4 days ago