▲ 1 r/email

62.4% Open rate on first email newsletter - good or bad?

Hello all!

I recently got a Kit free account and launched my first newsletter that I've been procrastinating on. I run a local-based Instagram page (@dcspot) and I started a newsletter to share things to do in the Northern VA/DC area. It went out to 314 subscribers and had a 62.4% open rate and a 7.3% click rate. Is this good?

Also, I was curious about the A/B testing. If I set it for 60 minutes, does it send out a few for the first hour to see which subject line does best, then select a winner and send the rest out to the rest of my subscribers? So if I send the emails out at 6pm will most of them not be sent until 7pm?

I had one email bounce. Should I unsubscribe that email? What can I do to improve my open rate? Any tips would be helpful, especially when it comes to a Kit email marketing account. Thank you in advance!

reddit.com
u/AlexHussein — 8 days ago

62.4% Open rate on first email newsletter - good or bad?

Hello all!

I recently got a Kit free account and launched my first newsletter that I've been procrastinating on. I run a local-based Instagram page (@dcspot) and I started a newsletter to share things to do in the Northern VA/DC area. It went out to 314 subscribers and had a 62.4% open rate and a 7.3% click rate. Is this good?

Also, I was curious about the A/B testing. If I set it for 60 minutes, does it send out a few for the first hour to see which subject line does best, then select a winner and send the rest out to the rest of my subscribers? So if I send the emails out at 6pm will most of them not be sent until 7pm?

I had one email bounce. Should I unsubscribe that email? What can I do to improve my open rate? Any tips would be helpful, especially when it comes to a Kit email marketing account. Thank you in advance!

reddit.com
u/AlexHussein — 8 days ago

62.4% Open rate on first email newsletter - good or bad?

Hello all!

I recently got a Kit free account and launched my first newsletter that I've been procrastinating on. I run a local-based Instagram page (@dcspot) and I started a newsletter to share things to do in the Northern VA/DC area. It went out to 314 subscribers and had a 62.4% open rate and a 7.3% click rate. Is this good?

Also, I was curious about the A/B testing. If I set it for 60 minutes, does it send out a few for the first hour to see which subject line does best, then select a winner and send the rest out to the rest of my subscribers? So if I send the emails out at 6pm will most of them not be sent until 7pm?

I had one email bounce. Should I unsubscribe that email? What can I do to improve my open rate? Any tips would be helpful, especially when it comes to a Kit email marketing account. Thank you in advance!

u/AlexHussein — 8 days ago

Looking for outside perspective on a positioning question.

I've spent years building DC Spot (@dcspot) — a local lifestyle brand covering food, events, and things to do across the DMV (DC, Maryland, Northern Virginia). It's grown into a real community page:

  • 404K on Instagram
  • 198K on TikTok
  • Active on Facebook and YouTube too

Brand deals with companies like the Washington Wizards, Lucky Strike, and Lidl. Audience is broad across the entire DMV metro.

I just got my Virginia real estate license and will be servicing Northern Virginia specifically. Trying to figure out my next move:

Option A: Rebrand DC Spot — keep the (@dcspot) handle but change the display name to something like "Alex H | Northern VA Realtor" and work real estate into the existing content.

Option B: Leave DC Spot alone and build my personal brand from 5k on (@alexh), keeping real estate completely separate.

Option C: Hybrid — keep DC Spot purely lifestyle, build (@alexh) for real estate, use DC Spot as a top-of-funnel awareness engine that feeds the personal brand (maybe add my personal name into DC Spot?).

For the personal brand, I want to lean heavily into an AI-powered content series — documenting how I'm using AI tools to level up across different areas of my life:

  • Using AI to study and pass my real estate license
  • Using AI to train me on real estate cold calls and objection handling
  • Using AI to engineer my dream body (training, macros, recovery)
  • Using AI for productivity, language learning, business ops, etc.

Basically positioning myself as a guy using AI as a personal performance stack — with real estate as the business arm of it.

My concerns with rebranding DC Spot:

  • Audience signed up for DMV lifestyle, not a realtor
  • Followers outside NoVA can't even use me as an agent (yet)
  • Risk of algorithm suppression from identity pivot
  • DC Spot has standalone brand value with sponsors

My concerns with starting (@alexh) from scratch:

  • Slow grind starting at 5k when I already have a massive audience on DC Spot
  • Splitting my time and energy between two content engines
  • Risk of looking inconsistent or scattered

For anyone who's navigated something similar — pivoting an established brand vs. building a personal one alongside it — what worked? Would the AI content angle be strong enough to differentiate a personal brand, or am I better off just funneling everything through DC Spot? If I did everything through DC Spot, I would continue the content I post then add some luxury local listings into my page which I think would get attention, I wouldn't really post AI content.

reddit.com
u/AlexHussein — 4 months ago