Thanks, I am having a blast.
This meme is so weird to me and seemingly the other people who are actually playing this game. It seems just so out of left field. I don't think the obsessive player count posters understand that, to the people actually just playing the game, the low player count is interceptible. It's not a real problem that affects the game directly, it just affects it on a meta level regarding the health of the company that made it. It's just the only thing they can really point at because Marathon, objectively, fucking slaps. It's not perfect obviously, but it doesn't have the same kind of glaring flaws like the games that were quickly canceled or the games that we're initially received very poorly such as No Man's sky.
Marathon, unlike Concord and highgard and whatever else, is actually a very good game. That just doesn't compute to all of the people who are looking for a post-hoc rationalization of an opinion they formed long before they knew anything about the actual game. So they have to obsessively post about player counts and forcing a meme out of people simply playing and enjoying a video game unironically.
It's a manifestation of their frustration that the game is actually good and people really like it. They wanted it to be bad so it will fail, so they can mock it, so they can feel catharsis over a company they don't like failing. Since they didn't get the first part of that, they have to skip to part two without a convenient narrative to justify it. The failure of the game must serve as its own cause because to examine the real causes would be too complicated and you'd have to examine things like narrative and company reputation.
And all that is just too complicated for the average culture vulture slop-tuber making daily videos about culture war shit and ranting about DEI.