
My Review of one of AoS’s earliest and most forgotten novels: Labyrinth of the Lost
Yes, today I bring to you a review of a book that, to be honest, has mostly been forgotten even by the most diehard fans.
And after reading it, I can say: yeah, it checks out.
I don't mean to say the book is bad. It has some good ideas, but it never really lets them grow or, hell, even explore them, leaving it feeling unfinished at times and making you ask, "Is that it?"
It's okay at worst. You can finish it in a sitting and be entertained by the action, and by what I think is both the book's biggest strength and biggest fumble: its cast of characters.
So, from now on, I will be discussing spoilers. You have all been warned, probably all nine of you who are interested in reading this novel.
>!We start the novel with a Fyreslayer Doomseeker named Sornsson waking up and being confused by his surroundings. But before he can ponder things any further, he is joined by an Excelsior Warpriest named Masudro and his Gryph-hound.!<
>!At first, Sornsson is suspicious of Masudro, believing him to be a heretic, and asks him to prove that he truly is what he claims to be. Each piece of evidence Masudro gives to prove his innocence does nothing to abate Sornsson's suspicions. Eventually, Masudro points out that nothing he says will be able to prove his innocence and asks Sornsson to have faith that he isn't some Tzeentch trick.!<
>!Sornsson decides, for now, to trust him, and the two join together to explore this place, which Sornsson reveals to Masudro is the Silver Tower, much to Masudro's fear of being trapped in this Chaos-blasted place.!<
>!While searching for an exit, Sornsson jumps into a portal, much to Masudro's revulsion at getting any closer to something so chaotic. Not wanting to remain behind, however, he enters as well and arrives in a library in the middle of a fight.!<
>!There, he meets, to Masudro's relief, a Knight-Questor named Avanius, who is fighting a Blue Horror, and to his displeasure a Darkoath Chieftain named Hathrek, who is fighting Sornsson.!<
>!Before Masudro can act, he hears a voice that he attributes to Sigmar, telling him that he must join forces with the Darkoath if he intends to escape.!<
>!So, he decides to break up the fight between Sornsson and Hathrek, much to Sornsson's bafflement. This leaves Sornsson open, allowing the Chieftain to kick him away and turn his attention to the Horror that Avanius is fighting. Hathrek slays it, much to the Knight-Questor's surprise at being saved by a Darkoath.!<
>!Now, before the Stormcast and Fyreslayer can decide to jump the Darkoath, for being, you know, a Chaos worshipper and, in their eyes, probably being in league with the Gaunt Summoner.!<
>!This is much to Hathrek's annoyance, considering that he had just saved them minutes ago and hadn't shown any hostility toward them, especially considering that Sornsson was the one who attacked him first.!<
>!Before things can escalate any further, Masudro barges in and asks everyone to stop, much to Avanius and Sornsson's bafflement. Masudro points out that they are all in this together and shouldn't be fighting each other. Reluctantly, Avanius and Sornsson lower their weapons.!<
>! Masudro asks how the Knight-Questor and Darkoath Chieftain arrived here. Avanius says he came to hunt down the Gaunt Summoner, while Hathrek says he is here to save his tribe, Gadalhor.!<
>! Masudro can sense that Hathrek is telling the truth, but also feels that he hasn't revealed everything. Still, for now, he is pleased and invites the chieftain to joined them.!<
>! Hathrek, on the other hand, isn't interested in joining up with a priest of sigmar, knight Questor and a weird stunting, and tries to leave. Masudro attempts to stop and convince him, but Sornsson stops him.!<
>!At first, Masudro is angry that Sornsson has stopped him, until the Fyreslayer explains that Hathrek will return.!<
>! This confuses the priest until the Darkoath Chieftain appears from the same portal Masudro came through. This confuses both Masudro and Hathrek.!<
>! Sornsson explains that the Silver Tower, as far as he can tell, has a system where its victims are grouped into teams, meaning they are now unable to leave each other's side.Much to Hathrek's annoyance, he begrudgingly joins the team.!<
>! So our newly formed party of champions proceeds further until Hathrek decides to ask where they are going. Avanius, who has been leading the team, admits that he has been following a path directed by a voice that he believes belongs to Sigmar.!<
>! This surprises the group, with Masudro explaining that he has experienced the same thing. Even Sornsson has heard it, much to Hathrek's stupefaction.!<
>!The fact that they've all been following what he assumes to be a mysterious Tzeentchian voice makes Hathrek decide to take the lead because, apparently, he can't hear it and therefore believes he is unaffected.!<
>! The team decides to follow him. (For some reason, despite the path they've been following so far being safe, they decide to listen to and follow a Darkoath Chieftain. For Sigmar's sake.)!<
>!Unfortunately, this results in them encountering a cabal of cultists who attack them. They are almost defeated until someone saves them and reveals herself by puppeteering the corpses of the cultists.!<
>! She is a Mistweaver named Eithweil.!<
>! She reveals that she was the mysterious voice guiding them safely through the Silver Tower, using a map she created after interrogating a daemon. Unfortunately, that map is now useless after they strayed from her path. So now she has revealed herself to them and intends to guide them personally, making sure they don't die.!<
>! (Which I don't know why she didn't reveal herself before the team decided to follow Hathrek in the first place, while knowing that if they took that path it would render her map useless. But nope, she decides to reveal herself now.)!<
>!Eithweil reveals to the team that she seeks to kill the Gaunt Summoner. Seeing as they don't have any other choices, they decide to follow her plan.!<
>! While this is happening, a Clan Eshin Deathrunner named Scrytchwhisker, who was sent to kill the Gaunt Summoner, is spying on them and decides to follow them in secret so he can take the anything useful from the Mistweaver after he kills them.!<
>! Things happen, and they eventually arrive in a chamber where they are supposed to find the Gaunt Summoner. And they do.!<
>! They fight him, during which Masudro's Gryph-hound is melted into slime. (RIP good boy.)!<
>! The Gaunt Summoner then reveals that Hathrek came here to gain his boons, which causes Avanius to turn his blade on the Darkoath Chieftain.!<
>! Fortunately, Masudro manages to defeat the Gaunt Summoner. But before he can break up the fight between Avanius and Hathrek, he is assassinated by Scrytchwhisker, much to everyone's shock.!<
>!The Deathrunner escapes, deciding that it's better not to kill the others realizing they're simply too powerful for him.!<
>!After Masudro's funeral, everyone is grieving, especially Avanius, who blames himself for his death. He decides to put aside his pride regarding the Darkoath Chieftain and becomes the mediator of the team, much like Masudro was.!<
>!He asks Hathrek what he is truly here for, and Hathrek admits the truth: he is here to gain the Gaunt Summoner's gifts.!<
>!Avanius isn't pleased, but decides to let it slide, much to Hathrek's surprise.!<
>!After some more travel, they encounter another cabal of cultists accompanied by an Ogroid, which they defeat.!<
>!Before they continue, Sornsson accuses Eithweil of hiding the fact that she has been collecting a bunch of amulets, which shocks the rest of the team.!<
>!Before things can escalate, Avanius asks her to explain.!<
>!She begrudgingly does so, explaining that there are nine amulets and that if she collects them all, she will be able to summon the Gaunt Summoner.!<
>! This satisfies Sornsson and Hathrek enough that they decide not to kill her. But she's not done.!<
>! Spitefully, she accuses Sornsson of hiding his own fair share of secrets, specifically the ring he took from a skeleton and is wearing.!<
>! This turns everyone's suspicion toward him. Sornsson is forced to reveal that the ring belonged to an explorer whom he was supposed to guard while they explored the Silver Tower. Unfortunately, the explorer died, meaning Sornsson failed his oath and remained trapped inside the Silver Tower for a long time. Avanius and Hathrek offer him their sympathies, and they continue onward.!<
>! After some more adventures, including arriving in a fake Sigmaron, they encounter the Gaunt Summoner again, disguised as Sigmar, who offers them their eighth amulet.!<
>! After escaping the fake Sigmaron, Sornsson becomes incredibly depressed after yet another failed attempt at finding an exit.!<
>! He wants to give up entirely, believing he has nothing left to live for. He can't remember anything from outside the Silver Tower, combine with living with the fact that he has failed his oath to protect the explorer and everyone he met before Masudro, has cause to think himself curse and it's better for everyone to die.!<
>! Yet Sornsson is saved from his depression by none other than Hathrek.!<
>! Hathrek points out that Sornsson has survived all this time, so why give up now when they are so close to killing his tormentor? He also points out that the fact Sornsson is still alive means he can make a new oath, something his people no longer have the privilege of doing.!<
>! This motivates Sornsson to make a new oath. He promises to protect everyone on the team, and if he fails, he will forfeit his own life.Ironically, this makes him feel more alive than ever.!<
>! While this heartfelt moment is happening, Eithweil keeps her distance from the others while pondering how, thanks to her gift(possibly Witch-sight) she can see what the rest of her team cannot.!<
>!She can see how the Tower has been working on them. She also knows they are being followed by the Deathrunner, but decides not to tell her team for reasons.!<
>! (Spoiler alert: she is manipulated by Chaos, while the others are completely fine.)!<
>!A little later, they finally collect all the amulets.!<
>!And, to the surprise of absolutely no one, Eithweil is controlled by the Gaunt Summoner.!<
>!He proceeds to summon himself, starting a cool fight, until the Gaunt Summoner decides to run through the fist-sized hole he came from.!<
>!The group follows him, including Eithweil, who is very pissed about the whole situation.!<
>!After an awesome chase, including Sornsson trying to kill the Gaunt Summoner, being poisoned by the Deathrunner, and still continuing to fight anyway it ends with a battle against the same Ogroid they fought earlier, who is now alive again and much bigger. And probably possessed.!<
>!The Ogroid kills Eithweil by punching straight through her. (Viltrumite style)!<
>!Sornsson is saddened by her death. Despite never fully trusting her, he still feels sad that she died instead of him.!<
>!Finally, Avanius, Sornsson, and Hathrek arrive at the final chamber and the first one where they meet the Summoner.!<
>!The final phase of the battle is about to begin.!<
>!And it's already starting bad.!<
>!Sornsson becomes cooked ,literally, while Avanius and Hathrek are struggling to survive against the Summoner.!<
>!But things get even worse when Scrytchwhisker appears and almost kills Sornsson.!<
>!Fortunately, after cutting off Sornsson's arm, the Deathrunner leaves him to die, believing that he's finished.!<
>!He then tries to throw a bomb near the Gaunt Summoner, who Avanius and Hathrek are also in it's radiance.!<
>!But before the skaven could throw it, Sornsson takes him with him and throws them both in front of a statue spewing fire, killing them both.!<
>!Sornsson's death invigorates Avanius enough to defeat the Gaunt Summoner.!<
>!Now the Summoner is at the mercy of the Knight-Questor and the Darkoath Chieftain.!<
>!The Gaunt Summoner begs for mercy, promising to give Hathrek the gifts he came here for.!<
>!This tempts the Chieftain.!<
>!But Avanius begs him not to do it, telling him that he would become a monster.!<
>!He explains that he has realized that Sigmar didn't send him here to defeat the Gaunt Summoner.!<
>!He sent him here to help Hathrek.!<
>!Avanius pleads with Hathrek, even calling him a brother, saying that there is a place for him in Sigmaron. Even if Hathrek rejects him and kills him. He pleases to at least kill the Gaunt Summoner after his death.!<
>!And so Hathrek makes his decision...!<
>!He chooses the Gaunt Summoner.!<
>!And so he returns to his tribe, arriving at the exact same moment he left.!<
>!Only this time, he is changed and proceeds kill his entire tribe, including his brother.!<
>!He realizes that he has devoured their souls.!<
>!And he feels no remorse.!<
>!Instead, he laughs.!<
>!He renames himself Soul Eater and pledges his loyalty to Tzeentch.!<
>!Characters!<
>!Avanius: At the beginning, Avanius is supposed to be extremely prideful and righteous, looking down on Hathrek because of his origins as a Chaos worshipper. After Masudro’s death, however, he begins to open up to Hathrek and look past his dark past, eventually becoming one of his closest companions. Unfortunately, his initial prideful and self-righteous personality isn't developed enough. We are told more than shown that he is this way, and his change of heart happens far too quickly. In less than a chapter, he goes from trying to kill Hathrek to seeing him as a fellow human being. That feels especially rushed for someone who, only moments earlier, viewed him as an enemy.!<
>! Hathrek: Hathrek is one of the best characters in the book. His growth feels natural as he gradually becomes a reliable and genuinely good teammate, particularly when he helps Sornsson during one of his lowest moments. His developing friendship with Avanius is also one of the strongest relationships in the story. Watching the two gradually learn to trust and respect each other makes the ending all the more tragic.!<
>! Eithweil:Compared to the other characters, Eithweil is by far the most underdeveloped. Her personality is lacking, feeling so one-dimensional that she could almost come across as a stereotypical self-insert character from Wattpad. She doesn't much with the rest of cast and most the time she is just there. She also suffers from inconsistent characterization. At first, she is caring, useful, and secretive for seemingly legitimate reasons. Later, however, she becomes uncaring, smug, and even a liability. One particularly frustrating example is when she knows the group is being followed by a dangerous enemy but deliberately keeps that information from her teammates. Rather than making her mysterious, this makes her decisions feel needlessly frustrating and out of character.!<
>! Sornsson:Sornsson is an excellent character. His entire character arc does a great job showing him confronting his past failures, particularly his inability to save the people he cared about. More importantly, he gradually learns to move beyond those failures rather than allowing them to define him. His development feels earned and gives him one of the more satisfying arcs in the story.!<
>! Masudro:Masudro is intended to be the wise figure who represents the beating heart of the team—the person who holds everyone together and allows them to work as a group. Because of that, his death is supposed to force everyone else to question what they are going to do without him. That's a genuinely good idea. Unfortunately, I think he is killed far too early. His death could have had a much greater emotional impact if the story had spent more time developing his relationships with the other characters and establishing him as the team's emotional center. As it stands, the story doesn't give his death enough time to hit as hard as it should.!<
>! Scrytchwhisker: He's a Skaven, so what more can I say? Jokes aside, Scrytchwhisker is a good character despite not getting much screen time. He has enough personality to be memorable, and I generally enjoyed his presence whenever he appeared. !<
>!The Gaunt Summoner: Is probably my least favorite character. For a villain with such an intimidating presence and title, I expected someone much more eccentric and memorable. Instead, he ends up feeling fairly generic and, ultimately, rather boring.!<