[Discussion] Can we talk about the AI hate reflex in this community?
Every single time someone posts a new indie game here, I see the same thing happen in the comments.
Within like 5 minutes someone goes "vibecoded?" and then it just spirals. Suddenly everyone's a detective. "That UI looks AI." "The art style is giving Midjourney." "LLM slop." Game's dead before anyone even looked at the gameplay.
And I just have to ask, have any of you actually played it?
Here's the thing though, this isn't new. People said the same stuff about every tool that ever changed how games were made.
When game engines like Unity and Unreal became accessible, the old guard said real devs write their own engines. When asset stores appeared, people called it lazy and fake. When RPG Maker blew up, everyone dunked on it. When drag and drop tools came out, "that's not real programming." Every single time, the community lost its mind, and every single time, genuinely good games still came out of those tools anyway.
AI is just the current version of that panic.
And honestly at this point, no one is hand coding every single thing anymore. Nobody writes their own physics engine from scratch. Nobody hand draws every texture. Developers use whatever gets the job done. That has always been true and pretending otherwise is just nostalgia.
I'm not saying AI has zero problems. Studios using it to fire artists, the training data stuff, that's all real and worth being angry about. But that's a completely different conversation from jumping someone's indie game post because a texture looked a bit too clean.
If the game is fun, does it actually matter? Like genuinely. Are you reviewing the tools or the game?
and yes i fixed my long text using AI (just for the haters who wants to hate for the sake of hating)