Paige
Okay I’m fuller aware this is a VERY unpopular opinion. I actually think Paige was Emily’s 2nd best love interest. I know that the whole drowning thing was horrible but everyone’s love interests screwed up massively. Paige truly cared for Emily and even lost her trying to protect her. At first I always hate Paige but by the end of my re watch I honestly just feel bad for her.
But yes ik this is a very controversial opinion.